3 ms·
The purpose of universal credit was not to solve any particular problem - it was to give conservative politicians something to say when their voters demanded so
by mantap 7y ago
The purpose of universal credit was not to solve any particular problem - it was to give conservative politicians something to say when their voters demanded something must be done [about people on benefits].
The world makes a lot more sense when you realise that laws and regulations are primarily conceived and constructed to keep incumbents in power. Maybe we should vote in our representatives for life then they'd actually have to focus on making things better.
- SilasX 7y agoIf the system incentivizes capable people not to work and just live off taxes, that should be corrected.
- tremon 7y agoThat's a bit shortsighted. There are many valuable types of "work" in society that are not rewarded monetarily. Take for example, child rearing, community building, or caring for elderly/disabled/homeless people. Should "the system" really push capable people into valueless jobs at the cost of meaningful jobs that have no monetary value?
- SilasX 7y agoIf there is a deliberate policy decision to penalize someone for working on the grounds that "hey you would do better as a stay-at-home mom", that would be one thing; it would at least have some consistent internal logic to it. But I don't think the UK's or US's systems are like that; they just got hobbled together by being pushed in different directions by various groups with conflicting desiderata that combined to produce ridiculous incentives, and those incentives should be corrected. Moreover, to the extent that valueless jobs and valuable non-monetary jobs exist and can be identified, the proper response is to explicitly target them (either with penalties or subsidies), not just allow anti-market-labor incentives to exist because "hey, not every job is worth doing, you know?"
- M2Ys4U 7y ago>The purpose of universal credit was not to solve any particular problem - it was to give conservative politicians something to say when their voters demanded something must be done [about people on benefits]. It's both. The idea of Universal Credit is a good one - it rationalised dozens of benefits into one programme. Unfortunately the implementation is - because Tories - a terrible system that causes more problems than it solves.
- 113 7y agoBut no one involved in creating universal credit did so for any other reason than as an excuse to cut the number of people who are eligible.