2 ms·
> That's only true for discretionary spending. The article's whole point is that the real cost of a family's non-discretionary spending (Healthcare, education,
by rayiner 7y ago
> That's only true for discretionary spending. The article's whole point is that the real cost of a family's non-discretionary spending (Healthcare, education, shelter, and transportation) have gone up, to the point where they are no longer affordable on a single income.
You're overlooking that education, housing, and transportation all have a discretionary component. Having a house is non-discretionary. But having a house with 1,000 square feet per person (2015) versus 500 square feet per person (1985) is definitely discretionary consumption. Even if you say that college is non-discretionary these days (which I disagree with--somehow Germany manages with 75% of people not going to college), but all the amenities of modern colleges are certainly discretionary. (Compared to when I went to college just 20 years ago, even state schools have vastly nicer facilities and more administrative support.) And transportation isn't discretionary, but sharing cars versus having multiple cars per household certainly is.
Your argument also overlooks that two income couples were already typical in 1985, the author’s baseline year. Since 1985, women’s labor force participation rate has increased only slightly. (From 55% to 60%.) So more women aren’t working in order to afford essential expenses. About the same percentage are working. They’re just earning much more money. And they’re spending it on more consumption.
As to healthcare--the author's analysis is extremely misleading. The author compares health insurance premiums to a single man's wages. But most people who aren't on Medicare get their health insurance from their employer, and employers cover on average 70-80% of premiums. If you want to count health insurance premiums as a cost, you either need to separate out the employee-paid portion, or look at total compensation not just wages.
- vkou 7y ago> But having a house with 1,000 square feet per person (2015) versus 500 square feet per person (1985) is definitely discretionary consumption. The linked article points this very thing out. Specifically, it points out that nobody in 2020 is building 500 square foot homes, or shitty black-and-white televisions, so you don't actually have the choice to buy one. > which I disagree with--somehow Germany manages with 75% of people not going to college If every aspect of Germany society was magically transported into the US tomorrow, that statistic would be relevant. It's not, though. The American wage-earner in 2020 has to live in the America they have, not the America that they wish they could have. > but all the amenities of modern colleges are certainly discretionary. Colleges don't allow freshmen and sophomores to opt out of paying for them. > But most people who aren't on Medicare get their health insurance from their employer, and employers cover on average 70-80% of premiums. Outside the tech bubble, they don't. Great health insurance plans for normal people may cover 80% of the premium of the worker, but between 20% to 0% of the premiums of spouses/children. This only marginally changes his math.
- xyzzyz 7y ago> Specifically, it points out that nobody in 2020 is building 500 square foot homes, or shitty black-and-white televisions, so you don't actually have the choice to buy one. You can build one yourself: even if you don’t drive a single nail, you can get cheap plans over the internet, then coordinate contractors that will build it for you. This will be much cheaper than you think, in fact it will be so cheap that you’ll realize that at only slightly larger expense, you can have significantly larger house. Since people today are much wealthier than in the past, it’s much easier to foot this additional expense, which is the real reason why nobody builds small houses anymore. Think about it this way: house construction costs about $100-150 per finished square foot. Since lots of cost doesn’t really scale linearly with footage (e.g. site preparation, plans are typically fixed costs), a cost of marginal square foot is probably under $100. This means that additional 500 square feet, that is, additional two bedrooms, ends up being only $250/mo in extra mortgage payment. Since households make much real income than 40 years ago, and since interest rates are much lower than 40 years ago, people usually just decide to get these two extra bedrooms.
- vkou 7y agoWet streets don't cause rain. The reason that people are building large houses is not because they are richer. It's because the fixed costs of a house have gone up, and the marginal cost of making the house bigger are a smaller share of that pie. Yes, you get more square footage for your money. Nobody's disputing that. What you can't get, is a 1980s house at a 1980s * wage growth price. You simply can't. No such thing exists on the market. Building a 1980s house in 2020 is going to cost far more than it would have in 1980s * wage growth. When it comes to houses, the analogy is that we're living in a world where the only new cars that get built are 24-seat mini-buses that cost a small fortune. And then people come in and argue that actually, cars are cheaper than they have every been, because, sure, the minibus is three times the cost of a 5-seat sedan from the 80s, but the per-seat cost is lower than it was in 1980s, so personal vehicles have become more affordable! I don't care about the per-seat cost. The average person doesn't care about the per-seat cost. They care about the total cost of ownership.
- rayiner 7y ago