7 ms·
Does it matter? Every time without fail when I argue on HN that government involvement in tech is usually negative I get downvoted to oblivion. But then when t
by scarface74 7y ago
Does it matter? Every time without fail when I argue on HN that government involvement in tech is usually negative I get downvoted to oblivion.
But then when the same government interferes and is on the "wrong" side of popular geek opinion there is an uproar.
- Apocryphon 7y agoThat's how issues work, there are different stances that people feel positively and negatively about. People here are generally pro-net neutrality, which involves at least some FCC intervention and enforcement. It's not a blanket libertarian vs. statist situation.
- ASalazarMX 7y agothey're not incompatible: All industries have to be regulated, because they are made to make money, not to regulate themselves. When the regulator is not doing their job properly, there's the uproar. TL;DR: Government should regulate industries, but it should do it for the greater good or people will complain.
- scarface74 7y agoYes and industries only make money if they get customers to give it to them. The government should step in to counter negative externalities. For example was different phone manufacturers using different cables really enough of a negative externality for the EU to step in?
- ASalazarMX 7y ago> Yes and industries only make money if they get customers to give it to them. That only works if you have choices that aren't just the same megacorporation with different names. In reality, most people have less voting power in their wallets than it appears.
- projectramo 7y agoWait, when people disagree with you on an issue then they downvote you. However, when you are talking about the same government, when they agree with you, will upvote you? This, right here, is a broken system. People should only be able to upvote or downvote another person, but not both, whenever they are talking about the same government!
- pstuart 7y ago> the same government The same branch of the same country, but with changes in who occupies it they can be vastly different. I greatly dislike the "both sides are the same" narrative, but there were some strong elements of consistency regardless of occupant. The current administration is an entirely new beast that reflects the whims of a single individual. We are in uncharted waters now.
- homonculus1 7y agoIt is the same government. Every power the current administration has at its disposal was granted or expanded at some point in the past into what it is now. The Trump administration is not a paradigm shift toward obscene federal executive power, it has been this way for a long time. The small-government counterargument has always been "You are not going to like this new power when it's inevitably in the hands of the wrong person". That has always been ignored--the Whig theory of history ruled as enlightened new theories for social management demanded more and more centralized authority for the greater good. Now that the chickens are home to roost and someone truly offensive to the left has been elected, they are doing the world's biggest surprised Pikachu face. But the capacity for human self-deception is infinite, as for example the very same people panicking about imminent fascist takeover are simultaneously panicking that anyone other than the government has guns. So I don't believe that any event can shock the hubris out of smart people and their tidy moral rubrics.
- scarface74 7y agoWhile the last thing I want is a “War on Guns” because it will end up just like the “War on Drugs”. It will give another excuse for the government to enforce laws much more harshly on poor and minorities. But at the same time, it’s just silly to think that a reason to own guns is in case the government wants to impose martial law. We are talking about the government with the largest military in the world - with tanks, jet fighters, bombs etc. The 2nd amendment is not going to protect you from a hypothetical fascist government.
- matthewdgreen 7y agoWhat this case demonstrates is that the fantasy of government-free tech is just that, a fantasy. Governments are going to be increasingly involved in issues that only techies used to care about, and it behooves us to make sure that involvement is as benign as possible.
- Apocryphon 7y agoThis should’ve been clear to everyone from the get go, when research into electronic computers began during WWII under the aegis of military codebreaking.
- rsthjrsthrs 7y agoRealistically it's too late for that. Industries that want to be apolitical need to actually behave apolitically, one look at the circus of blatantly political employee activism at google and other big companies demonstrates that tech can't be trusted to be adult enough to accomplish that goal.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Industries that want to be apolitical Industries, pretty much without exception, don't want that.
- strbean 7y agoI'm guessing the comments you are referring to are more specific than a broad reading of "government involvement in tech"? My first thoughts were "DARPAnet, automobile safety standards, ... etc.". Reading it as "regulation of communications", I find myself leaning more towards agreeing with your sentiments.
- scarface74 7y agoGovernment should be involved when there are major externalities that the market won’t address. Most die hard free market economists would agree with that. For instance, they must regulate communications because the airways are limited and a free for all would render communications useless. The government getting involved in basic research is also necessary sometimes.