3 ms·
> 1. PGP is old and broken and messages can potentially be decrypted without access to private key GPG works. > 2. Because email's default is plain-text, in r
by baybal2 7y ago
> 1. PGP is old and broken and messages can potentially be decrypted without access to private key
GPG works.
> 2. Because email's default is plain-text, in real world conversations you end up with people replying in plain text with your whole message being quoted
Don't quote
> 3. Archived messages will leak. An e2e channel needs to have a way to inform receivers that messages should be deleted after some time
Don't archive
> 4. Private keys eventually leak, therefore it is important that when it happens, the system makes it hard to decrypt old messages (by combining it with ephemeral keys).
Delete them before they do.
The "new wave" of encryption like on from the guy calling himself Moxi Marlinspike is the prime definition of an unproven technology.
The screaming headline is because he wants to make noise, and get cred for his crowd.
His argument: GnuPG — a proven, and well reviewed technology is broken because some minor bugs were found, despite the fundamental crypto behind it still being more sound than anything else.
He then follows to say that a fundamentally less sound, complex unproven system, is a better alternative. And that even when the novel crypto messengers themselves are dogged with daily minor security bugs being found.
If I met the man in person, I would've said some warm words to him.
- cwyers 7y agoYour messages are only as secure as the least careful person you correspond with.
- inetknght 7y agoThat will always be the case though
- thaumasiotes 7y agoBut that's true no matter what methods you use. When you send a message, you don't enjoy any security at all from the recipient. If they decide to leak your messages, your messages will leak. If the way they decide to do it is by being incompetent, your messages will still leak. Look at the HackerOne reward policy for Snapchat: https://hackerone.com/snapchat https://hackerone.com/snapchat Among many less notable findings that aren't considered security issues, you can see that "screenshot detection avoidance" is a non-qualifying "bug". It's not really a bug. It doesn't qualify for a reward because your messages cannot be secured against people who are supposed to read them. Security against the recipient is (or was; I don't know the current marketing) a major marketing point for Snapchat, but it's never been something they actually offer. How is "your messages are only as secure as the least careful person you correspond with" more of an argument against PGP than it is against Signal?
- soraminazuki 7y agoThe parent is focusing on carefulness, and not malicious intent. If being careful requires you to be knowledgeable in computer security or cryptography, we're never going to have a secure communication system because people aren't going to spend years learning those things to simply talk to people. Secure defaults matter, and not being able to configure and use GPG correctly is hardly "incompetence."
- cwyers 7y agoExactly this. tptacek's article talks about issues like someone replying (with the messages quoted) in cleartext by mistake, or leaking their keys. In a messenger like Signal, there's no easy way to accidentally reply in cleartext, and key management is handled for you so it's not possible to accidentally send the private key instead of the public key. It's not enough for _you_ to never do those things, you have to trust your correspondent to be capable to do those things without error (which is different than trusting them to not intentionally disclose).
- iRobbery 7y agoExactly, and therefore i think the whole 'stop using encrypted email' is a rant that could apply to anything. Basically comes down to, you don't want people to know something, do not write it down.... not in email, not in pgp encrypted email, not in whatsapp, not even native American smoke signals....
- soraminazuki 7y ago> His argument: GnuPG — a proven, and well reviewed technology is broken because some minor bugs were found, despite the fundamental crypto behind it still being more sound than anything else. I don't think we've read the same article. Nowhere in the article does he mention a "minor bug" that can be avoided by using the latest versions of GPG. He explains in length why encrypted emails, and also GPG in particular, is broken by design. That's really two different things. I'd also hesitate to call something that hasn't reached the masses a "proven system." It's only a tiny fraction of *nix users that actually use the software.
- baybal2 7y agoWe read the same article, and you did not understand it beyond the screaming claims, and shallow statements. No, him saying it's "broken by design" is really not substantiated. SigSpoof is certainly not a design specific bug, but an implementation flaw. On other hand, the "new agey" crypto messengers mess up the protocol and the app internal mechanism hard, and that's compsci101 mistake no matter how much they gaslight that. It's them benefiting from their stuff not being subject to serious security review because of lack of adoption, not the other way around.
- tptacek 7y agoThe article is not talking about SigSpoof. The person you're corresponding with appears to have read the article more carefully than you have.
- melicerte 7y ago> Don't quote ha ha ha, seriously? Even if I don't quote, go and explain 99% of my recipients they should not quote when replying ... > Don't archive Maybe I miss to read the irony in your message, otherwise it is useless, or we don't live in the same world. But in mine, everybody archive emails in separate folders. period Fear of discarding information, especially in the business, is a great thread. [edited for formatting]
- philwelch 7y ago> Don’t quote...don’t archive The risk is that somebody else quotes or archives an encrypted email you sent.