4 ms·

Was the parent post edited? Otherwise it agrees with you. They don't mention citizenship. Surely my physical location is no less part of my data than my citize

Was the parent post edited? Otherwise it agrees with you. They don't mention citizenship. Surely my physical location is no less part of my data than my citizenships? I guess if it's being processed immediately when it's collected it's possible to gdpr it or not, but if it's an offline process, then how can you do that?

manigandham 7y ago
Yes it was edited, the part I quoted came from that comment. Anyways it's based on physical location. There are lots of specifics around what PII is but in this case: 1) your location alone cannot identify you individually, and 2) nothing specific is stored and IP/network to region lookup for applying GDPR rules is acceptable.
- scoot 7y ago
  Yes, it was edited, but only to update the linked URL, not the comment. Also, hat part of my comment do you believe that you quoted? The only quote I see if from the article I linked to in the revised comment. Incidentally, when it comes to the GDPR, the term is "personal data", not "personally identifiable information" which is a US term.
- squiggleblaz 7y ago
  My citizenship can't identify me individually. If I use a VPN that makes me appear like I'm in China, I'm still in Europe so I think my data should still be treated as if I'm in Europe. My location/residency is a matter of fact.
  - manigandham 7y ago
    1) Your citizenship is not easily accessible over the internet anonymously. You would need to hand over personal data to prove that your personal data needs to be handled different. This doesn't work. 2) The point of location data not identifying you is in response to the parent comment saying that location could also be considered personal data. It can, but only if used in conjunction with enough other data to uniquely identify you; not to just check if you're currently in the EU. 3) Using a VPN prevents GDPR enforcement if your location is inaccurate. Again it comes down to the law preventing your personal data from being used before you consent, so whether your location is a fact or not doesn't matter when the service provider isn't allowed to use it in the first place and must rely on network lookup for a best guess.

manigandham 7y ago

Yes it was edited, the part I quoted came from that comment. Anyways it's based on physical location. There are lots of specifics around what PII is but in this case: 1) your location alone cannot identify you individually, and 2) nothing specific is stored and IP/network to region lookup for applying GDPR rules is acceptable.

scoot 7y ago
Yes, it was edited, but only to update the linked URL, not the comment. Also, hat part of my comment do you believe that you quoted? The only quote I see if from the article I linked to in the revised comment. Incidentally, when it comes to the GDPR, the term is "personal data", not "personally identifiable information" which is a US term.
squiggleblaz 7y ago
My citizenship can't identify me individually. If I use a VPN that makes me appear like I'm in China, I'm still in Europe so I think my data should still be treated as if I'm in Europe. My location/residency is a matter of fact.
- manigandham 7y ago
  1) Your citizenship is not easily accessible over the internet anonymously. You would need to hand over personal data to prove that your personal data needs to be handled different. This doesn't work. 2) The point of location data not identifying you is in response to the parent comment saying that location could also be considered personal data. It can, but only if used in conjunction with enough other data to uniquely identify you; not to just check if you're currently in the EU. 3) Using a VPN prevents GDPR enforcement if your location is inaccurate. Again it comes down to the law preventing your personal data from being used before you consent, so whether your location is a fact or not doesn't matter when the service provider isn't allowed to use it in the first place and must rely on network lookup for a best guess.