4 ms·
The only way this thing could be honestly sustainable would be if it were hydrogen-powered. That might also be a prerequisite for profitability. But the airfra
by ncmncm 7y ago
The only way this thing could be honestly sustainable would be if it were hydrogen-powered.
That might also be a prerequisite for profitability. But the airframe would need to be quite different from current designs because hydrogen tankage needs a lot more room than kerosene fuel would. Extra space on an aircraft is fairly cheap to provide. What is difficult is more weight, including extra fuel needed to get enough range at higher speed. Hydrogen fuel fixes that by having 3x energy per kg.
- jabl 7y agoI'm sceptical. You'd need a lot of insulation and possibly refrigeration to prevent excessive boil off on long flights, adding weight. Also you'd want the tanks to be, if not spherical, at least cylindrical. Where would you put them? Rockets make do with minimal insulation since they can top off the tanks just before liftoff and the flight itself takes only minutes. And then there's also the thing that the climate forcing of flights is roughly a factor of 2.6 worse than the CO2 emissions alone, largely due to high altitude water vapor emissions. Switching to hydrogen would obviously not fix this.
- ncmncm 7y agoPractical aerogel production makes a huge difference in insulation effectiveness. Lifting body designs provide plenty of interior room for tankage. Spherical/cylindrical tankage is needed only to contain high pressure, but we don't need to contain pressure. The greater energy density of hydrogen means much less fuel burnt at altitude, vs. diesel. Water vapor is a grrenhouse gas, but condensed into clouds they reflect sunlight before it gets converted to IR. Not so easy to know the net effect, but the lifetime of water vapor is much less than CO2. Visible contrails suggest that condensation is preferred.
- jabl 7y ago> Spherical/cylindrical tankage is needed only to contain high pressure, but we don't need to contain pressure. You want the minimum surface area to volume, to minimize heat losses (and minimize the surface area that has to be insulated when weight matters such as in an aircraft). Spherical being the optimum, but obviously unpractical. If you look at tanks in current aircraft, typically in wings, they have huge surface area vs volume. Lifting body might be better, I'm not sure. > Not so easy to know the net effect Luckily we have researchers who have dedicated years, if not decades, to studying this exact problem. Still, not an easy problem, surely. Some quick searching turns up this overview: https://www.carbonbrief.org/explainer-challenge-tackling-aviations-non-co2-emissions https://www.carbonbrief.org/explainer-challenge-tackling-avi... (and it seems I was wrong, it's not water vapor that is the major factor)
- ncmncm 7y agoThank you, this provides a lot of detail I was not aware of. The NOx contribution argues for use of onboard LOX, which would then enable a much higher flight deck, increasing efficiency further on long-haul routes. I wonder what mechanism transports water vapor out of the upper atmosphere. Availability of aerogels radically alters the equations that have dictated tank shape for liquified gases.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoMethane is a more than viable alternative and there are a few others. Of course for both we'd need infrastructure to generate it from renewable energy (as opposed to extracting using or extracting hydrogen from natural gas). In terms of energy density, methane is good enough for space flight. E.g. the spaceX raptor engines burn methane. The long term plan for SpaceX is to use renewable energy to generate methane; which as solar & wind cost drops, might actually become cheaper than using natural gas. On Mars this will actually be the only way to generate methane as there is no natural gas there. Even just switching to natural gas would already be more sustainable as it burns a lot cleaner and there's less need for energy intensive processing of crude oil to produce kerosine (not to mention shipping oil around the globe using oil tankers & trucks powered by bunker & diesel fuel). Kerosine is nasty stuff in terms of sustainability. So, there's a path to 0 carbon for jets (supersonic and otherwise). Even compressed natural/synthesized methane gas is viable for GA and there have been some prototype planes for that. For jets, you'd want the cryogenically cooled liquid variety because it's easier to store (lighter tanks). Of course this would require the usual suspects to get off their ass and start innovating. E.g. Boeing had some plans for this https://www.wired.com/2012/03/boeing-freezes-design-with-liquid-natural-gas-powerd-airliner/ https://www.wired.com/2012/03/boeing-freezes-design-with-liq... but not much seems to be happening. In light of Boeing's recent trouble with the 737 Max, this might be worth revisiting for them. Also the blended wing concept that Airbus demoed recently would apparently be quite good for holding liquid methane tanks. Also a 60% reduction in fuel cost sounds like it should be a nice incentive. I wouldn't be surprised to see SpaceX pivot to producing jet engines at some point as it's an obvious thing to do and they seem to have a lot of competence around the logistics and technology involved with generating, handling, storing, and burning methane. In any case, SpaceX is already doing supersonic flights powered by methane every time they launch a Falcon 9 and they have some wacky notion of actually using their spaceship to enable 90 minute hops to the other side of the planet. Guilt free sustainable supersonic travel is possible but it requires people to start thinking out of the box. IMHO the first aviation company that nails this is going to do extremely well.
- ncmncm 7y ago45-minute hops, I would hope. But, yes, the upside is tremendous. Aviation has long been innovation-averse, but that could change any time.