3 ms·
One use case I don't see mentioned, though, is "I sent you an email that I think you might tamper with the contents of. By doing authenticate and then encrypt,
by bsder 7y ago
One use case I don't see mentioned, though, is "I sent you an email that I think you might tamper with the contents of. By doing authenticate and then encrypt, you might be able to claim you never got it, but I prevent you from claiming the email to be different than it is."
- lvh 7y agoYou can generally just claim that it was never signed, so you usually need some other mechanism (technical or legal) anyway. This does work the other direction (term of art “non-repudiation”), where the sender can’t claim the message wasn’t theirs or said anything other than what it said. That’s generally considered an undesirable property for messaging systems (because the privacy trade off) but as you point out there are use cases.
- AstralStorm 7y agoCrucial use cases. Official digital signatures use X.509 (including S/MIME) for this exact reason.