3 ms·
To be valid for tax and legal purposes, valuations must adhere to generally accepted valuation methodologies. In some cases, like IP, there are enumerated metho
by gamblor956 7y ago
To be valid for tax and legal purposes, valuations must adhere to generally accepted valuation methodologies. In some cases, like IP, there are enumerated methods of valuation.
Cost of creation is not a valid measure of the value of IP or intangible products generally, though it can provide a lower bound for physical products.
e San Francisco office pays the contractor, then does nothing more than immediately sell the rights to the code to the Ireland office for approximately the same amount.
The market price is what an independent third party would pay for the IP, not what your other office would pay. And what a third party would pay is based on how much they would be able to monetize the IP for in their own uses or the value they would derive from it (for example, like a process-based IP that increases efficiency).
The Ireland office could have just as well paid the contractor directly.
Maybe they could have. If the idea actually would have originated in Ireland, then they should have contracted the programmer directly, and then they would own the IP instead of the US office. But they didn't. It was the US office's idea to engage the contractor, to tell him what to program, and to evaluate the fruits of his labor. You would need to establish that the idea would just as easily have originated in the Irish office, and generally that's a very difficult to prove.
What value is the San Francisco office supposed to be adding that justifies being awarded a significant fraction of the total revenue?
Because territory matters when you're talking about sourcing income for tax purposes, especially where you're dealing with two related but legally distinct entities in different countries. There are literally millions of pages written about this (see "transfer pricing") because it has been the primary means of tax avoidance and tax evasion by multinationals for the past 3 decades. It is the primary focus of the OECD and (pre-trump) of the IRS and the EU.
Note: if both entities were in the same country, these concerns usually go away because related companies usually file consolidated tax returns (i.e., as if they were a single company), so all of this valuation crap would be rendered meaningless for tax and reporting purposes.