3 ms·
Sorry, but you don't quite understand what sexism is. A quick review is in order. For hundreds of years, women were in effect property of men. They would go fr
by wpietri 7y ago
Sorry, but you don't quite understand what sexism is. A quick review is in order.
For hundreds of years, women were in effect property of men. They would go from being controlled by their fathers to their husbands. Their legal rights were narrowly circumscribed, and their practical rights were even smaller.
This is on the decline, but the changes are quite recent. Women couldn't vote until 1920. It wasn't until 1974 that women in the US could generally get credit without a male cosigner. It wasn't until 1993 that the US fully outlawed a husband raping his wife. It wasn't until 2005 that half the law and medicine degrees went to women. And, as Fowler demonstrated, there is still significant anti-woman bias backed up by institutional power, even at newly formed companies in that most forward-thinking industry, tech.
That's what sexism is: gender bias plus systemic power leading to broad harm in a way that maintains that systemic power.
So no, there's no such thing as "sexism against men" because even if non-men had sufficient bias, they don't have the power. Most of the things you're complaining about are not "sexism against men", they're anti-sexist action, working to dismantle centuries of oppression.
Now I get that we dudes losing our systemic power is uncomfortable. Loss of privilege is still a loss, and loss is never fun. But you have a choice. You can retreat into MRA/incel lingo, become bitter over that loss, and eventually die cranky about how things were better in your day, when men ran things. Or you can decide that sexism is bad, work to dismantle it, and be pleased to see a little progress toward freedom. I know which I'm picking.
- guitarbill 7y agoWith you for most of this. But saying > So no, there's no such thing as "sexism against men" because even if non-men had sufficient bias, they don't have the power. is obviously a horrendous over-generalisation, based on otherwise rational argument you laid out. It's just that it's much, much rarer (especially when we're talking about IT). But the pendulum swinging too far the other way isn't going to help society, either. The reason why I'm even bothering to call this out is that this attitude does everybody a disservice. By all means, fight sexism when you see it, in any form. Treat all people as equal. Avoid lumping them into groups and labelling them. Maintaining that one group deserves special treatment seems equally patronising and misguided, whether that's in a negative or positive way.
- wpietri 7y agoNo, it's not an overgeneralization. Sexism is a societal system of power, like capitalism or communism or racism. It's possible to have anti-male bias, of course. It's also possible to have biased anti-male action in limited circumstances. E.g., it could be that a woman might buy a gun go on a calculated anti-male killing spree, the way that men so often do to women. But it's not possible to have anti-male sexism in our society because men are a dominant group here. Being anti-sexist in a society dominated by men means dismantling the system that gives men unequal power. (As a side note, I understand that sometimes men use "sexism" to mean anti-male bias, the same way white people use "racism" to mean anti-white bias. I'm using them here in a technical sense, the one used by most people who study this professionally. Common terms are often wrong in a technical sense. E.g., the way people talk about how much "memory" their computer has, or the many things people mean by "energy". That can be fine when speaking casually, but it also can obscure what's really going on.)
- throwaway2048 7y ago>even at newly formed companies in that most forward-thinking industry, tech. I dispute this heavily, I've worked in both tech and some traditionally other heavily male dominated industries, like construction and oilfield work. While both have their sexists, I find that the problem is far worse, and far more accepted in tech than either. Blue collar workers often just have an old fashioned view of the sexes, but tech workers often have an actively virulent anti-woman persecution syndrome, as extolled by the post above. Women I have seen go into heavy industry lines of work seem to fare far better, and face less bullshit (anecdotally of course).
- MockObject 7y ago> While both have their sexists, I find that the problem is far worse, and far more accepted in tech than either. > as extolled by the post above. The post above that was killed by downvotes? Why is HN such an outlier, and how is it holding out for so long and resisting this dominant, anti-woman culture of the tech industry?
- wpietri 7y agoIt isn't "holding out". Having used this place a decade longer than you, I'd say that it's notably better than it used to be. As you say, blatant, factually wrong misogyny does sometimes get downvoted now. Especially in a case like this, which has been prominently covered, discussed for years, and stars a well-known bad actor like Uber. But "less bad than it used to be" doesn't mean that it's good.
- wpietri 7y agoI can totally believe that. There are a lot of smart, well-meaning people who believe they couldn't possibly be entangled in a problematic system, let alone benefiting from it or even responsible for it. It has been a long time since I worked in a factory or a restaurant. But in both those environments there was a straightforwardness, a bluntness that I miss. It was often obvious that things were fucked up, and people could be quite frank about it. In tech we build things out of words to match visions. It's not shocking at all to me that it's often easier to see the vision than the reality.
- ecmascript 7y agoStop with your mansplaining already, you are the one that doesn't understand what sexism is. ;)
- wpietri 7y agoThat is not in fact mansplaining. Which you would know if you had spent more time studying what sexism actually is. For a good explanation, I recommend Kim Goodwin's flowchart: https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20180727-mansplaining-explained-in-one-chart https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20180727-mansplaining-e...
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI think you missed the smiley...
- wpietri 7y agoOr perhaps I actually saw the entirety of his one-line post and thought it was a disingenuous use of a smiley.