4 ms·
It’s not like these bulbs are flickering in a way you can perceive just by slowing it down by 2/3/4x. They’re flickering at 10000+ Hz. The reason cameras percei
by derefr 7y ago
It’s not like these bulbs are flickering in a way you can perceive just by slowing it down by 2/3/4x. They’re flickering at 10000+ Hz. The reason cameras perceive the flicker is that they take discrete samples, with an (electronic or optical) shutter in between. This creates a beat frequency with things that also flicker, in effect “tuning into” a HF flicker and “lowering it” into the visible range, the same way a superheterodyne radio tunes into a HF carrier wave and brings it down into the audible range.
- Robotbeat 7y agoFilament LED bulbs usually flicker at 120Hz (with high duty cycle) and Christmas LEDs at 60Hz (with a short duty cycle). Other LEDs are, indeed, high frequency like you describe and are perceptually effectively constant.
- vidanay 7y agoThe filament in a filament bulb doesn't fully cool down when the voltage crosses to zero, so that smooths them out a lot. Sorry...I just noticed you are talking about filament LED and not old fashioned analog filament bulbs.
- smoyer 7y agoYep ... it's the digital (meaning on-off) version of the slow moving line you see if you point your camera at a TV (or computer) screen - the speed that it happens at is the sum and the difference of the two frequencies (and perhaps at the sum/differences of their harmonics). In the CATV industry, we used to send 110 analog channels across roughly 800MHz of spectrum (54MHz to 860MHz). Other than background and ingress noise, a major source of noise (effectively) was distortion - non-linearities in the amplifiers that kept the signal at a reasonable level. Composite Second Order (CSO) and Composite Triple Beat (CTB) distortions were two values that equipment transporting these signals would generally call out - they are analogous to the summing and differencing of two signals and three signals (respectively) as described above for the lightbulb, but imagine doing that with 110 different frequencies simultaneously.
- spookthesunset 7y agoI guess you are right about the beat frequency bit, but I still assert that the cheap LED's are cycling on and off 60 times a second (or 30.... math is too hard early in the morning). That is a bit low for my taste.
- seiferteric 7y agoTake a battery, photo-resistor and a capacitor and hook up to headphones in series and you will be able to hear your bulbs flickering.
- pwg 7y agoThe 10khz+ flicker only comes about if the bulbs have a proper switching power supply (and if that switching power supply itself runs at 10khz+). But for the 'real cheap' bulbs, they likely (due to being "real cheap") have either a half wave or full wave rectifier (i.e., no switching PSU) which results in the LED's having a flicker at power line frequency (either 50hz, 60hz, 100hz, or 120hz depending upon which combination of line frequency and full/half wave rectifier is present).
- nicolaslem 7y agoNow that incandescent bulbs are almost gone, I wonder if it will become common to have wires carrying DC in the ceiling instead of every bulb having to implement the AC to DC conversion as cheaply as possible.
- andruby 7y agoThen we can also use this for our video camera’s and wireless access points. Maybe we can add network to those cables. Let’s call it “power over ethernet” ;)
- elFarto 7y agoUbiquiti has got you covered: https://unifi-led.ui.com/ https://unifi-led.ui.com/
- zaroth 7y agoI have DC powered under-cabinet lights which are definitely flickering at some fairly high rate. Imperceptible if you are just looking at it, but in a dark room if you move something quickly in front of it you can see the strobe effect.
- 205guy 7y agoBut where is the DC coming from? If it is a cheap power source (a rectifier plugged or wired into AC), the DC into the lights could be intermittent, and so cause flicker. For true continuous DC, you need a good rectifier or get the current directly from batteries.
- syphilis2 7y agoI have 960 fps video of some LED bulbs in my house. It's very apparent that some bulbs do not flicker (perceptibly), some flicker at 120Hz, and some flicker at 60Hz. At night I can sweep my eyes across the bulbs and see the dashed lines resulting from them turning off and on.
- sjg007 7y agoYeah mine do that, you can see it in slo-mo video mode.
- mrb 7y agoNo, as reported by other posters, most bulbs that flicker do it at 120 Hz or 60 Hz. This is easily confirmed by eyesight alone because 60 or 120 Hz can be perceived when an object illuminated by the bulb (eg. your hand) moves quickly in front of a dark background.
- ubercow13 7y agoSome bad LED bulbs flicker so slowly you don't even need to video it, you can just tell when you walk into the room