4 ms·
I used to glue stuff together to FDDI rings and Token Ring networks back in the day (I used Xylan switches, which had ATM-25 UTP line cards among other long-for
by rcarmo 7y ago
I used to glue stuff together to FDDI rings and Token Ring networks back in the day (I used Xylan switches, which had ATM-25 UTP line cards among other long-forgotten oddities), and MTU sizes always struck me as being particularly arbitrary.
But I'm not really sure about the clock sync limitations being a factor here. It was way back in the deepest past.
What I do remember vividly is the mess that physical layer networking evolved into over the years thanks to dial-up and DSL (ever had to set your MTU to 1492 to accommodate an extra PPP header?).
And something is obviously wrong today, since we're still using the same baseline value for our gigabit fiber to the home connections, our 3/4/5G (scratch to taste) mobile phones, etc.
- kalleboo 7y ago> ever had to set your MTU to 1492 to accommodate an extra PPP header? I had to replace my Apple AirPort Extreme when I got gigabit fiber since it didn't have a manual MTU setting and it didn't autodetect the MTU properly over PPPoE... In 2020 I still need to manually set the MTU on my Ubiquiti USG...
- hylaride 7y agoPPPoE was such an ugly mess. In its early days there were various server-side OSes (IRIX and one other I can't remember) that had piss-poor TCP/IP MTU implementations. The result was that you ran into random websites that just took forever to load as packets that happened to not fill the full 1492 limits eventually got the data through. By around 2003 i rarely encountered it anymore, but then I moved to a place with cable and never had to deal with it again.
- neurostimulant 7y ago> ever had to set your MTU to 1492 to accommodate an extra PPP header? Ah, I was always wondering why my ISP configured my fiber modem's mtu to 1492. So it's due to using PPPoE? Is there no way to use bigger mtu when using PPPoE?
- toast0 7y agoNowadays, there's PPPoA (over ATM) which wraps at a lower level, and allows 1500 byte ethernet payloads through. But running the ethernet over ATM at 1508 MTU so that PPPoE would be 1500 was probably out of reach --- when PPPoE was introduced, the customer endpoint was often the customer PC, and some of those were using fairly old nics that might not have supported larger packets. Sadly, smaller than 1500 byte MTUs still cause issues for some people to this day. It's all fine if everything is properly configured, or if at least everything sends and receives ICMP, but if something is silently dropping packets, you're in for a bad day. These days, I think it's usually problems with customers sending large packets, as opposed to early days where receiving large packets would routinely fail, but a lot of that is because large sites gave up on sending large packets.
- rcarmo 7y agoYes, PPPoA was also a thing I dealt with, and another source of irritating MTU issues.
- jburgess777 7y agoRFC 4638 provides a mechanism for this. It relies on the Ethernet devices supporting a ‘baby jumbo’ MTU of 1508 bytes and support for it is still a bit scarce. https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4638 https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4638
- mrkstu 7y agoOh, and throw IPsec and a bunch of other protocols into the mix- networking is often a fragile beast: https://www.networkworld.com/article/2224654/mtu-size-issues.html https://www.networkworld.com/article/2224654/mtu-size-issues...