11 ms·
As an user, I usually dislike these walk-through when they are forced to me and I try to finish them as fast as possible. I think a good user interface shouldn'
by speedgoose 7y ago
As an user, I usually dislike these walk-through when they are forced to me and I try to finish them as fast as possible. I think a good user interface shouldn't need them by default.
- tagspace 7y agohey speedgoose. Totally agree. You mean the ones in-platform, before you can use the product, right? Yeah, we don't like those either. This is an optional walk-through on the landing page, for those who prefer that over signing up and trying it themselves.
- lucideer 7y ago> You mean the ones in-platform, before you can use the product, right? Not the op, but I didn't interpret the comment as being restricted to certain types. I particularly dislike any walkthrough. An optional one still needs user-interaction to dismiss. Sometimes multiple interactions. A few specifics: - As a first-time visitor to a product, I have usually joined the product with an initial particular motivating intent. Walkthroughs can't typically know this intent (and optimising multiple walkthroughs for many intents would be a challenge), so you're just putting extra clicks in the way of me getting to the thing I joined for. - If walkthrough experiences were genuinely of use, they'd be integrated as a permanent product feature. Examples of things like this are Instagram / Facebook / Twitter's "discover" features. These are slightly different as they're about discovering users, not features, but the general idea is the same: a user wants guidance.
- lowercased 7y ago> An optional one still needs user-interaction to dismiss. If it's "click here to dismiss this walkthrough we just started", yes. If it's "click here to view a walkthrough", then... no? User interaction is required to start. That would be optional. If you're thinking it's the "we auto started something and you can optionally stop it" then yeah, I agree, those are often annoying.
- lucideer 7y agoIt's neither. It's "click here to dismiss this annoying message asking you about something you don't want" It's essentially the ux equivalent of an ad or newsletter popup.
- pc86 7y agoIt's definitely not equivalent to an advertisement.
- libria 7y agoThere are poor implementations of this, certainly. Is that the only way this feature could be used? Would it still be obtrusive if it were on the help/knowledgebase page? Imagine that these exist _alongside_ step-by-step documentation reachable by specific searches "How do I download in CSV?".
- Swizec 7y agoA good product walkthrough is just part of user onboarding. By the time I’m done creating an account I should already know what to do and how to get Main Benefit
- tagspace 7y agoIt's true. The problem we have though, is that there's a bit of setup involved to connect Trevor to your database, so we want to show the users the value add early as possible (even before sign up if we can)
- superasn 7y agoYes but this would make much more sense if used as help topics, i.e. "confused about how to upload your portfolio? click here for an interactive demo"
- tagspace 7y agoThis is a really nice suggestion! We could totally do that. Will run that by the team. Thanks
- aconst 7y agoThere are a few products on the market for it (I work for one, and no, it's not WalkMe). There are free solutions too (e.g. http://bootstraptour.com/ http://bootstraptour.com/ )
- andrei_says_ 7y agoNo. Show me an animated gif instead.
- tagspace 7y agoBut animated GIFs don't go at your own pace. Doesn't that annoy you sometimes? I guess a video would do the trick though
- andrei_says_ 7y agoSomething taking over my interface and locking me into its narrative, explaining instead of showing annoys me 10x more. An animated gif can loop so I can watch it twice.
- enraged_camel 7y agoProblem with animated gifs is that they are not very efficient in terms of bandwidth, especially if you need them to show UI interactions (which means you need a high frame rate).
- tsukurimashou 7y agoA good user interface is only good for people that like it, you cannot please all "populations", just try to make an interface that will be both liked by techs and HR / managers. Good luck with that.
- lunias 7y agoI agree. I hate these walk-throughs. I always skip them because they tend to be exceedingly basic and frustratingly slow. E.g. "Click on your avatar to view your personal profile". Like every other site on the internet? Thanks for that curated pro tip. The knowledge gained by sitting through the demo (and more) could be had in less time by simply using the software. I prefer to learn by doing, not watching.
- tagspace 7y agoWhat if there's some learning curve in the product. How would you prefer to receive this information? We iterate on onboarding constantly. There's a few concepts that users need to understand to get to grips with using Trevor. E.g. that queries are made up of steps.
- lunias 7y agoThe reason that I hate the guided tour is that it's restrictive. It's not at my pace and it gives me the feeling of being obstructed in my goal of learning the software; which is actually my secondary goal. My first goal is using the software. Learn by using. In the beginning just using is good enough; learning should follow naturally through use. I'd prefer to use my time clicking around the site than clicking to close tooltips and modals. I think introductory tutorials are better served by: 1. Scrollable documentation w/ images and an easily navigable sidebar that allows you to jump to specific topics that draw your attention. 2. In the case of something truly complex I like to watch videos for a more holistic perspective. Note that this is the slow and "relaxing" way of getting information. I do this primarily at night and never if I plan on using a product that same day. I'd probably recommend a video for conveying a workflow (is the fact that queries are made up of steps best categorized as a workflow?), but make it short and focused; and support it with text so that I can quickly decide whether that video is worth clicking or not. Most of what's in the video should be readable in text on the same page as the video.
- tagspace 7y agoThanks for the detailed response. Super helpful! Will run this by the team tomorrow.
- jotm 7y agoSpeaking of good UIs, I recently used not one, but two task management websites that had no tutorial (OK, no problem there) and... no tooltips for any of the textless icons. How in the world am I supposed to know what does what without clicking on them? Even then I'd forget. They were pretty unique icons, too :/ Please don't do that. Tooltips save lives :)
- zzo38computer 7y agoI agree. I don't want a walk-through. I want documentation.