3 ms·
Some countries have GAAR a General Anti-Avoidance Rule. Exactly how these rules work varies but e.g. the English law version uses a trick called the Double Reas
by tialaramex 7y ago
Some countries have GAAR a General Anti-Avoidance Rule. Exactly how these rules work varies but e.g. the English law version uses a trick called the Double Reasonableness test. This says avoidance is legal IF a reasonable person (such as a juror) thinks that any reasonable person (here a different hypothetical person that the juror may well not agree with) might think that there was some other reason to do what was done besides to avoid tax.
For example, tax free savings accounts are often mentioned as "avoidance" in this context, to suggest that it's somehow nonsense to criminalise avoidance. But saving money is a reasonable thing lots of people might want to do anyway even if there was no tax advantage.
On the other hand, a scheme in which rich people pay somebody else to pointlessly buy and sell cars at a loss makes no sense - except that they then claimed a large tax discount as second hand car dealers...
One of the cleverest parts of the English scheme is that tax advisers, who sell such schemes to the rich for lots of money, are insulated from any penalty for doing so... As long as they tell the tax authorities how their scheme is supposed to work.