4 ms·
Sure its not literally about the physical means of production, but more the abstract notion around creating/owning a bussiness. A hard problem that does involve
by bawolff 7y ago
Sure its not literally about the physical means of production, but more the abstract notion around creating/owning a bussiness. A hard problem that does involve real skill and lots of risk.
The reason you're not starbucks isn't that you can't serve coffee out of your house. Do you think that independent coffee houses don't exist? Do you think that new coffee franchises don't come into being regularly?
The reason you're not facebook has nothing to do with dmca or cfaa (relatively easy to comply with regulations). Do you think that facebook didn't have to deal with that when they started? They were hardly the first social network either so its not like they had first-movers advantage.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Sure its not literally about the physical means of production, but more the abstract notion around creating/owning a bussiness. A hard problem that does involve real skill and lots of risk. But that makes it a completely different problem. There is no longer a prohibitively expensive "means of production" causing the problem, to which a solution might have been collective ownership, but now instead a collection of barriers to entry to what might otherwise reasonably have been employee-owned businesses if not for the barriers that increase the scale required for success past what the employees can afford. > The reason you're not starbucks isn't that you can't serve coffee out of your house. Sure it is. If you can't serve it out of your house then you have to buy separate commercial property from where you live in order to start out. That dramatically increases the barrier to entry and excludes most of the prospective entrants. It also makes it that much more likely for the small entities that do exist to fail, because they have higher expenses. So you get more Starbucks and fewer independent coffee shops than you would have otherwise. > The reason you're not facebook has nothing to do with dmca or cfaa (relatively easy to comply with regulations). It's not about compliance costs in that case, it's about the regulations prohibiting a method of competition (adversarially bootstrapping from a competitor's social graph), which entrenches the incumbents. > Do you think that facebook didn't have to deal with that when they started? They were hardly the first social network either so its not like they had first-movers advantage. It's not about first-movers advantage either. It's about rules that promote scale and thwart competition, by e.g. de facto inhibiting network forks. It's why Facebook (or whoever is winning this year) has a billion users instead of there being nobody that big and thousands of independently operated community networks each with a fraction of the users. The problem isn't that nobody can be Facebook. Facebook is clearly Facebook. The problem is that there shouldn't be this much consolidation, and making your own Facebook is harder than it ought to be.
- bawolff 7y ago>But that makes it a completely different problem. There is no longer a prohibitively expensive "means of production" causing the problem, to which a solution might have been collective ownership, but now instead a collection of barriers to entry to what might otherwise reasonably have been employee-owned businesses if not for the barriers that increase the scale required for success past what the employees can afford. Startup capital is still very much a problem you need to solve to start a businesses. Its just spent on different things than people did in the 1800s
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThat's the point. What people couldn't afford then was factory machines, so the proposed solution (collective ownership) was for that problem. What people can't afford now is to scale to the entity size necessary in this regulatory environment. Collective ownership doesn't solve that -- these huge conglomerates are already "collectively owned" in the sense that everybody owns one ten-millionth of them in their retirement account. The problem is that the entity size is too large for your one ten-millionth to allow you to exercise any meaningful control over the company. So the solution now has to be a larger number of smaller companies, and a regulatory environment that facilitates rather than impedes that.
- lmm 7y agoOr a different way than companies. Perhaps if antitrust law permitted productive individuals to coordinate their interactions in other ways, running a company would not be the only way to do well.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoAntitrust predominantly applies to entities that are already too big, so what are you suggesting it's interfering with? If people can't start selling coffee out of their homes because of zoning, and can't start selling coffee out of a shop downtown because they can't afford that property in addition to their homes, I have a hard time seeing how any relaxation of antitrust is going to improve that.