2 ms·
Peer review almost never means reproducing the model, but that isn't because of the dataset (which is usually available to the reviewer) but because that's not
by nl 7y ago
Peer review almost never means reproducing the model, but that isn't because of the dataset (which is usually available to the reviewer) but because that's not what a peer review is!
A peer review isn't an adversarial process where you think that the person has done something wrong. Instead, it's extra eyes on it to make sure they have thought of everything, and to say what additional tests might be needed and why.