3 ms·
Does that mean they are shutting down? Too bad, it was an interesting company developing an interesting kite-based alternative to traditional wind turbines. Al
by musicale 7y ago
Does that mean they are shutting down? Too bad, it was an interesting company developing an interesting kite-based alternative to traditional wind turbines.
Although Alphabet apparently wasn't a great match, is Shell any better - are they really going to be an effective advocate for developing wind power as an effective competitor against their primary fossil fuel business?
- tehlike 7y agoThat's probably a corp speak, to be honest. They'll almost certainly shut it down after few months/quarters.
- marcinzm 7y agoFossil companies are trying to diversify against both short and long term oil price drops: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-09-04/shell-leads-big-oil-in-the-race-to-invest-in-clean-energy-tech https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-09-04/shell-lea...
- beering 7y agoRe: Shell, I think there's something similar playing out with automobile manufacturers and "mobility". They will honestly give it an effort, but perhaps without the clarity, expertise, or strategy that's actually needed to make it succeed in the long run. And then once it doesn't grow huge, they'll sell it, spin it off, or shut it down, because it was only ever a diversification bet, not their ambition at heart. See: GM with Maven, Ford with Chariot, BMW with Parkmobile.
- tytso 7y agoThe FT article makes it much more clear: "But Alphabet decided the opportunity to greatly disrupt to energy sector had begun to dwindle. While Makani at first felt it could provide a competitive advantage by using its technology on land and in shallow water — as well as deep water — advancements in competing technologies meant that was likely no longer the case. “That’s very sad for Makani,” Mr Teller said. “But it’s really great for the world.” An EU report published in 2018 concurred with Alphabet’s assessment. “The technology still has a long way to go before it can reach commercialisation,” it read, noting that challenges remained in demonstrating the reliable, autonomous operation that would make the concept viable." Shell is going to have to decide whether they think the risk/reward calculation is worth investing in the technology and the current staff. This sounds like it's not really different from a VC deciding not to continue with the next round of funding. Perhaps some other VC will be willing to throw in more money. Who knows, maybe the "Vision Fund II" will be willing to put more money in. :-)
- lovemenot 7y agoSpeculation: Perhaps they will eventually adorn offshore oil rigs. 600kw is not large, but could help supplement power systems offshore. It looks good for their image and seems a good fit for local conditions. In particular rigs stand-alone, so less concern with tether coming down on someone else.
- taneq 7y agoI’d imagine an oil rig is the least likely place on the planet to need complicated wind power. They flare off natural gas constantly, sticking a turbine (or indeed just a thermoelectric stack ) in there would be trivial.