6 ms·
There are two basic reasons I would select an 'advanced' language for development. 1 - can express 'weird' things that other languages would not be able necess
by pnathan 16y ago
There are two basic reasons I would select an 'advanced' language for development.
1 - can express 'weird' things that other languages would not be able necessarily express without strange gyrations.
2 - if you can develop in it, you're probably on the upper half of the developer bell curve. That brings systemic improvements in general.
- victorNicollet 16y agoFrom my experience, PHP can be as expressive as OCaml in the hands of an expert - in different ways, of course, but the end result should be fairly similar in terms of size. The problem is that PHP achieves this by throwing any kind of compile-time safety (and any kind of compile time, for that matter) to the wind. It's doing the equivalent of running around naked and shouting "I'm invisible". So, most of the time, you end up with a piece of software that's short and sweet and hopelessly brittle.
- kenjackson 16y agoif you can develop in it, you're probably on the upper half of the developer bell curve. That brings systemic improvements in general. Why hasn't this happened? Preumably if you use an advanced language you'll be a lot more productive because of the language and because you have the best developers. Why haven't we seen shops that use advanced languages just utterly clean up? "Oh, you're doing 30fps with 1m vertices -- we just did 90fps with 50m vertices -- and btw, we did this w/o using the GPU". Or "Chrome? We built a new web browser that supports every draft of every aspect of HTML5, w/ a Javascript parser that runs at twice the speed of Chrome, and we wrote a new H264/WebM codec that doesn't require a GPU and can do HD video on a 286". It just seems like for all the advantages that using an advanced language presumably gives, the software I see is simply "competitive". Maybe it will be the best in some spaces, but within the range that one would expect the best to be if everyone used C, for example. And even among those who know these advanced languages really well, we don't see them fighting for them in their organization the way one might think given all they should presumably provide. Think Norvig, Steele, Abelson, Meijer, etc...
- technomancy 16y ago> Why hasn't this happened? Preumably if you use an advanced language you'll be a lot more productive because of the language and because you have the best developers. > Why haven't we seen shops that use advanced languages just utterly clean up? "Oh, you're doing 30fps with 1m vertices -- we just did 90fps with 50m vertices -- and btw, we did this w/o using the GPU". More productive doesn't mean more performant. It means building systems more quickly, a phenomenon for which there is ample evidence. Large companies using less productive languages can still achieve great performance because they can throw lots and lots of resources at the problem, even if the payoff per head is much lower.
- kenjackson 16y agoMore productive doesn't mean more performant. Where performance matters, I'd think they'd just build codegen systems, using the advanced language. They should still have a fundamental advantage here since they could build codegen systems faster and presumably with better codegen techniques. It means building systems more quickly, a phenomenon for which there is ample evidence. So what is the evidence? Large companies using less productive languages can still achieve great performance because they can throw lots and lots of resources at the problem, even if the payoff per head is much lower. But even with small/medium sized companies you don't see this happening. It just seems like everytime someone tries to show me how some company has done something incredible with advanced languages it is really borderline. It's never, "wow, slam dunk" For example, I've never seen a Wolfenstein 3D from an advanced language. Soemthing that just blows away everything else. WordLens wasn't done with some advanced language. Google search engine. Excel. VMWare. There aren't a lot of big jumps in SW, but few, if any, seem to have come to market quickly (if at all) due to advanced languages. You'd think they'd be able to take these advanced languages and top flight devs to change the face of software. But it usually turns into arguments about how their code is less buggy or produced faster. Both hard to really judge objectively given one rarely writes the same program concurrently in two different languages. And the delta rarely seems large enough that it is obvious.
- technomancy 16y ago
- pjscott 16y agoOne more: really advanced type-checking. I've been using Haskell a bunch lately, and I've found that by the time the compiler stops snarling and hissing at me, most of the stupid little bugs are gone. That's a nice thing sometimes, even if appeasing the type system can be annoying.