4 ms·
They say "anti-nationalist" is a bad thing? Wow.
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
They say "anti-nationalist" is a bad thing? Wow.
- legolas2412 7y agoThey're calling you anti-national. Basically a traitor.
- _jgdh 7y agoFor Americans, this is identical to when Sen. Joseph McCarthy was branding people "Unamerican". The BJP have succeeded in establishing their brand of hatred and stupidity as the only valid form of patriotism.
- _-david-_ 7y ago>this is identical to when Sen. Joseph McCarthy was branding people "Unamerican". Communists want to abolish countries so saying that communists are Unamerican seems to me to be an accurate statement.
- legolas2412 7y agoI'm not sure what communists wanted to do that. Care to shed some light?
- _-david-_ 7y agoCommunists believe countries and governments should be abolished. Seeking the destruction of the American government and country is unamerican.
- legolas2412 7y agoThat has never been the communist philosophy. Communism seeks to destroy private property ownership and capitalism, because they believe that the profit generated by any business is the right of its workers, not the capital owner. They intend to do that by taking ownership of all resources and property by the state and the state managing all businesses. None of this involves abolishing countries and governments. If anything, communism involves a far more stronger sense of community, patriotism, and a much more powerful government
- truncate 7y agoWhat's worse it is somewhat synonymous to being secular, anti-hindu, or just debating whatever government does. All different things.
- friendly_fren 7y agoWhy do you think nationalism is bad?
- riffic 7y agoIt doesn't have a good track record. Nationalism in all its forms is abhorrent.
- iso947 7y agoScottish Nationalism seems to appeal to many on the left. Apparently it’s very different to English Nationalism.
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agohttps://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/an-important-distinction https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/an-important-distinction Patriotism is love for one’s country. Nationalism is the belief that one’s country (and often ethnic subset) is supreme (and more deserving of prosperity), speaking generally.
- champagneben 7y agoWould the formation of Israel be an expression of nationalism? Can it in that light be seen as the belief that one's country or ethnic group is just as deserving as others'? Or to take a more recent example of Kurdish nationalism.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoA desire for sovereignty isn't a belief that your people are supreme. The methods taken creating countries are often nationalistic though.
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agoI’m not especially familiar with those groups but I would think not. Semantics are subjective but I would tend to assume that there’s a pre-requisite that they already be in power, and yet be pushing for tripling down on those power structures. Trump’s campaign rhetoric is emblematic of nationalist themes. Anti immigrant. Playing up cultural mythos. Bragging about military capabilities. Blaming foreign nations for most problems. Implying that a return to core values will bring greatness. Lots of fear and anger. Tends to be very effective for groups of people that used to be powerful but are no longer.
- jdfellow 7y agoSince when was India a nation? It's got dozens of languages, two major religions (one of which is more of an ecumenical blending of ancient practices), and many ethnic groups and cultural norms. A nation is by definition homogeneous or nearly so across these variations. By my estimation India is an empire, and nationalism makes no sense in its context. Patriotism maybe, or political loyalty. Just seems like a weird choice of political propaganda. I do understand there's a strong anti-Muslim attitude in India, which might be what they're calling nationalism. But it doesn't seem right.
- denkmoon 7y agoWorth noting that many of those ethnic groups still suffer disenfranchisement under the caste system. Indian/Narendra Modi nationalism is Hindu nationalism.
- doyoureallytnot 7y agoI expect Parent either meant nation as a synonym for "country". nation is defined as: na•tion n. A relatively large group of people organized under a single, usually independent government; a country. n. The territory occupied by such a group of people.
- hnews_account_1 7y agoHinduism is not "an ecumenical blending of ancient practices". It has well defined rituals, rites and codes. They were simply allowed to be modified as necessary by anyone since the ancients essentially believed in freedom to appease your god as you wanted. The core of Hinduism remains the vedas, gita, the puranas and the upanishads. They lay out a very deep philosophy that theologians much more educated than I am have been investigating for centuries. It is a highly rigid system at its core (contrary to the freewheeling morass image Indians themselves have projected to appear non religious). This is why India is a nation. From the tip of Jammu till the edge of Kanyakumari, people thought of the vedas as the progenitor scripture of all civilisation. They heard the exact same stories of the Mahabharatha and Ramayana for millennia. The fact that they were free to adapt it and retell or embellish it does not mean they broke away from the system itself or that the system emerged later than the stories did.