14 ms·
They are buying more than the snacks. They are buying you time, since you never need to make office grocery runs to stock your desk. Might not be a huge deal, b
by TylerE 7y ago
They are buying more than the snacks. They are buying you time, since you never need to make office grocery runs to stock your desk. Might not be a huge deal, but elimination of chores really is a perk.
- breischl 7y agoOr you could just buy snacks at the same time as all your other grocery shopping? I guess if you literally never go to the grocery store it's a perk, but otherwise it's questionable at best.
- HenryBemis 7y agoI remember when I was working on one of the big4, whenever we were getting "snacks" we would EACH pick from a menu what EACH wanted,and EACH was getting exactly what they wanted. Some were going for the ribs, some for the salad, and we would all sit and enjoy our lunches/late dinner together. Not all perks had to do with junkfood.
- breischl 7y agoAs you said, that stuff is lunch/dinner, rather than snacks. Certainly that's a more valuable perk that some pretzels and sodas (or whatever). It's also less common.
- gaustin 7y agoI can have them delivered for very little premium. If my co-workers and I pool our orders we can reduce the impact of those deliveries (or rotating pickup), and have more choice about what snacks we get. Donut and coffee clubs (and similar) in offices have worked this way forever.
- kerkeslager 7y agoOkay, pay me the money you were going to spend on snacks and the money you were going to pay the person who you pay to fetch the snacks, and I'll go fetch my own snacks or order them off the internet to my desk. It's arguable whether it's actually a perk for me to spend 8 hours in a row at my desk, but even if we accept that claim at face value, it's still not a significant factor in any decisions I make. Perks are things you give me that I can't get for myself, like health insurance which you use collective bargaining to get a lower price on. Snacks aren't that. And while it's anecdotal, I've seen people take multiple-thousands-of-dollars pay cuts to work at places with "a better culture" where the only discern-able differences were soda in the fridge, beer on tap, and a ping-pong table or similar: all things that if you put a number value on what it's worth to you, aren't worth it. Culture does matter, but it starts with valuing your workers enough to pay them and not use irrelevant "perks" as an excuse to pay them less.
- throwaway894345 7y ago> Okay, pay me the money you were going to spend on snacks and the money you were going to pay the person who you pay to fetch the snacks, and I'll go fetch my own snacks or order them off the internet to my desk. Your office manager (or whoever) orders snacks from a contractor in bulk once a month (they don't make N GrubHub/etc individual orders every day). If they give you your fraction of that back, it wouldn't cover your GrubHub/etc order. Perks work because of these economies of scale. You can rail against the value of these perks, but "give me the cash and let me decide for myself" doesn't work.
- kerkeslager 7y agoWell I'm certainly not ordering from GrubHub either. > Your office manager (or whoever) orders snacks from a contractor in bulk once a month (they don't make N GrubHub/etc individual orders every day). If they give you your fraction of that back, it wouldn't cover your GrubHub/etc order. Perks work because of these economies of scale. What's the economy of scale on me getting up and going to get a fresh salad even when snacks are provided for free, because I value my health and sanity?
- throwaway894345 7y agoIf you don’t value it, that’s fine. No one is holding a gun to your head and demanding you eat the snacks, but your original proposition was about using that money to buy your own snacks which doesn’t work for the aforementioned economies of scale.
- kerkeslager 7y agoReally, you think buying my own snacks doesn't work? I gotta tell you, I've been accused of many things, but being unable to buy snacks is not one of them. Sure, maybe it costs me some minuscule amount of money: if that's your point you can have it. Congrats! You win that argument. My argument is: pretending that snacks are a meaningful benefit in negotiating employment is a huge loss to employees. But if you want to choose your job based on the snack benefit, have fun working for reduced wages so you can sit at your desk more.
- watwut 7y agoUnless you left all shopping on partner or parents, it is like 5 seconds to grab stuff for office too while in store. And even if your partner does it all, "honey would you buy also some crackers" is quick.
- _jal 7y agoSo close, but not quite right. You get free snacks at the office for the same reason people sitting at slot machines get free drinks - because someone wants you to stay there.
- quickthrower2 7y agoAnd get diabetes
- rs23296008n1 7y agoPlenty of companies provide fruit. Apples are not strong causes of diabetes last time I looked.
- ieRei6ae 7y agoPlenty of companies provide mostly unhealthy snacks. Also, encouraging workers not to spend time out of the building is not so healthy, physically and mentally. And it's not meant to be a perk. It's mean to keep people glued to the chair.
- rs23296008n1 7y agoGo outside. Don't eat the donut. You are not a NPC in some game. Do your thing.
- regularfry 7y agoAnd yet, on average, nudges work.
- cosmodisk 7y agoEat apples on daily basis and you'll soon see the affected on your teeth and heart. They are good source of fiber, vitamins bit also have a lot of sugar. Despite all this,they are still miles better than your average Snickers bar.
- 7y ago
- caymanjim 7y ago> They are buying more than the snacks. They are buying you time, since you never need to make office grocery runs to stock your desk. Might not be a huge deal, but elimination of chores really is a perk. Wrong. This is the complete opposite of what's happening. They aren't eliminating a chore you'd need to do. You're going to work 9-5 whether they provide free snacks or not, and you're going to snack. If they don't provide them, you're going to leave and go get them somewhere else. They're providing snacks to keep you from leaving the office. They get you at your desk longer. It's not a perk. It's a cheap way to extract more labor.
- lmm 7y agoIf your job is more fulfilling than walking to a store and standing in line (and most programming jobs are IME), then it's win-win. Company gets something they want, I get something I want, we're both happy.
- untog 7y agoNo, they’re trying to make sure you never leave the office. A walk down the street to the nearest grocery store is a nice break, but not one the company wants you taking.
- chillacy 7y agoI'm under the impression that the practice started in the bay area where the nearest grocery store is a nice 10 minute drive away.
- awalton 7y agoYou know, with the advent of Amazon and other Task Rabbitty to-your-door delivery services, did they really save me any chore here? I can get just about anything delivered to my door stop within 48 hours, why is it trouble for me to get my preferred snacks at all?