3 ms·
Doesn't seem that scathing of a criticism. I'd consider Beaker Browser (https://beakerbrowser.com/ https://beakerbrowser.com/) to be its own browser even thoug
by hombre_fatal 7y ago
Doesn't seem that scathing of a criticism.
I'd consider Beaker Browser (https://beakerbrowser.com/ https://beakerbrowser.com/) to be its own browser even though it's "just" an Electron app. Brave is another example: it's "just" Chromium. Or Firefox and Chrome on iOS: just Webkit wrappers.
You can come up with your own completely novel UI on top of a browser that is indistinguishable from "your own browser" to the end-user. Mincing words with implementation detail just seems like a tired "well actually" HN gotcha.
- kragen 7y agoBoth the Beaker Browser and Brave offer new functionality that go well beyond adding some buttons. > You can come up with your own completely novel UI on top of a browser Not if it's Blink or WebKit; they want to draw stuff with pixel-perfect control. > that is indistinguishable from "your own browser" to the end-user In https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22359642 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22359642 I list 10–12 ways that even Beaker or Brave are distinguishable from "your own browser".
- sli 7y ago> Both the Beaker Browser and Brave offer new functionality that go well beyond adding some buttons. In what way does the browser in the article not offer new functionality? The entire reason it exists is to offer functionality not found in typical browsers.
- fao_ 7y ago> Beaker Browser (https://beakerbrowser.com/ https://beakerbrowser.com/) to be its own browser even though it's "just" an Electron app The Beaker Browser actually supports other protocols than just HTTP(S). I think it's fair to be frustrated that the person in question didn't implement the engine at the core of it. That being said, I disagree with the criticism in the parent poster -- the interface seems to be sufficiently novel enough to warrant interest.