2 ms·
The clipboard can’t tell whether the content is “right” nor can the copying be done by the OS/clipboard itself. In general the application is the only thing th
by alkonaut 7y ago
The clipboard can’t tell whether the content is “right” nor can the copying be done by the OS/clipboard itself.
In general the application is the only thing that knows what is selected (e.g objects in a cad program) and the OS has no idea of how to serialize these into the clipboard.
Even a text editor has to tell the OS what is selected and the OS can only trust the app to tell the truth.
The only way to “verify it” is to show the copied content to the user (e.g in a notification after the copy). Obviously for anything but plaintext this verification doesn’t help (I can’t tell serialized cad objects from something else - it’s just gibberish). I can however verify that it’s not a script that will erase all my files when pasted into a shell (btw executing on paste is s a horrible behavior by a shell. Pasted data must be treated as untrusted and verified before acted on. Immediate shell execution breaks that).
- dredmorbius 7y agoThis is getting beyond my paygrade, though it in part depends on the OS dispaly system. There are some concepts -- and I very barely grasp this -- such as Display Postscript, not in present use AFAIU, which might offer such capabilities within the windowing system. That is, with DPS the display itself would have awareness of both the underlying text and the formatting directives. Whether that's even remotely similar to existing graphical systems, I've no idea. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Display_PostScript https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Display_PostScript
- alkonaut 7y agoIn the most general case (and more commonly than it ever was) each app is just a rectangular area where it renders using gpu hardware with. This used to be how games rendered but now even shells and text editors are getting there. If one has to manage this case too then basically the only places one can copy from are in the compositor (images ie screenshots) or from apps. Even when text drawing is passed through the OS (or platform libs e.g GDI on windows) it’s difficult to imagine APIs where the OS would know what is “selected”, ie what should be passed to the clipboard.