5 ms·
I really don't understand this. A career in software is one of the most pampered and lucrative ones I can think of. Due to the shortage of software engineers, w
by echelon 7y ago
I really don't understand this. A career in software is one of the most pampered and lucrative ones I can think of. Due to the shortage of software engineers, we can go anywhere and get a job instantly.
The only downside I can think of is ageism, but then again, I have colleagues in their 50s and 60s where I work. But I suppose this isn't universal. (I'm in Atlanta and we have a lot of older workers. Age doesn't seem to be a thing here.)
Yes, we're underpaid for the value we provide, but we're paid a hell of a lot more than most people. We have the flexibility to find new work or create our own businesses.
Why introduce a new level of politics and collective bargaining? I don't want to pay union dues. If I don't like where I'm working, I'll go somewhere else.
Can someone explain why I should want this? (Or why I should empathize with those who do?) I don't understand it at all.
- dangus 7y agoJust look at their employee reviews. The management there seems toxic. I implore you to also think twice about the way in which you are demonizing unions. Sure, some unions aren’t the best, but what you’re saying is 100% discounting the benefits that a union can bring to employees. Union dues can more than pay for themselves in wage negotiation. They can restrict overwork, unpaid overtime (see the special salaried overtime exemptions that IT employees and teachers get enshrined into US law), and unsafe working conditions. Sure, unions have bureaucracy, but they have bureaucracy that is incentivized to increase outcomes for the employee and not the employer. You are directly paying the union to represent and fight for you. The “go work somewhere else” solution isn’t an equitable or realistic solution for many employees. That often equates to “I can go work somewhere else that’s just as shitty.” Sure, life is nice for many tech employees right now, but what happens when the supply/demand situation inverts? Tech employees often also have a very bad habit of pretending that more poorly compensated areas of their own company are enjoying the success in the same way. Ask someone in support or a junior graphic designer about what they think about the prospects of “working somewhere else.”
- ApolloFortyNine 7y ago>junior graphic designer I don't think anyone says tech employee and is referring to graphic designers/anyone in that area. 99% sure anyone who hears tech employee is thinking software development. EDIT: How on Earth can anyone downvote this statement? If you ask 10 people to name 10 tech companies, not one of them is going to pick a game studio.
- jkaplowitz 7y agoGraphic designers work at most tech companies I've worked at, and I've never worked at a game studio. They definitely can be classified quite reasonably as tech employees. Also, here in Montreal, most people's list of well-known local tech employers would absolutely include at least one or two of the many game studios here.
- ApolloFortyNine 7y agoBe honest here. What percentage of employees at Google/Apple/Microsoft do you think are "graphic designers", and what percentage are "software developers"? Your argument to create a union is that the 1% of employees need protection. Honestly I agree video game industries could use a union. But the presence of a graphics designer at Google does not mean every employee needs to unionize.
- jkaplowitz 7y agoGoogle has more software developers, no doubt, but still far more graphic designers than you seem to expect. No, every employee at Google does not need to unionize. CEO Sundar Pichai certainly doesn't. But lots of Googlers have long wanted a union for good reason, including software developers. I would have happily voted yes in a union election when I was there, despite being a software developer myself. I know of plenty of examples of misbehaviour and other harmful actions by Google toward software development employees, a number of which have been publicly reported. And the situation seems to have gotten worse since I left. To be clear, Google is far from unique in this regard, and it's still probably a better employer than many of its peer companies. That just underscores how severe and widespread the problem is.
- Nuzzerino 7y ago> The “go work somewhere else” solution isn’t an equitable or realistic solution for many employees. That often equates to “I can go work somewhere else that’s just as shitty.” Bingo. I've worked at enough places to know that the greener grass myth is indeed a myth in the industry. That doesn't mean you can't get a better job, but there's always a very real risk that things will be worse at your new job.
- nerdponx 7y agoThis, plus in the USA you can't quit your current job without another one lined up, because your access to healthcare is dependent on employer-sponsored health insurance. Especially if you already made enough money for the year that you don't qualify for a program like Medicaid or state-sponsored subsidies.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- briandear 7y ago> Union dues can more than pay for themselves in wage negotiation. Those negotiations can also drag down your salary potential as well. You get paid what everyone else gets paid. If you warm the chair longer, you get paid more, regardless of any innovation or extra value you bring to the business. You have incentivized mediocrity because what’s the point of doing anything beyond the minimum requirements? It isn’t like you’re going to get a raise for being especially clever.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- manfredo 7y ago> Sure, unions have bureaucracy, but they have bureaucracy that is incentivized to increase outcomes for the employee and not the employer. You are directly paying the union to represent and fight for you. No, they have bureaucracy that is incentivized to increase the influence and power of the union leadership. You are directly paying the union to represent the union's interest, which may or may not align with your own. E.g. a motivated, capable teacher has a portion of their salary deducted and spent on defending seniority based pay even if said teacher is in favor of performance based pay. The union directly acts against the desired of the employee.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- maire 7y agoThe bigger issue is going from Salaried to Hourly employees. I assume (but don't know) that you need to be hourly in order to unionize. I have been at a bunch of companies that reclassified employees from salaried to hourly. This always came after a single employee filed a lawsuit. It almost never impacted developers, sometimes impacted QA and often impacted other development support employees. I have never seen an impacted employee like it because they could not participate in stock options. I was only at companies with lucrative stock options. If a company had poor stock options then I could see that somebody might like the change.
- jkaplowitz 7y agoYou don't need to be hourly to unionize. Salaried employees can do that. The exclusion is based on meeting the definition of supervisor, not by the payroll category.
- ditonal 7y agoWhy do people on HN constantly claim that companies are right to consider “a false negative is better than a false positive”, act like insane interview gauntlets are normal and desired, AND claim that people can easily change jobs? It’s not true. I live in the SF Bay Area, have worked as a SWE for 10+ years including at top companies like Google, and changing jobs is NOT easy and I’m sick of the implication it is. There are also a LOT of younger kids on HN who have never worked through a recession. Finally, just because you make an ok salary doesn’t mean a political voice is worthless. Why do doctors have the AMA? Engineers desperately need to stop boxing themselves out of the discussions, we absolutely need to organize, badly.
- qzx_pierri 7y agoYou sound spoiled, but go off
- jschwartzi 7y agoI graduated 11 years ago when they were firing teachers because the school districts were going bankrupt. I had to take a job clerking in a warehouse to make ends meet. That was a lesson that all my prospects could go sour in a matter of a couple of months. So please tell me how I had an easy time because I'm an engineer now.
- wbronitsky 7y agoI'm always amazed that when people ask for dignity, respect and the ability to have agency in their own life, other people feel the need to put those people down, call them "spoiled" and assert that life is just fine for everyone, thank you. What I usually can't figure out is "why". Do you own a company? Are you part of management? Do you think that life should stay as it is and not get better for everyone? Genuinely curious.
- dang 7y agoPersonal attacks will get you banned here. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and take the spirit of this site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- Nuzzerino 7y ago> I really don't understand this. A career in software is one of the most pampered and lucrative ones I can think of. Due to the shortage of software engineers, we can go anywhere and get a job instantly. There are dozens and dozens of threads on this site about the cancerous software engineering interview techniques in widespread use in the industry. Despite having 15 years of experience and a lot of accomplishments under my belt, I still had a bad streak a few years back where I had to interview 30 times before getting an offer. So I have to say it's a fallacy to make this kind of claim.
- refurb 7y agoYou think a union is going to fix the interview process?
- Apocryphon 7y agoWhy couldn't it be a potential tool towards addressing this problem? Will the status quo of angry blog articles posted to HN and Blind do any better?
- username90 7y agoUnions tend to put up more barriers to entry, not remove them.
- Apocryphon 7y agoThis is an industry founded upon the principles of innovation and invention, is it not? Perhaps tech can invent a union that can overcome issues found in the unions of the past.
- Nuzzerino 7y agoAh, the good old "those corporate boomers elsewhere are uncreative and therefore we'll beat them easily" trope. It's certainly possible, but I have doubts that the generation of scrum teams and open-space offices will solve unions. Innovation is hard no matter who is doing it, and most of the "innovation" seen in the valley is just applying existing solved problems to economies of scale, made possible by advancements in the supply chain (such as the SaaS paradigm).
- karatestomp 7y agoWell, for one thing, the good times won't last forever. Now's the time to prepare for the bad—it's much harder to organize when you're weak. For another, despite our compensation we're still much weaker at the bargaining table, individually, than our employers. See how casually so many of them reject applicants just to make sure "false positives" don't get through the hiring pipeline. I'm not saying they shouldn't do that—it's not my point—but it's definitely a sign of who's setting the terms of these interactions, and where the power is. And it'd be incredibly unusual if that weren't the case, as the overwhelming norm is for employers to have a huge advantage in labor negotiations versus individual workers, even if circumstances are currently such that those workers are paid a lot of money. And then, software development and related jobs are not all at FAANG, or even close to that. Many of those working in software aren't negotiating, individually, from a position even a little better than a "normal" office worker. Probably most, in fact. There's a whole world of software developers out there beyond SV, Seattle, and New York—the average state of a worker in our industry, even just in the US, is probably much closer to the norm outside those places than in them. It's also a proven avenue for putting a stop to all sorts of abuses that exist due to the uneven power of workers and employers, not just direct compensation. Lots of non-California workers in tech are under badly disadvantageous employment agreements, but without working collectively, either through unions or government, against them, they're so common that resisting them carries high individual risk and a low chance of benefiting anyone else who's in an even worse position to resist them. That flexibility to work or create our own businesses you bring up? Yeah, that could be assured for non-California, non-public-figure-rockstar developers, too, through union negotiations.
- majormajor 7y ago> For another, despite our compensation we're still much weaker at the bargaining table, individually, than our employers. See how casually so many of them reject applicants just to make sure "false positives" don't get through the hiring pipeline. I'm not saying they shouldn't do that—it's not my point—but it's definitely a sign of who's setting the terms of these interactions, and where the power is. And it'd be incredibly unusual if that weren't the case, as the overwhelming norm is for employers to have a huge advantage in labor negotiations versus individual workers, even if circumstances are currently such that those workers are paid a lot of money. At the handful of places I've been, those "reject heavily" decisions are driven by engineering, not by HR or CEO. HR often gets upset about the low offer rate, since it's not all that much fun for a recruiter to see so many people they bring in get rejected, or for a CEO to see "we need more people" as a continuing excuse for why stuff isn't getting done but also see people constantly rejected by the engineering managers. Compensation decisions are a different beast, of course, and there a union could be much more helpful, but I would worry some about it introducing more of a "just throw more people at it" mythical-man-month thing.
- pastor_elm 7y agoMost of the people that work there probably aren't software engineers.
- dunkelheit 7y agoSome things other than salary to consider: open-space offices, unpaid overtime, increase in managerial oversight (pointless standups etc.), erosion of work time/free time boundary, onerous non-compete/intellectual property clauses in employment contracts. Everybody is constantly bitching about those things but despite the claimed shortage of software engineers they seem to only get worse with time. I don't claim that unions are the solution but these problems don't seem to magically resolve themselves either.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoYou say "increase in managerial oversight", but then mention standups. That's about the least onerous oversight possible. I understand not liking standups, but... that's not at the level of excessive management oversight. Excessive management oversight is a whole different level. (And yes, I know, standups can be part of that whole different level. That's the one you specifically mentioned, though. If that's the excessive management that most grates on you, you don't have excessive management.)
- dunkelheit 7y agoSo, do you agree that managerial oversight is increasing or not? Of course standups can be helpful and unobtrusive, but they also often degrade into shamefests with the sole purpose of forcing everybody to conjure up reasons why they are not done yet. And of course I agree that they are not the most annoying thing possible. Let's wait a few more years until something like DingTalk (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17678571 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17678571) becomes popular in Western companies.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoManagerial oversight is increasing as a general trend? I have no data one way or the other. Standups increase managerial oversight compared to not having them? True... as far as it goes. The thing is, management is going to make decisions based on something. Having them make decisions with no data leads to bad outcomes, so they've got to get the data somehow. If you've got a way for them to get the data that's less intrusive to workers' time than standups, I'd like to hear what it is. (Seriously. I've got standups now, and if you've got a better way, I'm not above copying it.)
- ksr_throwaway 7y agoSometimes it's not all about money. People in the bay area may not understand that most people working at Kickstarter truly believe in the company's mission. The money is not great and we've been willing to accept that to feel like we're making a positive change in the world. Unfortunately upper management has used this (as well as Kickstarter's reputation) as a bargaining chip to treat employees poorly. Source: I work at Kickstarter
- commandlinefan 7y ago> we can go anywhere and get a job that's exactly like the current one.
- buzzkillington 7y ago>Yes, we're underpaid for the value we provide, but we're paid a hell of a lot more than most people. And compared to Africa everyone in the US is overpaid. Janitors are welcome to try and raise their wages too. I will not lower mine on their behalf.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- notJim 7y agoAs others say, one reason is that busts happen. I was reading the union contract for one of the local government unions (like you do…) the other day, and noticed they had a lot of provisions related to lay-offs. How much severance people get, how it's calculated, how it's decided who gets laid off, etc. This kind of thing would be very valuable if there's ever a tech bust. The other thing is that not everyone experiences the supposed benefits of these careers. I talk to a lot of people who are exploited in the tech industry with long hours and salaries that aren't really that high for the high CoL we deal with. Talk to bootcamp graduates about their job experiences some time. PoC and women also report rampant discrimination—lower salaries for the same work, sexism, organizations providing cover and golden parachutes for harassers. Finally, think of all the issues that we gripe about here on HN: - Open office plans - Horrible and overly-demanding hiring processes - Lack of transparency or consistency around promotion processes and salaries Fixing these types of issues are bread and butter for unions.
- pathseeker 7y ago>This kind of thing would be very valuable if there's ever a tech bust. Not if you're a top performer who switches jobs to find new interesting things. If you look into the details of the "who gets laid off", it's very frequently just all of the newest members of each department.
- triceratops 7y agoBy your own logic, if you frequently switch jobs to find new interesting things, don't the odds of you ending up on a layoff list go up?
- HeroOfAges 7y agoAs someone posted previously, would you consider the possibility it's not the software developers that are leading the push to unionize? Perhaps there are people occupying roles in the company that don't pay as well or roles that aren't considered as valuable. Could it be that they feel they should be compensated on par with their software developer counterparts? edited for grammar
- nitrogen 7y agoI don't understand it at all. I'm kind of in the same boat, though I actually kind of lean toward some kind of organizing. Those I know who are members of a national union complain about the union spending most of its money on things unrelated to the employment of its members. But at the same time professional organizations like the AMA and ADA seem to benefit their members (unfortunately sometimes at the expense of the public). I think the questions to ask are what's the bigger picture? What is the framing used in the current discussion to limit our view of that bigger picture? Who is doing the framing? I don't have answers there, but it definitely seems like there's some important hidden variable that is omitted from the framing of either side of this debate.
- standardUser 7y ago"The only downside I can think of is ageism" "Yes, we're underpaid for the value we provide" Seems like you came up with another downside in pretty short order. I believe you can come up with even more if you peruse the comments here.
- HeroOfAges 7y agoWhy do you assume software developers are leading the push to unionize? All we know is that Kickstarter employees have voted to unionize. The majority of Kickstarter employees don't write software. My cynical take is the non-dev employees feel they're not getting what they deserve in the form of let's say salary. Perhaps they would like compensation closer to or on par with the software developers at their company.
- carapace 7y agoI've already mentioned this twice in other comments here, so I feel like I'm overdoing it, but I'm sincerely interested in your (and others') opinions: About six years back it came out that the big tech companies were conspiring against their own employees: https://pando.com/2014/03/22/revealed-apple-and-googles-wage-fixing-cartel-involved-dozens-more-companies-over-one-million-employees/ https://pando.com/2014/03/22/revealed-apple-and-googles-wage...
- themagician 7y ago“A career in software is one of the most pampered and lucrative ones I can think of.” Yeah, when you are in the top 5%. I’m not sure you realize just how shit most tech jobs are. Not everyone gets $300k a year in stock. Most people get nothing. You don’t want it because you are in the top decile. That’s the same reason that everyone who is in the top decile of anything doesn’t want change. This is for the 90%, not for you. You shouldn’t empathize. You should oppose this because it will ultimately hurt you.