4 ms·
> It pains me to come to the conclusion that in Facebook, we have created something that should not exist: an addicative worldwide mob where peddlers can sell e
by ekianjo 7y ago
> It pains me to come to the conclusion that in Facebook, we have created something that should not exist: an addicative worldwide mob where peddlers can sell emotionally manipulative ideas to the people least able to handle them,
Or maybe, alternate world view, it does not even matter as much as you think it does.
- authoritarian 7y agoPeople dying of starvation and homelessness doesn't matter to many people but that doesn't mean it doesn't have a negative impact on society or shouldn't be solved
- ekianjo 7y agoHow is that comment related To Facebook ?
- DanielBMarkham 7y agoIt doesn't really matter. At scale, 3% is huge. We keep having these discussions about the impact of social media as if the relationship was directly causal, ie Zuck pushes a button and robot people do his bidding. Wish the problem were so easy. It's at scale, dealing with fractions of percentages over thousands of randomly subsegmented markets, nobody knows what the hell is going on. It's incomprehensible by any human. What we know is that people pay billions of dollars to advertise there. We know that most of the world's population (!) has signed up. We know that people who quit feel better. We can observe people doing and saying things with other people at a scale never seen before. In fact, that's one of the selling points. We know that more and more studies are showing addictive and maladaptive behavior from people who spend a lot of time there. We're not trying to convict FB in a court of law or inventing some new science. The preponderance of all the available evidence says that there's a major social change at work worldwide that has at least some deleterious effects. Works for me. Any small number times a billion is a big number. That's the entire business model of social media. You logically can't deny the way social media works in order to make a defense of social media.
- Dumblydorr 7y agoIt does matter, look at who is in power after democratic elections where FB aided and abetted foreign nations to lie and deceive voters.
- stuaxo 7y agoParties within countries were able to manipulate elections, see the UK, with the vast avalaunch of deceptive ads where Cambridge Analytica were involved - circumventing limits on election spending.
- ch4s3 7y agoAs much as I dislike FB I think this gives their ad platform far too much credit. How do you go about connecting ads viewed to votes, or even poling data? Of those views how many users engaged with the content?
- take_a_breath 7y agoSome people are obviously making a connection between the two or else there wouldn't be political spending on Facebook.
- ch4s3 7y agoCampaigns and PACs spend money on all kinds of useless things. The burden of proof is on the people claiming that Facebook ads are uniquely malevolent and effective. This is also not to mention that the money spent on Facebook pales in comparison to other channels. From my perspective, it has all of the hallmarks of a moral panic, right down to the calls to "think of the children."
- take_a_breath 7y ago==Campaigns and PACs spend money on all kinds of useless things.== Do you have a citation for this? It seems like a failure in the free market if organizations spend $55 billion [1] on Facebook advertisements with no benefit. ==From my perspective, it has all of the hallmarks of a moral panic, right down to the calls to "think of the children."== What data is that perspective based on or is it just your gut feeling (aka bias)? [1] https://martechtoday.com/despite-ongoing-criticism-facebook-generates-16-6-billion-in-ad-revenue-during-q4-up-30-yoy-230261 https://martechtoday.com/despite-ongoing-criticism-facebook-...