3 ms·
This article seems to be interpreting any attack on "toxic" masculinity as an assault on masculinity in general. Things we consider "toxic masculinity" are (fo
by olliej 7y ago
This article seems to be interpreting any attack on "toxic" masculinity as an assault on masculinity in general.
Things we consider "toxic masculinity" are (for example)
* Sexism and misogyny - that is women are less than or inferior to men, and should be focused on serving them.
* Violence is a reasonable response to being upset
* Men who aren't sufficiently "masculine" (often defined in terms of the above), are also lesser
* Women who aren't sufficiently "feminine" need to be put in their place (understand who's in charge, and who they should serve)
Are there a few idiots who go beyond that? yes. Just like there are idiots who go bizarrely far on any other topic.
But attacking toxic masculinity is not attacking masculinity. It's not attacking men and boys.
If you feel attacks on toxic masculinity are attacks on you fathers/husbands/sons maybe there should be some thought about what about their behavior overlaps the above, and whether you think that's ok?
- forgottenpass 7y ago>If you feel attacks on toxic masculinity are attacks on you fathers/husbands/sons maybe there should be some thought about what about their behavior overlaps the above, and whether you think that's ok? My favorite part of social commentary these days is how it's layered in "I'm not poorly conveying a point, you're hearing me wrong and/or you're the problem."
- belorn 7y agoPeople who use the term "toxic masculinity" will always be perceived by others as wailed misandry, just as "toxic [target demographic] would get perceived as some form of wailed -ism. Bringing an association between a strongly negative stereotype of an a demographic is an invitation for harm. A litmus test I often use in politics is to switch the target demographic of a negative stereotype with one of the opposite side of the political spectrum. It usually show if a phrase, term or statement is acceptable or an -ism. In the case of feminism, switching the target demographic of "men" with "immigrants" and "women" with "natively born" works pretty well. Someone talking about "toxic immigrants", listing points of negative stereotypes of immigrants, and it would enlist feelings of racism. One can have a level discussion about crime, theft, murder or rape, but if it get associate directly to a discussion about toxic immigrants then what people see is racism. People can write "It's not all immigrants!" as much as they want and it won't change a thing. People will see it as an attack and rush to defend themselves. The only thing talking about "toxic masculinity" results in is harm, as has been demonstrated every single time it get discussed here on HN.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- philwelch 7y agoYou’re not fooling anyone.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't react to a comment by breaking the site guidelines, no matter how wrong it is or how strongly you feel about it. Instead, reply substantively and respectfully, or don't reply. I know how hard the latter can be sometimes, but it's preferable to posting like this. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- philwelch 7y agoYou’re right. I’m sorry.
- Craighead 7y agoThere's literally nothing unreasonable about what was written.
- blotter_paper 7y agoYour comment seems to be assuming bad faith. This is not helpful for a discussion, nor does it add anything to it. My own problem with GP is that they claim "attacking toxic masculinity is not attacking masculinity", but I don't think the people using this term would defend similar language if the genders were reversed. If we called stereotypically bad feminine traits "toxic femininity" it would be called out as sexist. Indeed, it is[0]. I can't imagine most racial descriptors would fair much better. "The limits of my language are the limits of my world," and we shouldn't be surprised when attaching a descriptor of a subset of humanity to a negative term sparks backlash. It seems like we face this general problem where it's shitty to use group descriptors for negative behavior, but sometimes groups of people are disproportionately responsible for some subset of negative behavior, and we've traditionally been more willing to attach negative terminology to oppressed groups, but now some of us are simultaneously realising that was a shitty practice and deciding to attach negative descriptors to the oppressive groups instead... which is kind of understandable, since those groups have been oppressive, but we're still dealing in broad group identities that encompass some individuals who have behaved less oppressively than other individuals who fall into less oppressive group identities, and using group identities as a linguistic weapon in this way is sort of obviously going to engender mistrust and negative reactions. So, maybe it would be more helpful for the dialogue if we found linguistic constructs that didn't pair "man-" or "male-" with some harmful follow-up. If we find ourselves in a situation where it is useful to discuss the intersection of group identity and negative behavior, it might be nice to slow down and say exactly what we mean rather than calling it "toxic masculinity" and then being surprised when this is taken as an attack on men. That said, I do agree that GP's subpoints are actual issues which we should address. I just have serious reservations about this language. [0]: https://geekfeminism.wikia.org/wiki/Toxic_femininity https://geekfeminism.wikia.org/wiki/Toxic_femininity
- thu2111 7y agoattacking toxic masculinity is not attacking masculinity Yes it is. It's an inappropriate and offensive term to use. The lady who wrote the article is correct to be upset about it on her son's behalf. Precision has value. If you're upset about violence, complain about violence. If you're upset about someone praising physical strength or other classical aspects of manhood, respond to that specific argument. Don't use sweeping, general terms phrased in deliberately ambiguous ways that collect anything "masculine" under one roof. The simplest way to see you're wrong is to ask yourself how you'd feel if it suddenly became common to write op-eds in major media outlets on the topic of "bitchy women" and how "bitchy women" are a widespread problem that all women need to step up and fix. I think you'd find it troubling.