3 ms·
I concur. The American Transcontinental railway system had it's foundations laid in a time where full electrical generation and distribution were not by any me
by salawat 7y ago
I concur.
The American Transcontinental railway system had it's foundations laid in a time where full electrical generation and distribution were not by any means solved problems.
Furthermore, the safety issues that would come with trying to use any of the previous rail infrastructure, (which one would be mad not to given how much of it there is) would make things nigh impossible to make work safely given the fact there is quite literally nothing separating people from the tracks. Which is not something would worthwhile to have to implement everywhere given that would consume far more energy to establish than it would save in operation for a very long time.
Also, China's "high speed" rail formula is great for moving people around, but definitely not a regime you want to have to design around for freight. Freight is generally far more massive/dense than the same volume of people. Acceleration of that load to/from excessively high speeds is an engineering nightmare. Not impossible, but definitely expensive.
That's just the points I can think of off the top of my head. I'm sure someone in the industry would have more insight than I.
- rbanffy 7y ago> Acceleration of that load to/from excessively high speeds is an engineering nightmare Apart from reusing the same rails of passenger cars, there is no need to accelerate freight to high speeds - it can comfortably cruise at the most efficient speed. Also, if the freighters have onboard batteries, not all of the railroad needs to have external power supplied by overhanging cables. Add regenerating brakes and the trains will be able to charge themselves every time they are going down a slope.
- tomatotomato37 7y agoI can't imagine upgrading the US freight rail system with basic catenary technology to be that expensive. You don't really need all the fancy tensioning technology and stuff for a train that goes above 50mph maybe once a month; an offset electric pole would be enough. It's not that much more a safety issue than the 50 year old wooden electric poles we already have running mains voltage all over the country. Also in contrast to passenger services the US frieght system actually has a lot of money being thrown around so it'll be able to afford it. That being said I still think this article is a bit of a shill piece. Reinforced glass windshields aren't going to affect shit, especially when they are already mounted 6 feet off the ground and thus out of range of most kicked up road debris.