6 ms·
It's a good question about something that is probably not a coincidence! But immediately moving to speculating about a conspiracy theory seems like hiding a goo
by skybrian 7y ago
It's a good question about something that is probably not a coincidence! But immediately moving to speculating about a conspiracy theory seems like hiding a good question with a fake answer.
It seems better to keep it unanswered and remain curious.
- gpm 7y ago"Conspiracy theory" is an exaggeration. Lots of things rocketry related are covered by ITAR and are not allowed (by law) to be shown to non-green-card holders. SpaceX is pretty careful to comply with ITAR restrictions. It would not surprise me in the slightest if the US government had decided that satellite deployment mechanisms were one of those things covered, or if SpaceX's legal department decided that they weren't sure they weren't covered.
- DEADBEEFC0FFEE 7y agoIf that were true, they would simply say as much. What possible advantage would there be to offer a bullshit reason? A far more likely reason is that it's technically hard, and/or not a priority.
- gpm 7y agoI tend to agree, but that doesn't mean keeping quiet about ITAR is "conspiracy theory" level of ridiculousness. Possible advantages could be avoiding looking like they are putting pressure on the US government to change it, avoid getting into debates about whether or not ITAR prohibits it, avoiding looking like they are a workplace that is heavily bogged down by security clearance issues, etc.
- madamelic 7y agoYeah, I totally have to agree. They have repeatedly cut streams and stated they aren't allowed to show the payload deploying.
- ColanR 7y agoI don't think it's intellectually honest to label something as a conspiracy theory and brush it aside without discussion.
- skybrian 7y agoI said "conspiracy theory" when I should have more accurately said "to keep a secret." But it's still just a bit of speculation; we don't know that there is a secret.
- elif 7y agoDoes "Unfounded speculation about an organized effort to deliberately mislead the public" do more justice to the subject?