4 ms·
Aviation looks like the industry least likely to go green to me. I doubt electric planes are ever going to be viable for anything other than a short hop which w
by tonyedgecombe 7y ago
Aviation looks like the industry least likely to go green to me. I doubt electric planes are ever going to be viable for anything other than a short hop which would be better done by train. Synthetic fuels sounds interesting until you look at how much fuel they consume.
The trend is quite obviously in the wrong direction: https://www.statista.com/statistics/655057/fuel-consumption-of-airlines-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/655057/fuel-consumption-...
It's often quoted as 2% of global emissions, my (admittedly back of the envelope) calculations come out 50% higher without the cost of burning it at high altitude nor refining the fuel nor the infrastructure on the ground to support air travel.
My guess is emissions from air travel will continue to rise as the world develops and they will take an increasing share of the total as other sectors decarbonise.
This all leads on to political problems, how are you going to convince the poor to reduce their emissions when they see their rich neighbours jetting across the world on holiday.
- stingraycharles 7y agoI think it’s important to look at this from a different angle: sure their requirements are high, and they may not be able to go completely green in a short timeframe, but should we therefor not even attempt it? It’s not difficult to imagine a hybrid system at some point in the near future, and/or other ways of reducing the carbon footprint. Focus on those positive things, rather than “this will never be completely green, so why bother?”
- tonyedgecombe 7y ago“this will never be completely green, so why bother?” You are putting words in my mouth, I never said that. The industry has been reducing emissions per mile pretty much since it was founded. Looking at that graph I posted it is having the opposite effect to what we want. Jevon's paradox and all that. My personal solution was to stop flying, I haven't got on a plane for 19 years. I'm not sure that is palatable to most people here though, it certainly isn't to the airline industry.
- jerome-jh 7y agoThey may reduce the carbon footprint per mile, but the physics of thermal engines imposes hard bound to what can be achieved. The article mentions the delta wing design may save 20% on fuel consumption. However those gains are completely swallowed by the traffic increase which is about +30% every 10 years if I remember correctly. The target for 2050 is completely unrealistic, considering the traffic increase and the long cycles of the aviation industry. It may be achieved with hydrogen, assuming it can be produced in large enough quantities with renewables. "should we therefor not even attempt it?" Oh they certainly want to look as if they were trying to reach there objectives ... for the moment it is business as usual. The production of conventional, kerosene powered planes has never been so high and still increasing.
- Vesuvium 7y agoIn aviation, reducing fuel consumption has always been very important, since it's the most expensive part of flying. The heavier a plane is, the more fuel it needs. But fuel has weight, too, which means you need even more fuel! Reducing fuel consumption translates to exponential operational savings.This is also why planes with batteries are problematic: batteries store much less energy per kg than fossil fuel. I doubt that the increased efficiency in going electric is going to offset the extra consumption due to the increased weight. Even if they reduce emissions by 50% by 2050, flying will still produce ~5 more times CO2 than taking the train. And guess, what? The railway industry is also working to reduce emissions and with trains there's just so much more you can improve with much less investment. By 2050, aviation might very well produce ~20 times the emissions of railways, even though it has halved its emissions.So, with our current knowledge, the best way to reduce aviation emissions is...taking the train.
- jeromegv 7y agoOnly solution is to have some type of carbon tax on local travels and use it to reinvest in a train network. A lot of the air flights in North America would be better served by high speed trains. We won’t have an alternative to long distance flights, but there is one for shorter flights.
- kypro 7y agoIn Europe train is already quite a nice way to get around. I live in the UK and caught a train to London then a Eurotunnel train to Paris and it was probably quicker and easier when you account for time spent in departures and going through airport security.
- lkramer 7y agobut sadly also 2-3 times more expensive.
- davidgh 7y agoI’m often surprised at the ticket prices on trains in Europe. As I’ve traveled around there, it’s not uncommon for me to see a route by train at approximately 100 EUR and the same route by air by for less than half that. Causing additional confusion is that when I take the train, there are often a significant number of empty seats. It seems that the cost of an additional passenger on a train is almost zero, so why do trains not attempt to reduce per-ticket prices to increase capacity and become more competitive against low cost airlines? In your example, the train from London to Paris in my experience has almost always been nearly triple the cost of a flight.
- byroot 7y ago> It seems that the cost of an additional passenger on a train is almost zero It is. But the cost of the first passenger is massive. Think of all these rails (and the terrain under it you have to pay a hefty price for), all the bridges etc. You mention the Paris-London train, just the tunnel did cost $21 billions, add the high speed rails before and after it and you are probably at close to $40 billions in infrastructure before the first train can do the trip. Trains are orders of magnitude greener than planes, but unless you massively tax planes, or massively subsidize trains, they'll always be more expensive than planes.
- fulafel 7y agoI hope blimps make a comeback, they have a lot of potential. Especially considering high speed rail is bound to stay limited to busiest connections, given the fixed costs and required high passenger volumes.
- dangus 7y agoBlimps are slow. That means they’d probably cost more than commercial jets, because the crew is being paid for a longer period of time. It also seems like jets can fly in far more inclement weather than blimps, but I’m no expert in that.
- fulafel 7y agoOf course everything currejntly costs more than commercial jets now because we aren't pricing in the havoc to the fuel cost, this can't be the criterion. Also, the Hindenburg went at 100+ km/h in the 30's, we're already using many kinds of vehicles that go at similar speeds and don't cost more than commercial jets. Hopefully we could beat the 30's technology in speed, that's just the lower bound. edit: also, correcting my terminology, I should have talked about "rigid airships" instead of "blimps" apparently - blimps are like balloons with little engines, and the Hindenburg & modern credible air travel blimpy looking designs are "rigid airships".
- dredmorbius 7y agoThey're also fragile, handle poorly in adverse conditions, and have little excess lifting capacity. In a world in which heavier-than-air flight becomes less affordable, there might be some niche uses. In general, my sense is that lighter-than-air craft are simply too close to the limits of potential engineering and materials.
- fulafel 7y agoSure there are drawbacks, but they can be mitigated to some extent by engineering, and we're not in a position to be choosers about it. Airplanes were also all of those things before enormous amounts of engineering investment started being poured into it, continuing incremental improvements across 100 years. The question is not "how can we keep our air travel habits?" after all.
- rypskar 7y ago>> than a short hop which would be better done by train. Train is better for short hops between highly populated areas, but not so much between islands with 10k peoples. Many short flights are between places where only other option is car + many hours on ferry, and for them an electric plane would be perfect
- econcon 7y agoFirst of all there is no need for people to trottle globe needlessly, all Instagram culture and people every person on earth dreaming of seeing same locations as photographed on Instagram is vanity. Why we've to damage our planet so much just to see some locations?