4 ms·
N26 customers feel betrayed by the German digital bank’s decision to quit the UK
- marvel_boy 7y agoMonzo and Revolut were a thousand times better than N26. Good riddance N26 !
- notkaiho 7y agoWhat was poor about N26? I have a Monzo account but have not really used the others.
- marvel_boy 7y agoThey lied about the reasons to betray 200.000 users in UK. One hint: it was not Brexit.
- mstade 7y agoDo you have a source for this? All I see in the article is conjecture. (Edit: I am not nor have I ever been an N26 customer, just curious.)
- 0x1221 7y agoDo we have any evidence that they lied? Like actual evidence, not the comments of a few outraged customers (one of them literally calling it "fake news").
- kmlx 7y agoit's known across the financial news teams that N26 left the UK due to very low adoption numbers. applying to the UK regulators did not make sense.
- mnd999 7y agoThat would confirm what they're saying - that the costs of continuing to give it a go in the UK market will increase substantially post brexit. Inside the EU costs would have been lower so it was worth trying to gain a foothold.
- pgeorgi 7y agoAs I understand it, the need for UK regulation only came up due to brexit (before they were in thanks to the common market), so I guess "it's brexit" is sort of right, even if that leaves it a couple of steps? Without it they could have coasted along for a while longer with not much extra effort.
- kennydude 7y agoafaik they shipped cards from germany (really ineffecient) and were generally really really slow at anything
- kmlx 7y ago- no IBAN number - when receiving a new card due to upgrade the old one becomes void but there's no mention anywhere of this - the login didn't work consistently (faceid today, tomorrow password) - no extra features, or very poorly implemented the general feeling I got from N26: not up to standard. it's a poor app with poor customer support.
- bathory 7y ago- Of course you have an IBAN, it displays when you click on the profile icon on the top right. - Sounds reasonable? - FaceID works for 30 days, after that you have to enter your pass again for FaceID to work another 30 days, it says so when activating FaceID - I agree that there are no really nice "extras"
- kmlx 7y ago> - Of course you have an IBAN, it displays when you click on the profile icon on the top right. No IBAN support in the UK. really bad startup, avoid.
- fenk85 7y agoThey are a German bank, UK are not part of SEPA european payment system, and now UK are not part of EU either... You are blaming a company for not accommodating non standard UK systems, and now deciding to pull out of UK, as UK literally does not want to be held to common standards (be it chargers, trade or bananas) as rest of Europe. Brexit is imposing costs on companies, some like N26 decide not to bother with UK, others like Revolut and Coinbase now have to open offices and operations in EU if they want to retain access to this large market. Did you vote for Brexit? Brexit has consequences, N26 leaving is a very minor one compared to whats coming down the line, live with it.
- myopenid 7y agoHaving lived in Germany (where N26 started), had the opposite experience. Revolut is a disaster. Reason being: - No 3DSecure, renders it useless for most online transactions. - No personal IBAN, uses some janky shared IBAN that is not tied to your name, which is required for many online depositing service like Coinbase.
- bathory 7y agoRevolut lets you receive many different currencies at 1:1 Interbank exchange rates during weekdays. That is pretty amazing compared to any bank.
- neximo64 7y agoIts really slow for me and very frustrating to use.
- kmlx 7y agoStarling as well.
- marvel_boy 7y agoYes, agree.
- bilekas 7y agoThere is a difference, N26 is an issuing bank. That means they have to follow different regulations than Revolut for example. Its not as black and white, as usual with banking nonsense.
- krn 7y ago> There is a difference, N26 is an issuing bank. Monzo and Revolut are too: https://monzo.com/blog/2018/06/07/is-monzo-a-bank/ https://monzo.com/blog/2018/06/07/is-monzo-a-bank/ https://blog.revolut.com/we-got-a-banking-licence/ https://blog.revolut.com/we-got-a-banking-licence/
- bilekas 7y agoOkay, I don't know too much about Monzo at all tbh, but Revolut got an EU banking license, which means, simularly to the N26, it will not be applicable for the UK Market. If that means they fall bank to not issuing accounts with Deposit protection in the UK, I'm not sure, or if it means they are just waiting to see what happens; sugested here : https://blog.revolut.com/how-we-protected-our-customers-from-brexit/ https://blog.revolut.com/how-we-protected-our-customers-from... It's not sure. But either way, if there are not enough people in the UK market to warrant the hassle of re-investing in the UK, I don't see the issue. The EU feel betrayed by Brexit too.. :(
- throwaway9d0291 7y agoMonzo yes, Revolut no. Revolut has permission to operate a bank but currently does not actually do so. It has the license but doesn't offer full current accounts.
- venantius 7y agoRevolut is a bank in Lithuania but not in the UK.
- neximo64 7y agoWhich one isn't an issuing bank?
- tluyben2 7y agoRevolut started out with another bank (wirecard?) issuing for them. Now they have a banking license and issue themselves.
- throwaway9d0291 7y agoCorrect that they have a license however they don't yet use it. Funds deposited at Revolut are subject to the same (near non-existent) protection as always.
- kmlx 7y agolast year N26 was like: "we've just opened our London hub. we're adding hundreds every day. we'll be hiring hundreds of people". this year: "With the UK having left the EU at the end of January, we will in due course no longer be able to operate in the UK with our European banking licence. Therefore, we are writing to share the news that we will be leaving the UK and closing all accounts." translation: "not enough signed up in order for us to apply to the UK regulators." honestly, this was by far the worst kind of response any startup can have. really amateurish.
- kmlx 7y agofrom my financial news insiders: "they left the UK since they didn't have any clients around. they figured that applying for a UK banking license would not make sense with such low numbers. thus, they've basically quit the market".
- znpy 7y agoThat's basically speculation.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIn the UK, in the past years, we have got used to anything and everything being blamed on Brexit so people have really grown cynical about this 'reason'. Here, considering that they are faring poorly and that they launched in the UK after the EU referendum many people think (rightly IMO) that they are taking the piss by blaming Brexit. It's also not clear whether a full bank licence is required to offer basic current accounts. I believe that Revolut operated for years without one and that the bank licence they have now is in fact an EU licence. They seem to want to focus on the US, that's their choice.
- ptah 7y agocan you give examples of things blamed on brexit that is not, in fact, brexit's fault
- 7y ago
- zimbatm 7y agoA sample of 3 people is not representative of all the customers. This article is pushing for sensationalism. Switching bank accounts in the UK is dead easy. Open the new bank account, give them your old bank account reference and they do all of the switching for you, port over the scheduled and direct debit payments. N26 is not competitive in the UK compared to Monzo, Starling and Revolut. Just pick one and you're good to go.
- kmlx 7y agofor sure. but the way N26 framed it is extremely amateurish. and i'm being generous. "we are writing to share the news that we will be leaving the UK and closing all accounts." this is what you write when you've gone out of business, not when you re-focus on the US for example. own your failure, explain what you did wrong and move on. especially when you've basically told everyone a year ago that everything's going great.
- zhte415 7y agoI disagree. I've seen forced account closure, and it's ugly. They're giving 2 months notice, which is far better from what I've experienced. Let me explain that: Get a picture taken on a Blackberry of a DHL package with containing notice of account closure notice, when it was going through the counter for delivery, before delivery, as proof sent to the head office of the company. And bang! Accounts, thousands of regular/netting/sweeping accounts for a reasonably large company, are instantly closed around the world while the CFO of the customer is sleeping. The money's not gone, it's Nostro'd, but the liquidity is. A desperate call from the relationship manager of a client that woke up, realised they didn't check their emails for a couple of months while this was in the planning, and found their client has a serious business problem. You're talking of paying employees, suppliers, rent, of staying in business. Forced account closure is never nice, it is brutal. One of the reasons I left banking, well, that company, I do have strong faith in how banks and a well run, ethical financial system can facilitate our lives. Two months notice, whatever the reasons, Brexit, or not, is pretty OK. N26 were also one of the few challenger banks that actually had a website aside from a phone app, a bit sorry to see that leave.
- 7y ago
- ptah 7y ago> “never gave any indication that the U.K. leaving the EU would make trading difficult for them.” duh. it should not be something you have to say. the opposite would be surprising and would be worth stating. my point is the default for banks is that brexit will affect their licence to operate in the UK
- Semaphor 7y agoYeah, every contact I have with UK institutions had been sending me letters for well over a year now about their brexit plans. OTOH, N26 (which is also my bank) really should have notified customers about their plans way earlier.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoLast year their plan was to expand in the UK. Their plan was to stay and ride out Brexit (a bank licence is not that big a deal and the government is helping). But since then they've launched in the US and investment money does not grow on tree. They've probably concluded that it was game over for them in the UK unless they launched a major investment push but they obviously decided to push in the US instead.
- ptah 7y agocustomers should have been wary that N26 did not have a brexit plan
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThey launched in the UK after the EU referendum... It's not like Brexit meant that they suddenly had to rethink their strategy, is it? No, they are faring poorly in a very competitive, crowded market and have simply decided to focus on the US.
- ptah 7y agothe nature of the withdrawal agreement was not clear until brexit actually happened
- fenk85 7y agoOne of the predictions of Brexit which was dismissed as "project fear" was that there be job losses and companies will leave. When Brexit happens and companies start to leave, there is surprise? shock, horror /s
- AlexAffe 7y agoI can totally see how staying in a market this volatile - due to Brexit of course! - can pose a too big and complicated task to a startup. That's fine I think. Better to estimate your ability to provide a good service up front and make professional decisions, even if that means sacrifice.
- peteretep 7y agoBrexit will have many challenges. But blaming “volatility” instead of competition is letting N26 off the hook for simply not being all that compelling compared to it’s competitors.
- rusk 7y agoI think maybe you are "half right" in that the additional costs imposed by brexit just meant it wasn't worthwhile.
- thu2111 7y agoSo far nothing has actually changed, despite the headlines. Transition period etc. If you believe the FT then the big impact so far is a slightly weaker currency which should help a German firm, not hinder them. It's really not clear where this volatility would be coming from, or what that actually means precisely, or why it'd be an issue now and not when they entered the market, or why they'd find it so hard to get a UK banking license if they did end up needing one. The costs of getting a banking license are high if you're creating a new bank, because there are so many policies and laws to comply with that require infrastructure e.g. AML enforcement. But if you're already operating the costs of getting a license would pretty minimal. So many of the requirements are about demonstrating you could run a bank in theory, that a process for converting an EU-recognised license to a UK-recognised license would certainly be very streamlined. This is doubly true because the UK has focussed on making it much easier to create new banks in the past 10 years. The banking application process is far easier than it used to be.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago
- kmlx 7y agothis is N26's deleted blog post before this announcement: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EQgcNPyXUAcsVrK?format=jpg&name=large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EQgcNPyXUAcsVrK?format=jpg&name=... key quote: "we are 100% focused on ensuring minimum disruption to our customers whatever the outcome or timing of Brexit"
- 101404 7y agoLeave means leave and this is what leave means. UK voted for this and actions have consequences. Many others will follow. Hardly anything to get upset about.
- znpy 7y agoCompanies leaving the UK after brexit, UNEXPECTED!
- znpy 7y agoPeople keep telling it's not about brexit. It is! Before brexit N26 could keep doing business in the UK with an european banking license, even if growth was slower than ideal. Now they cannot anymore, and have to apply for an expensive uk-only banking license. If it was because of low market share, they would have quitted earlier.