3 ms·
Actually, you have the same liberties with software as you do with recipes. The only problem is that it is vastly more complex, so you can't really use the libe
by tsimionescu 7y ago
Actually, you have the same liberties with software as you do with recipes. The only problem is that it is vastly more complex, so you can't really use the liberties.
You are not allowed to copy a recipe you found in a book. However, you can understand the concept and reproduce it in your own words. The same is true for software: you can't copy any source code that you see, but you are allowed to understand the source code and rewrite it in your own words. However, that is rarely doable, even for trained professionals.
Also, just like in food, while there are people who want the recipe, a lot more people that just want to eat, and don't have any desire to see the recipe, even less to change it. The restaurant industry is a lot larger than the recipe book industry.
So overall, the metaphor is perfect, but Stallman is drawing the wrong conclusions from it, and forgetting the huge complexity difference between the most complex food recipe and the simplest useful program.
- rhn_mk1 7y agoA more charitable reading takes this quote to highlight the disconnect between what people expect to do with things (recipes), and what is actually allowed legally. If you told someone they can't legally copy their neighbor's or grandparent's recipe, or heck, even one from a random website, they'd be very surprised, because this is what's actually happening. Now, with this reality in mind, Stallman's argument makes a lot more sense and reaches the conclusion: software resembles recipes in practice, but the law is incongruent with this practice.
- habitue 7y agoThere is actually a legal difference though (at least in the US) recipes can't be copyrighted, and software can be
- tsimionescu 7y agoThe law about copyright on recipes is more complex. Certain kinds of recipes (e.g. ones where the description of the steps is somewhat lyrical) are probably copyright-able, and so are collections of recipes, such as cookbooks. Photographs accompanying recipes are also copyrighted, so if you explain your recipe in pictures or video, that is also copyrighted.
- teddyh 7y ago> You are not allowed to copy a recipe you found in a book. I believe that to be incorrect. You are, in fact, allowed to copy the facts of a recipe. Copyright does not apply to recipes. The same goes for, for instance, clothing designs. (This is why expensive brands make designs with their logo plastered all over it; the logotype is covered by trademark law, even though copyright does not apply.)
- tsimionescu 7y agoEven with recipes, if the description is h baroque enough, you will not be allowed to copy it.