3 ms·
The biggest complaint about Spore was that it felt like a collection of minigames without an unifying vision. Maybe developing your game by aggregating a bunch
by jandrese 7y ago
The biggest complaint about Spore was that it felt like a collection of minigames without an unifying vision. Maybe developing your game by aggregating a bunch of minigames is a risky idea.
- GuiA 7y agoIt’s worked well for franchises like Mario Party, Wario Ware, amongst others.
- p1necone 7y agoThose games are explicitly designed and marketed as collections of minigames though, whereas Spore seemed to be presented as if it was supposed to be a more cohesive experience.
- c3534l 7y agoYakuza Zero as a counter-example. I think the problem with Spore is that it lacked depth, lacked the breadth of even contemporary RPGs or open-world games, and attempted to appeal to a mass audience by focusing on the wrong things. Minigame is just a concept. It's not good or bad.
- asutekku 7y agoThe core gameplay in yakuza zero is still just combat. Everything else is completely optional, apart from few hostess missions.
- setr 7y agoThe minigame aspect doesn't really matter -- most games can be considered a bunch of minigames wrapped up, where each component is really its own subgame (eg weapon crafting vs fighting vs town-building vs etc), all threaded together to produce some overarching value. The problem with spore is that it had a very clear, and obvious, and intentional thread -- the evolution of your creature. Each minigame was supposed to impact the way your creature developed -- the constraints of your environment, your skill, your choices, etc, were supposed to guide your creature down a path such that your choices from minigame 1 would change what you'd have to work with by minigame 3. The problem was that nothing mattered. It wasn't that there was no unifying vision -- it was that the game pretended everything mattered, but you'd chug along and realize there was literally nothing affected by anything you did -- the whole thing was an empty shell. It was supposed to be a (perhaps goofy) cross-millenia simulation, and instead it was.. 5 fairly worthless games mashed together to produce one large worthless game. The crime too is that mario party knows their minigames are shallow -- so they last for at most minutes, and offer like 60 of them. Spore, of course, somehow believed it had some kind of depth, and run you through each minigame for hours.
- TheObserver6955 7y agoIt's not like nothing mattered. e.g.: - How you evolved in Phase 1, decided if you get omnivore / carnivore / herbivore - How you acted in Phase 2 & 3, changed what you can do in Phase 4 & 5. So what super weapon you have in Phase 5 and if you are a religious, economic, military, ... nation. - Attacking nations, changes how they react to you in later stages of evolutions. There would have been a lot more potential in that game, but it is not like it was complletly unplayable. In fact, I didn't know about the hype regarding the game as I was a kid and just stumbled across it. Therefore I didn't had these high expactations, and it got my favorite game for many years.
- setr 7y agoyou're not wrong, but it's really as minimal an impact as it possibly could be -- my main point is that the game is incredibly shallow, not that it was nonfunctional.
- meowface 7y ago>The problem was that nothing mattered. It wasn't that there was no unifying vision -- it was that the game pretended everything mattered, but you'd chug along and realize there was literally nothing affected by anything you did -- the whole thing was an empty shell. This is how I felt when I first played Spore, but since then, I've come to feel this way about all single-player games and most multi-player games, honestly. The only games I've played where what you do really affects the world in a lasting and true way are sandbox MMORPGs. (Examples: EVE Online, Ultima Online, Shadowbane, Darkfall, etc.) Imagine some of the sandbox aspects of Spore, but with tens of thousands of other players in real-time. I think sandbox MMOs are a massively untapped niche. The problem is most of them have been developed by companies lacking funding and experience (and often competence), so they're usually rife with game-killing issues, and most people don't get interested in them or stick with them. Another inherent issue is that a lot of players aren't comfortable with the idea of semi-realistic consequences upon death, like other players taking everything in your gear and inventory, or perhaps even taking your clan's/nation's/corporation's city/territory that you painstakingly built over months. If you're just a casual video game player, harsh consequences and ruthless risk vs. reward often won't appeal to you. I suspect there'll one day be a "killer app" of sandbox MMOs that'll put them more into the mainstream, but I think it may be a decade or more away.
- EGreg 7y agoBut it could also be really a breakout hit — look at Myst for instance