4 ms·
Put it another way: do I rather fly with the wiring that was tested for 200M hours in the NG, or do I want the configuration that is retrofitted in a hurry to m
by alkonaut 7y ago
Put it another way: do I rather fly with the wiring that was tested for 200M hours in the NG, or do I want the configuration that is retrofitted in a hurry to meet the standard? It’s not obvious that trying to “fix” this defect is a good idea.
- noncoml 7y agoFalse dilemma.
- avalys 7y agoAbracadabra.
- teh_infallible 7y ago“Do we do our jobs and regulate Boeing, even if it means we can’t get cushy jobs there later?” The dilemma is real.
- fooey 7y agoIf they can't retrofit it in a way that's safe, then to the scrapyard it goes. All they did was ensure their fix gets even more scrutiny and to require additional proof that it's safe.
- alkonaut 7y agoWell they will say they can, if they are forced to. The question is: do I really think that the end result of that it is safer than something tested for 200M hours? There is only one good “proof” of safety and that’s testing.
- chopin 7y agoHow do you know that the wire harnesses on the MAX are the same than on the NG? The only word we have for it is Boeings. As the planes are not identical, the wiring might not be identical as well.
- alkonaut 7y agoIt's always going to be boeings word. This is like a building permit - the applicant argues with drawings and technical arguments why their design meets the criteria (and quite commonly why their design is safe despite not meeting some specific criteria). If you don't take a manufacturers word for something you can never get into any plane ever.
- rbanffy 7y agoI'll just take the A320 instead.