6 ms·
I remember the fantasy that more and more people would be able to develop simple basic apps for their own very personal customized needs. It was a vision of a m
by jrochkind1 7y ago
I remember the fantasy that more and more people would be able to develop simple basic apps for their own very personal customized needs. It was a vision of a more accessible and democratic compute infrastructure, where we'd all be 'makers' creating the compute environment we lived in. Things like hypercard were part of this vision.
Those days are gone. The article doesn't explicitly mention the fact we all know: Very few people have the capacity to create a 'home-cooked meal' like the OP, for their own use.
In fact much fewer than could create a little hypercard app. It's a world where there are pretty large barriers to most people being software 'makers', and instead we are just consumers who can choose from what is offered to us by various companies trying to figure out how to monetize our needs and desires.
Part of it is the increased complexity of app development. Part of it is the walled gardens of our suppliers.
> I distributed the app to my family using TestFlight, and in TestFlight it shall remain forever: a cozy, eternal beta.
Indeed. Because the very infrastruture ignores the needs of one-off "home cooked meal" apps, it assumes they don't exist, you have to pretend it is some kind of "beta" of a mass market commodified product instead (and be glad our suppliers still let you do that for 'free'). Our computers (increasingly the phone/device is people's primary computer) are no longer ours to do with as we will.
It is sad. If those who created the computing revolution 30 years ago (including prior versions of us) could see where it wound up.... the level of technological sophisitication of our pocket audio-video-geolocated-self-surveilling-communicating devices is astounding; the lack of 'empowerment' or control we have over them is utterly depressing.
- qiqitori 7y ago> in TestFlight it shall remain forever: a cozy, eternal beta. When I read this I thought -- oh man, I hope Apple doesn't decide to somehow limit this feature in the future. I wouldn't be surprised if it's already against the terms of service somehow to deploy a 'beta' app and then just keep using it forever. (Besides, don't you have to pay to be in the developer program? That may be somewhat acceptable for some adults, but kids whose parents would prefer that their kids "study" instead of "wasting time playing computer games"?) Anyway, this is one of the reasons I use Android. While becoming root isn't realistic on many devices, I think it allows you to do enough for kids to find their way into programming. Maybe the challenge of getting a root shell/flashing your own OS is enticing to some too. And maybe the tech used to protect devices from their users is interesting to some people too -- and since OEMs need to know how all this stuff works, it also happens to be documented pretty well. (I think this tech is still in its infancy unfortunately.)
- jrochkind1 7y agoWhat is the equivalent/alternative to "TestFlight as eternal beta" in Android, how do you (or "people") get self-developed "bespoke" "home-cooked meal" software onto their Androids? It's easier than iOS? I am not familiar, I'm a web developer not a device developer.
- detaro 7y agoIf you're not really worried about automatic updates, just e-mail them the app package, they can enable side-loading and install it. It has a similar "beta" mechanism to TestFlight in the Play Store. Alternatively, you can setup a private F-Droid repo and use the alternative F-Droid app "store" to distribute apps.
- jdormit 7y agoOn Android, you can just download an .apk and install it (you need to change the "Allow insecure apps" setting). No code signing, app store, or corporate approval necessary. This is the #1 reason I will never be getting an iPhone (which is a shame, since iPhones are beautiful devices in almost every other way).
- designcode 7y agoTestFlight is actually a simpler and better solution than having to deal with getting users to allow insecure apps
- peterbrown 7y agoI gad the experience you describe with root with jailbreaking iphones when I was younger
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lilyball 7y ago> you have to pretend it is some kind of "beta" of a mass market commodified product instead Or you could use enterprise distribution, which is the "correct" route for apps that don't go through the app store. But TestFlight is probably the simplest way to distribute an app to a handful of people and the only real problem with it is the need to distribute a new build every 90 days.
- snowwrestler 7y agoSince Apple really loves to lean in on the “anyone can learn to code” message around iOS (see: Swift playgrounds), it would be cool if they could figure out how to do a family-and-friends version of enterprise distribution. Some official way to let small groups of people build things for each other without having to list them in the App Store for anyone to find.
- nitrogen 7y agoThis is, I think, the fundamental problem with globalistic capitalism -- the total addressable market has to be either billions or zero. Google kills products because they will only make a few hundred million, when time was that would be an enormous, fantastic standalone company.
- k__ 7y agoI think we were too optimistic. These days were never here and are still yet to come. More and more non-CS people are learning to program every day. 10 years ago, I made good money with development of websites, that is solved and can be done by most non-technical people. I have to do other things that are still harder or that were too hard for a simple CS-grad in the past, but became simpler over the years.
- sombremesa 7y agoFor every one person learning to program, ten people are "learning to program". I would say that we're going to have a huge problem where most applicants aren't qualified for a given job, but I don't have to - we're already there. Still, BOTH numbers are trending up, so I guess at least that part is nice.
- k__ 7y agoIf we can make software development less of a specific job and more of a companion skill of most jobs, maybe people will start and develop systems for their fellow non-technical co-workers.
- jrochkind1 7y agoWe're going the opposite direction though, for good reasons. Have you ever experienced the result of business processes dependent on "hobbyist" systems developed by in-house dabblers? It's not good, and always needs to be cleaned up later. But it was actually a popular thing in the earlier days of computing, and still happens sometimes. One of the most likely places for it to currently happen is actually crazily complex Excel "macros" -- basically software apps written in Excel. So on the other hand to my original point, actually maybe those aren't always disastrous (yet?), there are a surprising number of them around powering all sorts of businesses, and their internals would seem horrifying to a software engineer, but they are working...
- scroot 7y ago> More and more non-CS people are learning to program every day. We (the computing people) make this much harder for them than it needs to be. Instead of giving them malleable computing systems like Oberon, or Hypercard, Smalltalk, or related, we give them glistening time sharing systems and tell them that "programming" is, really, entering text into a teletype emulator and watching it do things. People are not stupid, but insofar as computing has been dominated by industry and limited by open source, we have given them stupefying options. We have better examples from the past and should know better.
- dickjocke 7y agoThis is so pessimistic! What is the basis for thinking there are large barriers to most people becoming software makers? I was in high school 12 years ago, when iphones just hit the market at like 800 bucks each and there was no firebase or react native or Medium articles or youtube tutorials covering 1st step code generation commands to deployment for every tech stack. The language of the day was Java. There was no npm and not a trillion python libraries that you can do anything imaginable with. Is there any specific reason a 16 year old today couldn't make the app this guy did? As a software engineer I like the idea that I do a black magic that nobody could ever understand, but I genuinely don't think it's true.
- vorpalhex 7y ago12 years ago most folks had little webpages they cobbled together from snippets and ugly widget generators. It worked well enough. I've spent most of this week figuring out how best generate device specific thumbnails for my blog.
- yaitsyaboi 7y ago12 years ago the author of this post would have had a little website and now he has the ability to record and instantly share video with his family in a pretty delightful app :)
- ori_b 7y ago12 years ago, half the not-so-technical people I knew had little websites. Now, there's this one author.
- peanutz454 7y agoSo are you saying the barrier remains the same? Earlier we had less access to stuff, and could write simpler software. Now we have more access, but software has become complex
- nonbirithm 7y ago
- scroot 7y ago> Part of it is the increased complexity of app development. Part of it is the walled gardens of our suppliers. And our current culture contributes to both of these issues. We got the kind of computing that fits that culture, which is one that emphasizes profit making over other types of activity, and one soaked through with short term thinking. We need well funded basic research (to create computing media systems in the spirit of hypercard et al) and companies willing to push malleable computing systems out to their customers. Hypercard was extremely popular in its day, and Apple let it die on the vine. It's because they didn't know what to do with it -- the culture had become about shrinkwrapped solutions, and it no longer made sense.
- dannyw 7y agoThis comes from our capitalist economic model. Absolutely everything in the America, from healthcare to education is profit-driven. Some countries have decided to prioritise social outcomes over profit, hence government-funded healthcare, education, etc. To change this "culture", you have to change our economic model for how we allocate resources in the world.
- smabie 7y agoAmerica has public schools, but they mostly suck. I would take a profit driven private school over a public one any day. I would also take dealing with a corporation’s customer service over a government office like the DMV any day. And while you mention healthcare, the actual problem is that they aren’t profit driven enough and instead exist as this Frankenstein’s monster of a public/private partnership. I currently live in a 3rd world country with no health insurance or government intervention in medicine and healthcare and the system works well(ish). Fixing a broken bone or getting a tooth pulled is only going to set you back $10. And while this is a lot for poor people, it’s still only between 2-10 days salary for an average person. That being said, there are major trade-offs in quality. I wouldn’t recommend giving birth or getting a life saving treatment here, but for anything somewhat routine, the healthcare provides great value. Also, all meds are over the counter and are very cheap. One med in particular is 100x cheaper here than the out of pocket costs in America.
- 7y ago
- bhl 7y agoI sort of feel that way, that recent technological progress for the last 10-20 years has made life significantly more convenient for us as consumers, but not as producers. I’m not going to deny that we have better tools now like GitHub and Visual studio, but what’s the equivalent of two day shipping? There’s a few companies pushing the envelope, whether they know it or not. Notion for example allows people to build shareable webpages with their blocks; if their API ever gets released, you can imagine normal people using it as a CMS for blogs or websites. Another example is Levels.fyi using Google Sheets as a backend; Firebase is hard to use, but Word and Excel aren’t. It’s difficult to say where this trend will go, but end users shouldn’t be underestimated. We could probably teach more people python by asking them to manipulate numbers on a spreadsheet than with a black terminal and plain text editor.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> There’s a few companies pushing the envelope, whether they know it or not. Part of the problem is, they're pushing the Envelope-as-a-Service. Notion is all fun and games, until they change something you needed from under you, or get bought and thank you for the incredible journey. Similar for the others. HyperCard being a desktop product was a feature, not a bug.
- knzhou 7y agoThis is just a result of people having finite time and resources. There are thousands of possible hobbies, and making home-cooked software from scratch is just one obscure one. For instance, can you make a literal home-cooked meal, without acting as a passive mass-market consumer (no grocery stores or supermarkets)? After all, you're living in the richest part of the richest part of the richest time of the world! Can you raise and butcher your own pig, grind your own flour, grow your own vegetables in your backyard, distill your own spirits, and chop your own wood to build your own fire? Cooking has always been a much more popular hobby than anything technical, and likely always will be, and yet almost all its aspects have been outsourced. Why expect software to turn out any other way?
- jrochkind1 7y agoYes, but... in my childhood in the 80s, simple carpentry (for example) and other "handyman" type skills was a very popular "hobby" among men (yeah it was gendered) across the nation. Because it wasn't just about what "hobby" seemed "fun" (although it may have been enjoyable for people who did it), it was about control over your environment, being able to make the things you needed instead of relying on having to pay someone else to, being able to customize them to your needs, etc. Software in today's world is similar. But does not occupy a similar place as a prevalent "hobby" that can produce useful things for your daily life. Now it's true that such skills even "hands-on" are much less prevalent in younger generations. What the reasons are, I' not sure we have totally identified. But I'm sure it's not just about considering them as "hobbies", if that means recreational activities people might do because they are "fun", like bird-watching or drawing, divorced from their utility. Carpentry/handyman skills were not so popular because people found them more "enjoyable" than other "hobbies".
- packetized 7y agoThis is absolutely a false dichotomy. A home-cooked meal is not one conventionally thought of as being from items hyperlocally sourced. At least, not in the last 70-100 years. We’ve had Sears Roebuck and the like for quite some time.
- knzhou 7y ago