3 ms·
It's OK because it's their computer and the electrons in their machine didn't become yours when the became configured so as to represent different words. In th
by michaelmrose 7y ago
It's OK because it's their computer and the electrons in their machine didn't become yours when the became configured so as to represent different words.
In the same fashion if I write your words on my paper with my pen the common sense ownership of pen and paper doesn't change.
Copyright is an invented right drawn from nothing that derived its legitimacy solely from utility derived from paying for creativity.
Turns out that we are already rich enough as a society to pay for a decent life for everyone and most of the money sticks to the hands of greedy people with lumps of coal for souls and zero creativity.
The kind of morons who would try to take down a dictionary.
- Silhouette 7y agoCopyright is an invented right drawn from nothing So are all property rights. The "common sense" ownership of pen and paper that you mentioned is that if I'm bigger than you, or I have a better weapon, or I have more friends, then your pen and paper are now mine. Fortunately for almost everyone, as a society we have learned to cooperate better than that.
- michaelmrose 7y agoWe can't both eat the same sandwich we can both read the same epub.
- Silhouette 7y agoOnly if someone wrote that epub in the first place, though.
- michaelmrose 7y agoTrue and the equipment required to create the book in most cases is now down to about $200. Access to the internet comes at a comparatively princely $60 a month. In a lot of first world nations education and health are gratis. Donations can be solicited to fund the creation of desirable works. I wonder if copyright went away people would still write books?
- Silhouette 7y agoI wonder if copyright went away people would still write books? I respectfully suggest that you're asking the wrong question. Obviously some books would still be written. More insightful questions might be whether people would still write as many books, whether the books written would be as good, and whether books would reach as large an audience as happens under copyright. I contend that it is utterly implausible that an entirely voluntary or even patronage-based system would come anywhere close to our current situation by any of those metrics. The vast majority of the cost of making a book has nothing to do with buying a laptop or paying for an Internet connection. It comes from the time and skill and creativity and understanding of the author. Depending on the nature of the book, it also comes from the time and skill and creativity and understanding of proofreaders, editors, illustrators, graphic designers, researchers...
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Copyright is an invented right drawn from nothing that derived its legitimacy solely from utility derived from paying for creativity. All property rights are invented rights drawn from nothing justified (if at all) solely by the resulting utility of providing the exclusivity they grant.
- michaelmrose 7y agoThe rivulrous nature of physical goods is inherent
- dragonwriter 7y ago> The rivulrous nature of physical goods is inherent As is the rivalrous nature of all subjects of non-physical property. Otherwise, there'd be no advantage to exclusive privileges. Exclusive access being more valuable to the exclusive holder than shared access would be is exactly rivalry. But the rivalrous nature of the subject of property doesn't make property rights natural, it just provides the basis by which such rights create incentives which drive behavior which may or may not produce social utility.
- michaelmrose 7y ago> In economics, a good is said to be rivalrous or a rival if its consumption by Satvik consumer prevents simultaneous consumption by other consumers, or if consumption by one party reduces the ability of another party to consume it. You aren't the red queen and words don't mean what you want them to mean. It makes property rights a reasonable answer to a question that had to be resolved one way or another because we can't all eat the same sandwich. Because we can all ready the same epub or build the same machine intellectual property rights are an answer to a much higher level question of how do we as a society achieve success. Conflating this higher level abstract question with a low level physical question confuses the issue and makes it impossible to arrive at some potential solutions because of the baggage provided by the lower level question. Because we already know we can't all eat the same sandwich we refuse to ask if the world is better off if we make information free of constraints. We act as if we were ripping a sandwich out of somebodies mouth instead of asking if that particular sandwich actually ought to exist in the first place.