6 ms·
> Of course if you are in the top 5-10% of earners Do you go to a special doctors office for the top 5-10%? The one I go to is full of ordinary middle class pe
by rayiner 7y ago
> Of course if you are in the top 5-10% of earners
Do you go to a special doctors office for the top 5-10%? The one I go to is full of ordinary middle class people. 80% of Americans polled rate their healthcare as excellent or good: https://news.gallup.com/poll/245195/americans-rate-healthcare-quite-positively.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/245195/americans-rate-healthcar....
The American healthcare system isn’t hard to fix because it only works for 5-10% of people. It’s hard to fix because it works for 80% of people. Americans don’t irrationally cling to a system that’s bad for 90% of them. (Even among Democrats, a large fraction oppose getting rid of current health insurance: https://slate.com/business/2019/10/medicare-for-all-is-getting-less-popular.html https://slate.com/business/2019/10/medicare-for-all-is-getti...)
Americans stick to the current system, because it works for most people. Most middle class people don’t go bankrupt when they get sick. And the middle class pays the lowest taxes in the developed world, because they don’t pay 20-30% payroll taxes like in European countries to support healthcare for the bottom quarter of earners. That’s the bargain people have voted for. That is obvious, because candidates who campaign for Swedish style healthcare don’t propose Swedish style taxes to go with it. Elizabeth Warren isn’t running on a top tax bracket that kicks in at $75,000 — she’s running on a wealth tax Sweden abandoned and corporate taxes higher than Sweden. Because Americans won’t vote for the bargain between healthcare coverage and middle class taxes that Swedes have adopted.
It’s not the system I’d prefer, I’d rather pay more taxes and make sure the bottom 25% have adequate healthcare. But the notion that everyone is actually irrational and the current system only benefits a small minority is self deception.
- cheez 7y agoSo _why_ if it works for 80% of polled people does it keep being touted as it resulting in bankruptcy consistently?
- lifeformed 7y agoThe other 20% is a lot of people.
- xeromal 7y agoYup, the US is the 3rd most populated country on the planet.
- dahfizz 7y agoThe same reason that guns result in 1% of deaths but you hear about them constantly. It makes for a good news program.
- allover 7y agoYou're _honestly_ saying that fears over school shootings in the US are overblown because it makes for good news?
- rayiner 7y agoYes.
- dahfizz 7y agoSchool shootings average 4 deaths per year. They are very tragic and very sad, but you should fear them about as much as you fear cows. In fact, cows kill a lot more people than school shootings do. All this fearmongering over such a rare occurrence is actively causing harm: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/10/11/lockdown-drills-an-american-quirk-out-control/?arc404=true https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/10/11/lockdown-...
- cheez 7y agoThe only presidential candidate to speak truth about this... Andrew Yang.
- allover 7y agoHe said the drills are misguided though right? Not that the US obsession with guns and lax gun control that enables school shootings is defensible.
- rayiner 7y agoAmericans have guns because we believe that individual citizens may, god forbid, need to kill people. Many Europeans, by contrast, believe that they are past that, at a point in history where only the State needs the power to kill. Who knows who is right. But it’s ridiculously arrogant to say that the American position is not defensible. It was literally just a couple of generations ago when the US was air dropping rifles into France to support the Resistance. Even if we have now entered an age where ordinary people don’t need guns—that new age is younger than computers, supersonic flight, or television. Its far too soon to conclude that’s this is how the world will always be from here forward.
- Aunche 7y agoIf you're already in a lot of debt, getting a medical bill is just going to add to that debt. As a result, anyone who sees a doctor and declares bankruptcy can say that healthcare is at least partially to blame.
- cheez 7y agoI get the logic, but I'm more looking for statistics.
- Aunche 7y agoI can't tell whether there are "too many" medical bankruptcies, but I know that pundits are exaggerating the degree of severity. This link has some statistics, so you can take what you want from it. https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2019/jan/31/jose-oliva/health-care-top-reason-bankruptcies-florida-gop-le/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2019/jan/31/jose-oliva...
- refurb 7y agoTake a look at bankruptcy due to health issues in Canada. It’s lower than the US, but still a problem. They have a single payer system, but what people tend to forget is if you’re really sick, you often can’t work, so even if health costs are minimal, you can still go bankrupt. What I think would be helpful in the US is universal catastrophic insurance. Worst case scenario, you’re covered. If you want everyday health insurance, let people buy it or get covered if low income. Many universal system use this type of coverage.
- rayiner 7y agoIt’s a misleading statistic that gets used because it helps push the narrative that things are broken: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5865642 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5865642. > However, the magnitude of the bankruptcy effect is much smaller than previously thought: we estimate that hospitalizations cause only 4% of personal bankruptcies among nonelderly U.S. adults, which is an order of magnitude smaller than the previous estimates described above.
- cheez 7y agoI'm not so sure that rate of medical bankruptcies is the metric I'd use to measure the healthcare system! But point taken.
- bo1024 7y agoI'm not sure I agree with this -- how do you distinguish between "the system works for 80% of the people" and "79% of the people don't have medical emergencies (but the system would fail them if they did)"?
- dahfizz 7y ago> but the system would fail them if they did I'm not convinced on this point. Over 90% of Americans have health insurance[1]. Sure, insurance might not cover every dime of every bill, but I can't imagine falling ill is an instant and universal cause for financial ruin like people claim. Disclaimer: I've been lucky enough to not have to use my health insurance for anything serious. But I have had to use other kinds of insurance (car, home) and by and large it's been fine. We hear horror stories a lot because they're sensational and they sell well, but people continue to buy insurance because it actually does provide value. [1]https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2019/demo/p60-267.html https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2019/demo/p60-26...
- rjzzleep 7y agoThere's also this[1] study about cancer and debt in the US. Insurance isn't equal to insurance. The car insurances in the US are the most comfortable in the world. Something happens, you're covered, the insurance pays. Not so in other parts of the world. You drive out of the parking lot scratch another car? It's considered normal in the US. Not so in Germany. You scratch someones car by accident? Anything is possible now. Why compare apples and bananas? I had a surgery in Taiwan and worked in Healthcare in a couple of countries. I also had health insurance when I was working in the US and got hit by a car while on a bike. And while the insurance and the other drivers car insurance paid for most, man you sure have to be careful that someone can tell the emergency not to take you to the wrong hospital. Let's stop pretending there isn't something seriously wrong with the US healthcare system. If all stars align everything is fine, but just an MRI can take anything from 1000 to 2000 or more dollars depending on whether you have insurance or not. You don't have to pay the 2000 dollars if you know better, but it's basically like a bazaar where you have to bargain if your insurance hasn't done so already. Germany was at that point in the 1920s(or sometime around that) actually. I'm not a fan of Germanies healthcare system, especially since it's such a huge chunk of an already low income, but all the issues you describe about other countries are mostly non issues in Germany. https://www.amjmed.com/article/S0002-9343(18)30509-6/fulltext https://www.amjmed.com/article/S0002-9343(18)30509-6/fulltex...
- readhn 7y ago>> Most middle class people don’t go bankrupt when they get sick. The median American household currently holds just $11,700 in savings. most people in usa would be ruined financially by a serious sickness where each day at the hospital alone could be up to $5000.
- ars 7y agoNo one ever actually pays that. With insurance a deductible is around $4,000. Or they have medicaid. Or they negotiate with the hospital. Or they just don't pay. Those news stories about people being ruined, are in the news exactly BECAUSE they are unusual.
- eanzenberg 7y agoLiterally why insurance exists
- jandrewrogers 7y agoIn the US it isn't the poor that suffer but the lower-middle class, who are neither poor enough to get excellent health care for free nor wealthy enough to have high-quality private insurance. The policy problem is that to adequately cover the lower-middle class you would need to substantially raise taxes on the upper-middle class, which pay anomalously low tax rates in the developed world. And the upper-middle class in the US quite enjoys their low tax rates. (While often focused on, the upper class often pays aggregate tax rates in places like California and New York that are more in line with Europe.)
- NicoJuicy 7y agoLiving in Belgium, the healthcare works for every Belgian if it's realistically possible, not the "80%" like in America ( source?). When I see the costs of an operation in America, they just do unnecessary operations, because they can earn extra money. When your argument is "most people won't go broke", that is a really fucked up statement. Medicare ( that the current administration is trying to slash) is a partial fix for a very expensive and failed system.
- bcrosby95 7y agoMoney for employer provided health insurance doesn't come from nowhere either. Bumping payroll taxes up to 20-30% would actually be cheaper than the $30,000 per year my employer pays for my health insurance.
- meekstro 7y agoCharlie Munger who is charitably trying to fix the US health care system along with Bezos and others described it as evil due to its waste, hidden fees and perverse incentives. He applauded the Californian and Singaporean healthcare models. Singapore spends 20% of the US healthcare spend and achieves better statistics. He brought this up during a question session at the Daily Journal AGM while also repeatedly discussing the evolved prevalence of irrationality in Humans and how one has a moral duty to actively combat it. He also said US happiness would not shift as long as the current welfare spend didn't increase or decrease more than 5% and the divisive political hatred was largely unproductive.
- unexaminedlife 7y agoI think a better metric would be to find out what percentage of people who NEED their healthcare for major medical issues rate their healthcare insurance as good or excellent. https://www.commonwealthfund.org/press-release/2018/new-survey-sickest-finds-us-health-care-exacerbating-struggles-americans-serious https://www.commonwealthfund.org/press-release/2018/new-surv...