3 ms·
Communism also generates wealth for significantly fewer people. You think the concentration of wealth is bad in capitalist countries? It is. But communism sp
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Communism also generates wealth for significantly fewer people. You think the concentration of wealth is bad in capitalist countries? It is. But communism spreads the wealth even more unevenly.
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoGot a source for that? We’ve got extreme wealth inequality today on broadly capitalist terms. I think it depends on whether you mean state communism, where state officials can enrich themselves, or anarcho communism which would be truly democratic. Actually in most cases I think wealth concentration has a lot to do with how much democracy you have. In America the wealthy classes control our democracy and so we have a lot of inequality. In Soviet Russia the state officials had control and so there was a lot of inequality. A lot of anarchist theory is schemes for more democracy. The whole idea of anarchism is to eliminate unnecessary hierarchy.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoMy source was communism, as it was actually in the communist bloc, rather than communism in theory. The capitalist west not only did better at generating wealth than the communist bloc, it also did better at spreading it to more people in society. (Not well - just better.) But if we want to compare communism in ideal theory, we have to compare it to capitalism in ideal theory, right? At that point, nobody has any actual data.
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoSo you’re saying the USSR had more wealth inequality than the United States today? I’m genuinely curious if that’s true or not. But it doesn’t sound like you have a source. Is that just a feeling you have?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWell, officially the USSR had very little wealth inequality. But... what fraction of the population got to shop at the special stores? (You might consider them the "rich", because they could buy more things, and for less money.) I'm pretty sure they weren't more than 5% of the population, and maybe significantly less, but I don't recall specifically. And that's if communism was functioning "normally". Didn't Romania turn into a kleptocracy? What was the level of wealth inequality there?
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoI mean it is certainly the case that the top 5% get to shop at better stores in the USA. And the top 1% even more so. Now if you’re really concerned with who was authoritarian, I wouldn’t defend them. But it sure doesn’t seem obvious to me that there was more inequality in soviet Russia than there is today in the USA.
- d1zzy 7y agoThe fact that you can't get accurate income data from communist regimes that cover the entire society is also a sign of applied communism being a big lie/illusion, it needs to lie to its people and keep them in the dark to preserve it. I grew up in communism and indeed there were people who were "more equal" than others, mostly those well connected with high positioned party members (if themselves weren't such party members). That allowed them much better living conditions than the regular "worker", they ate meat every day (yes, it may sound strange to the average reader of HN but meat wasn't something that we in the 80s in Eastern Europe had access to very often), had bread (for the rest of us it was rationed), soft toilet paper, jeans (I would have killed for a pair of jeans!), pepsi (no coca-cola tho) and a million little other things that people living in Western Europe in the 80s took for granted. But hey, most of us were "equal" in our poverty, so communism can't be that bad.
- geofft 7y agoI'm not sure it's as simple as a binary "communism" vs. "capitalism" - at least in the context of feasible political proposals in most Western country, that's less often the debate than the strength of the welfare state and the amount of market regulation. Do we have stats on how wealth inequality relates to such things? There's also the question of what the shape of the distribution looks like - for instance, would you prefer a country where 90% of the country has no savings and 10% has more money than they need, or one where 95% of the country has two months worth of savings and 5% of the country has more money than they need?
- crimsonalucard 7y agoThis isn't even a topic on programming languages nor was the original post inflammatory yet here you are following me around like a creeper.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoFor what it's worth, I didn't notice the name until after I had replied. I replied because I thought it appropriate to reply to what was said, not because of who said it. [Edit: I will agree that your post was not inflammatory. I also note that I (on a different thread) replied to you on a programming topic, and for a change, I agreed with you and thought that you had a very interesting perspective.]