4 ms·
> Well the number one threat to Earth is an impact event. If we can hypothesize a rapidly growing lift capacity, why not use that mass budget to develop a solar
by samatman 7y ago
> Well the number one threat to Earth is an impact event. If we can hypothesize a rapidly growing lift capacity, why not use that mass budget to develop a solar-system-wide system for detecting and if necessary altering the trajectory of potential impacting objects? It would be WAY better to protect the Earth than any other backup plan.
Detection is a solved problem.
Altering the trajectory of an asteroid requires a large amount of lifting capacity to be available on relatively short notice. That is, it has to already exist when the crisis is identified.
Congratulations. You've identified a positive externality of Starship.
- disambiguously 7y agoConversely, of course, the trajectory of a non-threatening near-Earth asteroid can be known well in advance, but there’s no obviously benign reason for anyone to bring a lot of delta-v to one. So having a steady traffic in commercial heavy lift could be a positive externality as well, for whoever wants to find a close-call asteroid that has been recently marked as 100% safe and give it a little nudge.
- samatman 7y agoMaking it easier for mustache-twirling supervillains to destroy Earth is not a concern of mine, personally. Weaponizing smallpox and distributing it in major airports is the lower bound of effort. Anything that exceeds this is not worth worrying about.
- snowwrestler 7y agoIf you build such a capability on purpose you don’t have to hope you’ll be able to adapt a nebulous “positive externality” of some other system.
- samatman 7y agoI don't think a purpose-built capability is anywhere near as good. It would be a massive drain on the economy that chose to maintain it, there's no guarantee it would actually work when the time came, and it wouldn't benefit from improvements in design over time. Being profitable, Starship has none of these limitations.