4 ms·
> against a well funded nation state Why do people specifically state 'nation state' in these circumstances? What do you think makes a nation state a particula
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> against a well funded nation state
Why do people specifically state 'nation state' in these circumstances? What do you think makes a nation state a particularly notable adversary relative to countries which aren't nation states like the UK or the US, which seem to have more capability in this area not less?
- antepodius 7y agoWhen people say country, they mean the whole decentralised group of people, and the physical area, and a bunch of other stuff. When they say nation state, the mean a government.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> When they say nation state, the mean a government. That's not what 'nation state' means at all - a nation state is an international state that is also a nation. So pretty much orthogonal as to whether they're a competent cyber force or not.
- throw_away 7y agoWhy don't they just say 'a government', then? The only other rationale I can think of is that 'nation state' sounds much cooler and cyberpunk.
- samcal 7y agoThe reason that it's usually used in this context is that a nation state has a monopoly on violence within its borders. It's a natural extension in "cyberpunk" circles to apply this to digital violence.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> a nation state has a monopoly on violence within its borders But this isn’t unique to nation states.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoBecause cities, provinces, and states (as in one of the 50 comprising the United States) all have governments, and most of them do not have the resources for an international cyber-attack. Nation-states are by definition country-level governments.
- chrisseaton 7y agoNo, nation states are states which are also nations. For example Japan is a nation state but the UK is not.
- sterlind 7y agoSpecifically, nation states set their own foreign policy and have their own military. Usually APTs are associated with military or intelligence agencies, which only nation states have, though some (e.g. the Bears in Russia) aren't formally tied to the government (as much as being allowed to make money on the side.) I favor APTs as a term, since it denotes any actor with lots of technical means and a political/strategic rather than financial agenda. Many APTs belong to nation states, but that's not always true!
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoThe confusion seems to come from most people seeing nation and country as synonyms. The older traditional definition of nation has mostly faded except in the context of the modern use of the word nationalism, but even that has been perverted to mostly mean extremists.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wolf550e 7y ago"nation state" in the infosec industry means "sovereign government". Yes, it's wrong and it's very unfortunate, but it seems it's too late to change, though Maciej Cegłowski has been trying for about a year [1]. 1 - https://twitter.com/Pinboard/status/1121893376557633537 https://twitter.com/Pinboard/status/1121893376557633537
- catblast 7y agoIt isn’t what nation state has traditionally meant because of the differing definition of nation, true.. but it has some reason for existing... Nation here means national (as in internationally sovereign) and state means the government of that nation (or state :-) — these words can all be synonyms in English) specifically. It concretely means “national government” as you basically mention but with fewer syllables (3) vs (5 or 6) and it’s shorter to type. Do you have any creative alternatives that don’t step on the traditional use?
- perl4ever 7y agoWhy are those not nations? For further clarification, are the ROC or Israel nation states?
- chrisseaton 7y agoThe UK is four nations (four nations united into one kingdom, hence the name), and the US is a mix of people from many nationalities. Israel is probably a nation state. I don't know much about Chinese cultural identity.
- perl4ever 7y agoThis may be your opinion, but I'm not sure it implies a clear general rule that you could even hope to have people accept. I'm sure a lot of people from the UK would pedantically insist on the multiple nations point, based on my past experience on the internet. On the other hand, in the US, people declare it to be "one nation..." and so saying it is not a nation suggests that the determination is made more from an outside vantage point than a traditional American one. The Wikipedia page on Taiwan has some information on how people there view themselves. It seems that basically, people may be largely divided between those who came from mainland China after WWII, those who came in earlier waves of immigration, like the 19th century, and "aborigines" who came much longer ago (but it seems there were people from China on the island even before them) These may not seem like large differences, but it seems like they are tied up with the overarching question of the status of the ROC as being separate from China or not, of whether people are Chinese, Taiwanese, or both. And the question remains, do people determine for themselves if they are a nation, or do outsiders do it "objectively"? A definition can be stated without it being practical to use.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Why are those not nations? They are, as the term is usually used; the United Kingdom and U.S. are nations. In the former case, it is sometimes argued that the constituent countries of the UK are nations rather than the UK itself; they certainly are historically nations and may be so presently, but nationhood isn't exclusive; the UK definitely has a national identity whether or not England, Scotland, Wales, and/or Northern Ireland also do. The US is a more clear case of a Nation with a strong national identity and without anything even arguably competing the way the constituent countries of the UK do; yes, it's people have many ancestral nationalities (which is true in many nation-states), but that's hardly relevant to whether it's a nation-state. Since the advent of the idea of nation-states as a general norm, many polities have built national identities to form nations that coincided with the State and displaced ancestral nationalities as the locus of attachment for subjects of the state, often as deliberate projects.
- pjc50 7y ago"Nation state" is more of a verbal tic from people who need to distinguish that they don't mean US state, than a statement about ethno nationalism.
- pferde 7y agoYeah, I'd prefer the bike shed to be painted green.