5 ms·
This is a charming time capsule from a more innocent age, when us geeks could chortle smugly at how clueless government security agencies were about technology.
by pmoriarty 7y ago
This is a charming time capsule from a more innocent age, when us geeks could chortle smugly at how clueless government security agencies were about technology.
Since then, with the advent of the likes of Stuxnet, the NSA's ubiquitous surveillance apartus, and the Great Firewall of China, we've been taught a hard lesson that governments are perfectly capable of developing technology expertise or contracting it out, if need be.
It's even a truism now that computer defence against a well funded nation state is hopeless. This was not the case back in the old Steve Jackson Games days, when it seemed that the entirety of computer power rested in the hands of a relatively small number of idealist academics.
Rember John Perry Barlow's A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace?
"Governments of the Industrial World, you weary giants of flesh and steel, I come from Cyberspace, the new home of Mind. On behalf of the future, I ask you of the past to leave us alone. You are not welcome among us. You have no sovereignty where we gather."
What once sounded almost like prophecy has come to sound more like a sad, deluded joke.
- dmix 7y ago> It's even a truism now that computer defence against a well funded nation state is hopeless. It's interesting how many of those same early hackers [1] went on to working for those same governments or selling them exploits/offensive tools to make sure this stay true. None of that could have been accomplished by any gov without real legitimate talent joining on. Especially in the early days. Largely because the governments of the world decided they were far, far more interested in the offensive side because of the mountains of intelligence they were getting. Which then filtered down to industry to where all the money, fun, and very importantly, how much easier it is to break something than to protect it. Or maybe it was a side-effect of all the vast majority of talent/money going into the intelligence community and defence contractors instead of just the "government" in general. Probably a combination of both. The talent that did end up working on the defensive side (that was actually useful) was, and is, usually some super complicated and expensive systems that only big companies could afford. And/or you have a major budget to hire, or pay consultancies, with equal/superior talent than the adversary. Which leaves out the vast majority of companies and almost all civilians with useless or negative utility anti-virus software, or nothing at all besides the odd operating system, software, and public crypto progress. That's not to say great strides haven't been made on the civilian side in recent years, since the public has caught on to the true scale of the surveillance/offensive stuff and the implications that has given the general weakness of the technology we use everyday. The significance of WhatsApp adopting Signal's E2E, Telegrams popularity, and people moving to iMessage and other encrypted non-SMS text, emailing properly adopting transit encryption, and the Google TLS charts [2] reaching ~90% from around 40-60% only 7yrs ago is a really, really big deal IMO. [1] https://www.wired.com/story/cult-of-the-dead-cow-at-stake-hackers-excerpt/ https://www.wired.com/story/cult-of-the-dead-cow-at-stake-ha... [2] https://transparencyreport.google.com/https/overview?hl=en https://transparencyreport.google.com/https/overview?hl=en
- pmoriarty 7y agoThis is also a consequence of how much technology knowledge was easily obtainable by anyone interested in it. Even black hats were eager to spread their knowledge around, from 2600 and Phrack to the thousands of filez on BBS's and the early internet. That in turn was a consequence of both the open hacker ethos, born in the cradle of academia, and of "information wants to be free". As a result, those in the security and surveillance parts of the government who had an interest could easily learn pretty much whatever they wanted from the mouths of the very people they wanted to survey. Not that I'd have it any other way, being a fan of the free flow of information, but it's interesting to see what unintended consequences this has. Of course, this information flow was mostly one way.
- dvtrn 7y agoIt's interesting how many of those same early hackers [1] went on to working for those same governments or selling them exploits/offensive tools to make sure this stay true. Every man’s got a price.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoIt sounds cynical, but I think it is just being pragmatic. Once you recognize that the state holds a overwhelimng resources and only one mistake can land you in a world of hurt, joining a state hacking team seems like less annoying option. You do sell your soul, but.. you get to test your black hat skills with the backing of state resources and immunities afforded to it all the while learning how to really not make that one mistake. Steady paycheck is just a bonus. It is a price and a high one, but I can understand the motivations behind it.
- 1996 7y agoThere are many things I know I could do, that most people would find distasteful even if they are perfectly legal. Like working in the ad industry. I would prefer not to do them - but for the right price, why not? It'd better be damn high, because I can't easily see myself accepting. Still I can envision that in theory. But working for a government? I can't. I put that on the same ethical scale as murder. No. Never. For no price whatsoever.
- rectang 7y ago> It's even a truism now that computer defence against a well funded nation state is hopeless. For some, it is still worthwhile to harden defenses against nation-state threat actors. Raising the cost for those nation-states is sufficient justification on its own. For example, opaque binary distributions are more easily compromised than either source code distributions or verifiable reproducible builds. As an industry we should migrate away from opaque binaries, and major open source organizations should bear that in mind while designing their processes.
- IgorPartola 7y agoIt comes full circle I guess. Most of the technology we use today came from military research first. SV, for all of its recent boom, really has contributed the boring bits to make it all work. Things like GPS, cellular tech, the internet, Wi-Fi, AI, crypto, all stem from government research. Was the tech sector ever really in the control of the idealistic academics or was that all just an illusion?
- dv_dt 7y agoIf that's an interesting question to you, I'd recommend the book "The Entrepreneurial State" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Entrepreneurial_State https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Entrepreneurial_State
- germinalphrase 7y agoThe author has a good talk at the Long Now Foundation, as well. http://longnow.org/seminars/02014/mar/24/entrepreneurial-state-debunking-private-vs-public-sector-myths/ http://longnow.org/seminars/02014/mar/24/entrepreneurial-sta...
- chrisseaton 7y ago> against a well funded nation state Why do people specifically state 'nation state' in these circumstances? What do you think makes a nation state a particularly notable adversary relative to countries which aren't nation states like the UK or the US, which seem to have more capability in this area not less?
- antepodius 7y agoWhen people say country, they mean the whole decentralised group of people, and the physical area, and a bunch of other stuff. When they say nation state, the mean a government.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> When they say nation state, the mean a government. That's not what 'nation state' means at all - a nation state is an international state that is also a nation. So pretty much orthogonal as to whether they're a competent cyber force or not.
- throw_away 7y agoWhy don't they just say 'a government', then? The only other rationale I can think of is that 'nation state' sounds much cooler and cyberpunk.
- samcal 7y agoThe reason that it's usually used in this context is that a nation state has a monopoly on violence within its borders. It's a natural extension in "cyberpunk" circles to apply this to digital violence.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> a nation state has a monopoly on violence within its borders But this isn’t unique to nation states.
- 7y ago
- lazaroclapp 7y ago> It's even a truism now that computer defence against a well funded nation state is hopeless. This was arguably true (in the case of targeted attacks) even back then. That some civilian law enforcement agencies (and apparently the Secret Service) were clueless about SIGINT back then, doesn't mean that the same was ever really true for major spy agencies. Here is 1945's Stuxnet, for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thing_(listening_device) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thing_(listening_device)
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Since then, with the advent of the likes of Stuxnet, the NSA's ubiquitous surveillance apartus, and the Great Firewall of China, we've been taught a hard lesson that governments are perfectly capable of developing technology expertise or contracting it out, if need be. Unfortunately it can still be both at the same time. The NSA can hire some smart hackers at the same time as OPM gets breached and legislators pass laws putting all of everybody's data into the hands of the likes of Equifax which then also gets breached.
- rckoepke 7y agoHis next line was: >It's even a truism now that computer defence against a well funded nation state is hopeless. Which definitely agrees with your example. The pentagon officially operates on a doctrine that says "We may be able to have a whelming advantage in cyberspace, but we will never be able to operate with the overwhelming advantage that we enjoy in the physical space"
- cdoxsey 7y agoYour point stands, but the OPM breach was done by the Chinese government: https://www.fedsmith.com/2018/09/21/bolton-confirms-china-behind-opm-data-breaches/ https://www.fedsmith.com/2018/09/21/bolton-confirms-china-be.... It seems like governments have gotten good at cyber attacks but not so good at cyber defense.
- acdha 7y agoThe Chinese government did it but the public information about the attack does not show any advanced techniques or resources which would limit it to a nation state.