3 ms·
Did you click on the "link" link? It has a box and reply button just like the reply page. So removing the "reply" link wouldn't remove the ability to reply.
by jcl 18y ago
Did you click on the "link" link? It has a box and reply button just like the reply page. So removing the "reply" link wouldn't remove the ability to reply. I assume the inputs for the reply function are adequately captured by the URL (comment ID) and cookies (logged-in user) and thus don't require a continuation.
- palish 18y agoOh snaps son. I got burned. You're right, I didn't click on the "link" link and assumed that it was only for viewing the comment. I sincerely apologize.
- jcl 18y agoNo problem. Now all we need is for PG to tell us why it won't work. :) It's obviously a slightly different user experience, since users that aren't logged in won't get prompted to register/log in when clicking on "reply".
- palish 18y agoKeep in mind that getting rid of the "reply" link continuation would make the "Unknown or expired link" error less frequent, but it wouldn't solve the core issue of "each user requires a unique set of continuations". It would be a good stopgap measure in the meantime, though.