3 ms·
> But the illustrated example doesn't hold up to scrutiny and is overstated. The illustrated example is intended to be comparatively trivial. It's just clarify
by zozbot234 7y ago
> But the illustrated example doesn't hold up to scrutiny and is overstated.
The illustrated example is intended to be comparatively trivial. It's just clarifying what this kind of verification actually involves in practice. It makes no sense to describe it as "overstated", since the article actually mentions several case studies as demonstrating the usefulness of this approach; it's just that these cannot be examined in detail in an introductory article.
- Nursie 7y agoIt's attempting, AFAICT, to demonstrate TLA+ catching a class of very dangerous problem that traditional approaches won't/can't catch. It fails and in doing so it undermines the business case the wider article attempts to make. I think perhaps the example has just been simplified too far.