6 ms·
As a Fedora developer and amateur musician, I really couldn't recommend Fedora (or Linux in general) for music. The DAWs I've tried are terrible. They all hav
by rwmj 7y ago
As a Fedora developer and amateur musician, I really couldn't recommend Fedora (or Linux in general) for music. The DAWs I've tried are terrible. They all have horrible UIs, trouble doing basic stuff and are crash-prone (hint to developers: the DAW should never ever ever crash!) My band uses free GarageBand on Mac which is not very good but night and day better than any of them I've tried. Setting up Jack instead of Pulseaudio is horrible and invasive. Routing USB midi is an exercise in command line randomness.
Can we make this better? Probably. And I guess I should work on it. But right now it's not there.
- iovrthoughtthis 7y agoI mostly would agree in the past. Now that Reaper is available on Linux this has changed for me! I record on Linux all the time now. There are fewer plugins. You still have to wrestle with jack / pulse. There are other warts but it is a vast improvement. :)
- alkonaut 7y agoDo you mean that the Linux versions of DAWs are worse than their non-linux counterparts, or just that some linux-specific DAWs are worse than DAWs that are not linux specific? Because Bitwig for example is amazing, and it supports Mac/Win/Linux - but I haven't used it outside windows. I'd worry about sound drivers and plugin support (I doubt plugin makers spend a lot of time on linux GUI support) but I'd trust the core functionality to be the same across all platforms.
- acomjean 7y agoI’ve used bitwig Linux. Coming from ableton on Mac. I haven’t used it for much yet but it works quite well (pop-os). A little work to get it set up but nothing difficult.
- rwmj 7y agoThe second - I only tried free software DAWs on Linux. I've not tried proprietary DAWs on Linux, because if I'm going to do that I might as well go all-in on the Mac (not least because Macs and Windows don't have two competing sound systems that you have to switch between to use a DAW and do regular stuff like watching videos).
- eropple 7y agoWindows actually does have two competing sound systems. ASIO is, even in the far future of 2020, an absolute bear. My Windows machine has an audio interface with headphones and a separate set of speakers to play stuff while Ableton or Reaper is open. (Nobody really uses WASAPI. They should, though. It's great.)
- stefanha 7y agoI use Fedora to jam online several times a week and to record a few times a year. The open source Linux music software ecosystem is behind proprietary software available on Windows and macOS but it can do what I need. Audio system: JACK DAW: Ardour 5 Synthesizer: zynaddsubfx Pianos: PianoTeq 6 (proprietary) Drum machine: Hydrogen The lack of good drum kits and patterns is my current pain point. I haven't tried Reaper or Bitwig on Linux yet, but they should be decent if you are willing to use proprietary software. The Focusrite Scarlett 2i4 USB soundcard that I use is a class-compliant USB audio device and I've never had trouble with it.
- vibrafox 7y agoReaper and Live have spoiled me. I tried to like Ardour, and it would be great if it's all I had, but it has too many rough edges. LMMS is good though. I must have made 200+ songs in it before switching to Reaper. I could get by with LMMS and the included synths if I had to. It makes me wish Reaper supported LV2.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoI love LMMS cause it's like FL Studio. I used to use FL Studio (pirated when I was a teenager) to make rap beats and even once a dubstep beat, though it crashed and I lost all my progress.... LMMS is awesome cause it's free so I can just experiment with it. I havent found the time to make some serious tracks though. Also where do you get audio samples for LMMS? This is mostly my dilemma.
- vibrafox 7y agoThe best percussion I've ever had came from TAL-NoiseMaker. There's a Linux port. https://www.kvraudio.com/product/tal-noisemaker-by-togu-audio-line https://www.kvraudio.com/product/tal-noisemaker-by-togu-audi... LMMS also has its own percussion synth. https://lmms.io/wiki/index.php?title=Kicker https://lmms.io/wiki/index.php?title=Kicker As for samples, Echo Sound Works sends out occasional freebie packs on their newsletter. Their samples are usually good. https://www.echosoundworks.com/free-downloads https://www.echosoundworks.com/free-downloads Black Octopus Sound has a huge sampler pack that you can use in commercial stuff. https://blackoctopus-sound.com/free-downloads/ https://blackoctopus-sound.com/free-downloads/ Also keep an eye out for SFX packs around GDC (Game Developers Conference). Sonniss publishes one every year. You can probably find the (legit, official) torrents for past years.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoI know its Debian / Ubuntu based but have you tried Ubuntu Studio at all? It seems geared towards music and video editing out of the box so it might involve less command line incantations.
- indigochill 7y agoI tried Studio with a MIDI keyboard for input, but getting it to register the input was still a hassle to figure out. Had to go through JACK and explicitly wire the inputs and outputs of the various devices and apps to get everything working, which on a hack-everything level is kind of cool but on the other hand I just wanted to jam on a keyboard, not fiddle with a network of devices and applications. I can say, though, Studio is a huge step up from trying to get this sort of thing working in stock Ubuntu.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoGotcha, I have used Studio but in my case I havent wired up my Piano / Keyboard. I mostly use LMMS cause I dont have space for my Keyboard, and cause it's a free rendition of FL Studio which I love to be honest. I dont do a whole lot though, just things here and there. Good to know your side on it though. I think that might be the best thing till someone streamlines some of these libraries / programs is to focus on a Distro that makes it as seamless as possible, and push the fixes back to the original projects.
- Papric0re 7y agoFunny, I never had issues with my Midi-Controller. It's a USB-Class Compliant Controller. At least in Ardour its a simple task to do that. Haven't tried in Reaper so far. And also, I never found it difficult to connect devices, at least when using Claudia.
- EamonnMR 7y agoI've had good results with Renoise on Ubuntu
- pb82 7y agoCan I ask you what your opinion on LMMS is? It seems to get recommended a lot and I wanted to use it to get into DAWs at some point.
- rwmj 7y agoPretty sure I tried out LMMS, but don't recall anything specifically. The main ones I looked at and stuck with for a while were Ardour, Rosegarden, plus Audacity which is more of a sound editor. Just found out on this very thread about Non, which looks promising, so that's one I'm going to try next. I want to say the main problems are: having to set up Jack and switch between that and PA - why isn't there one sound system? - the whole USB midi routing situation, software with obscure UIs, and software that crashes. Apart from the first one these are all fairly easily solvable. These days I mostly write stuff using synths. The Deluge for example has enough built in that you don't need to use a DAW at all.
- billfruit 7y agoMay be that isn't the only approach that will yield good results, there are really powerful tools on a fundamental level like csound etc that I think fully leverage programmed computers and music.
- jcelerier 7y agoAs someone developing a daw (https://ossia.io https://ossia.io) - "hint to developers: the DAW should never ever ever crash!"... yeah, I'd like it not to have bugs too but there are only so many hours in a week-end :) I also had some cases / user projects where it was much more important to have maximum performance than guarantees of not crashing.
- wheels 7y agoThings have come leaps and bounds on Linux in the past 5-ish years. Linux is now viable (if not recommendable) for professional audio production. It wasn't before. Not only has Ardour gotten better, but also Bitwig is available, and Reaper too. Bitwig has the most polished UI, but Reaper has a particularly dedicated user base and is very extensible, if a little hard on the eyes. Routing MIDI is mostly a matter of using QJackCtl, which isn't pretty, but it gets the job done (and really, MIDI routing isn't pretty on any platform). Again, I wouldn't recommend someone building a system from the ground up for music production to go for Linux, but for someone who's already a long-time Linux user, it is now finally possible to do music production at a non-toyish level without switching OSes. As a side note, loads of audio "devices" (synths, grooveboxes, etc.) these days are just ARM devices running a modified Linux audio stack.
- sammorrowdrums 7y agoHave you Tried Bitwig? I have found it works pretty damn well, and is the most polished interface. It's just expensive. I've tried numerous packges, and MIDI devices etc. and I agree that things can be hard and decisions like "do I set up low latency kernel etc." have implications if you're using your machine for work other than music production, but I think things are better. I've tried Bitwig with external midi keyboard, USB keyboards, and Ableton Push - It's probably not my suggested setup for most musicians, but it's not a bad one.
- kagenouta 7y agoYou might want to look into Pipewire - it's a next-gen A/V framework being developed by one of the creators of GStreamer. It isn't ready for prime time yet, but the long-term goal on the audio side is to replace both PulseAudio and Jack.
- supernintendo 7y agoYou can actually do a lot with FOSS music production software like Ardour these days, although I’ve been using Ableton for over a decade so it’s unlikely I’ll be taking the time to learn another DAW any time soon. But if you’re interested, check out unfa [0] on YouTube. He puts out a lot of tutorials on free / libre audio production. [0] https://www.youtube.com/user/unfa00 https://www.youtube.com/user/unfa00
- willismichael 7y agoI think that Ardour 5.x has only crashed on me due to a bad plugin, and even at that it's usually a plugin that I'm developing when I haven't worked out the bugs yet.