3 ms·
Steve Jobs was always vocally opposed to DRM. He said the main competitors for the Music Store were CDs and piracy, and neither hassled you with DRM, so he saw
by chc 16y ago
Steve Jobs was always vocally opposed to DRM. He said the main competitors for the Music Store were CDs and piracy, and neither hassled you with DRM, so he saw it as a competitive disadvantage. The labels required DRM because Napster had left them gunshy, but Apple always seemed to be giving in grudgingly. (This is different for movies, of course, where the main alternative is DRM-encumbered.)
The lock-in was iTunes, not the DRM.
- Stormbringer 16y agoI think you need to clarify your point. When you say "The lock-in was iTunes, not the DRM." do you mean iTunes the application? iTunes the online store? Or iTunes the ecosystem? The app wasn't a lock in, as far as I know there were no rules requiring exclusivity on the online store... and if the ecosystem was a 'lock-in' there are alternatives. Not to pick on you specifically, I see plenty of people saying one or more of those is a lock-in, but I haven't seen a good reason why yet. It just seems to be an article of faith. Why is iTunes a lock-in? It just is, that's why. --- But then there is all this heated debate. Why even argue about it? If someone wants to own a Zune and feel all special and unique and pay $15/month for music subscription, hey, they can just do it. I think the debate is 'interesting', because at HN, surely we would all recognise that building an ecosystem (or community) around your product and giving the users a seamless end to end experience would actually be a good thing. Something to be emulated. No? If not, why not? What is it about Apple that singles it out from the herd for such uniquely irrational treatment?