6 ms·
Omg, I still can't believe that was in any doubt. If you are required to be at work, then you should be paid for that time. Just because you aren't "working" d
by olliej 7y ago
Omg, I still can't believe that was in any doubt.
If you are required to be at work, then you should be paid for that time. Just because you aren't "working" does change that the business is requiring you to be there.
If nothing else this should push them to make leaving work not take 20-45 minutes.
WTF. How does anyone think it's acceptable to [funcitonally] detain people.
- reactspa 7y agoApple, one of the richest companies in the world: - thinks they're above the law - is cheapskate that doesn't want to pay it's lowest level workers equitably *while constantly virtue-signaling about equality and the environment.
- michaelhoffman 7y agoApple argues that it's not required because you aren't required to be searched, it's only if an employee freely chooses to use the ~~~privilege~~~ of taking your personal items to work that they are searched. You can always come to work with nothing and not be searched. I think this argument is BS and it looks like so did the California Supreme Court. Apple argues that this choice is of benefit only to the employees but without it I think they'd have a much harder time keeping employees.
- JohnFen 7y agoAs you say, Apple's argument is ludicrous on its face (as the court pointed out) because Apple also requires employees to wear special clothing at work, and are forbidden from wearing that clothing off-premises. So employees must carry that clothing to work with them. I suppose that doesn't mean that they have to put it in a container, but that's a real stretch of an argument that the court also rejected.
- sjwright 7y agoAnd that really hinges on who is responsible for laundering said uniforms. If the employee is responsible for laundering, it is ridiculous for Apple to expect employees to not bring a personal bag to work.
- EdwardDiego 7y agoI love how they call it a privilege. This is indeed a boring dystopia.
- modoc 7y agonot saying its okay, but this has been standard practice at every retail store job I ever worked (mostly 20+ years ago). You clocked out in the back, and then had to wait to be searched and released in the front of the store. This isn't Apple being weird, this is amazingly common.
- JohnFen 7y agoIt may be common, but it's obviously wrong. It's good that Apple got slapped for this. It would be even better if all other companies that do this got slapped too.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoAs long as you are required to be at work and can’t leave you should get paid. With increasing surveillance some smartasses will soon have the idea that employees shouldn’t get paid during downtime when they are waiting for customers.
- MaximumYComb 7y agoDon't give people ideas
- matz1 7y ago>How does anyone think it's acceptable to [funcitonally] detain people From the business perspective, provided they can get a way with it, it is just another business decision, namely reducing cost and increasing profit. I would do the same.
- eropple 7y agoAlternatively, you could treat people like people and give them an actual measure of respect instead of stealing time and money from them. But, frankly, literally every time without exception that I remember seeing you post, it's been a variation on the theme of "of course they shouldn't be decent, why should they, I shouldn't have to be decent either", so I'm going to pass on being surprised.
- matz1 7y ago>Alternatively, you could treat people like people and give them an actual measure of respect instead of stealing time and money from them Thats depends on what one value, if you think treat people like people is important then yes you should do it but if one value profit then doing what apple did make sense.
- angry_octet 7y agoWould you be unhappy if someone stole money from your bank account? Because you're condoning theft. It's not clever business practices, it's theft.
- phibz 7y agoClearly someone thought it was unfair enough to take Apple to court over it. Workers rights has always been a struggle but this sort of behavior has been trending up over the last 20 years. From the "permatemp" jobs to the new no benefits "gig economy" it's worrying. I'm and experienced software developer and even I have seen this sort of thing. I worked for a company out of San Jose. I was hired full-time with benefits and a bonus structure based on performance. But I had to switch to hourly at no pay if I was "on the bench" between projects. Despite a year of solid work, and receiving my performance bonus, true to the agreement when I rolled off a project they stopped paying me. I went 4 months without pay. And when they finally found a new project for me to join I had to take a significant pay cut because the rate for the new client was less. Passing on risk and consequence to the employee seems to be increasingly common.
- sjwright 7y ago> I went 4 months without pay. Were you still expected to show up anywhere or perform any duties? How was the situation any different to being unemployed?
- tbyehl 7y agoTraditionally, "on the bench" meant getting paid between engagements. A similar type of wage abuse in call centers: The wage is $X/hr while on a call or available in the phone queue, and minimum wage at all other times.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoHourly at "No Pay" how exactly does that work. Presumably now any noncompete(etc) are void as your employer has frustrated they contract