3 ms·
If you're going to Google "Melinda Shore abuse of process" you'll have more fun reading about rehired (the "visibility" proposal for TLS 1.3 from Nalini's lot)
by tialaramex 7y ago
If you're going to Google "Melinda Shore abuse of process" you'll have more fun reading about rehired (the "visibility" proposal for TLS 1.3 from Nalini's lot) for which Melinda suggested that a proposed way of disposing of rehired was an abuse of process (others had proposed, perhaps not entirely seriously that since its authors and supporters had no intention of actually showing up to justify it, the in-person meeting should conclude it had consensus to reject the whole thing outright on the spot). She's technically right that time too.
Anyway I wasn't talking about Melinda, who as a co-author would be in your terminology one of the proponents that you think she's directing that message at, I was talking about Kathleen Moriarty at IETF 103.
The chair's choice of phrasing "This was not our finest hour" undersells it somewhat.
- tptacek 7y agoI don't know what Google search you're talking about, nor did I know who Melinda Shore was before reading these messages. What I did was go to the tls-wg mailing list archive, search for "dnssec-chain", and read every message on the list. I'm comfortable saying you've misrepresented the discussion. It was just funny to roll across messages about "abuse of process" saying the exact opposite of what you're saying here. Links to your messages are welcome.