8 ms·
Fedora Muscian's Guide
- ptah 7y ago>https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/Fedora/18/html/Musicians_Guide/sect-Musicians_Guide-USB_Sound_Cards.html https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/Fedora/18/html/Musician... this is completely wrong. internal audio interfaces tend to be worse than external audio interfaces. what internal soundcard can compete with a universal audio apollo?
- C1sc0cat 7y agoExactly the average internal sound card is normally the cheapest part you can get away with and wont have AISO drivers It wont also have proper Line and Instrument just a 3.5 jack if your lucky and a combo jack in a lot of cases
- johnr2 7y ago>this is completely wrong. internal audio interfaces tend to be worse than external audio interfaces. what internal soundcard can compete with a universal audio apollo? Audio engineer here. It isn't wrong. PCI and PCIe cards with external AD/DA converters have better performance, reliability and higher channel counts. Eg.: https://www.rme-audio.de/hdspe-madi.html https://www.rme-audio.de/hdspe-madi.html 64 channels in, 64 out. Works fine on Linux.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- casion 7y agoYou're confusing internal/external and USB. USB devices _do_ incur extra latency. The USB apollos do suffer from this. The firewire and thunderbolt do not. Whether a devices is internal or external is irrelevant. There are "Internal" devices that are PCI based which have excellent performance, and external devices that are Thunderbolt based with equal (and better!) performance characteristics. I believe you're talking about onboard sound, not "internal", in which case you're correct. However, that's not what the link is talking about.
- smcphile 7y agoBe warned that this guide was written in 2013 for Fedora 18. A few months back, I tried using this guide with Fedora 31 and I found things have evolved since the guide was written. For example, I gave up on installing the Planet CCRMA packages separately and just used the Fedora repository version. For some programs, in order to get a recent version, I installed from source code. Etc. Also, there is currently no Fedora Jam Audio spin, so be prepared to fiddle around a bit if you want to use Fedora for music.
- nightfly 7y agoCan someone please fix the typo in the title?
- montalbano 7y agoMusic production software is the only thing keeping me from going 100% Linux. Unfortunately this guide doesn't help me much with the key issues I don't know any production-grade sound cards that have Linux drivers (my RME ADI-2 Pro certainly doesn't) and the DAW that I use (Reaper) only has experimental Linux support. I would guess the Linux compatibility of other DAWs is worse. Audacity can only get you so far. I would guess many of the audio plug-ins I rely on within Reaper would also have issues running on Linux.
- johnr2 7y ago> I don't know any production-grade sound cards that have Linux drivers (my RME ADI-2 Pro certainly doesn't) Most of the RME HDSP/HDSPe PCI/PCIe cards work on Linux using the ALSA snd-hdsp or snd-hdspm drivers. The ADI-2 can use the generic Linux USB audio driver AFAIK.
- montalbano 7y agoInteresting I will look into this more now. Given the other comment suggesting that Reaper is stable it looks like two of my main impediments to using Linux may be voided. Plug-in stability and cross-compatibility is my last unknown then.
- peapicker 7y agoIf you have 3rdparty professional-grade plugins from NI (Massive, FM8), Xferrecords (Serum), Fabfilter (some of their amazing data vis use win/mac native graphics libraries), Arturia, etc, then you still aren't going to be able to use Linux as they don't build plugins for that platform.
- johnr2 7y ago> you still aren't going to be able to use Linux as they don't build plugins for that platform. You can still use Linux, but you won't be able to use those plugins.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rwmj 7y agoAs a Fedora developer and amateur musician, I really couldn't recommend Fedora (or Linux in general) for music. The DAWs I've tried are terrible. They all have horrible UIs, trouble doing basic stuff and are crash-prone (hint to developers: the DAW should never ever ever crash!) My band uses free GarageBand on Mac which is not very good but night and day better than any of them I've tried. Setting up Jack instead of Pulseaudio is horrible and invasive. Routing USB midi is an exercise in command line randomness. Can we make this better? Probably. And I guess I should work on it. But right now it's not there.
- iovrthoughtthis 7y agoI mostly would agree in the past. Now that Reaper is available on Linux this has changed for me! I record on Linux all the time now. There are fewer plugins. You still have to wrestle with jack / pulse. There are other warts but it is a vast improvement. :)
- alkonaut 7y agoDo you mean that the Linux versions of DAWs are worse than their non-linux counterparts, or just that some linux-specific DAWs are worse than DAWs that are not linux specific? Because Bitwig for example is amazing, and it supports Mac/Win/Linux - but I haven't used it outside windows. I'd worry about sound drivers and plugin support (I doubt plugin makers spend a lot of time on linux GUI support) but I'd trust the core functionality to be the same across all platforms.
- acomjean 7y agoI’ve used bitwig Linux. Coming from ableton on Mac. I haven’t used it for much yet but it works quite well (pop-os). A little work to get it set up but nothing difficult.
- rwmj 7y agoThe second - I only tried free software DAWs on Linux. I've not tried proprietary DAWs on Linux, because if I'm going to do that I might as well go all-in on the Mac (not least because Macs and Windows don't have two competing sound systems that you have to switch between to use a DAW and do regular stuff like watching videos).
- emmelaich 7y agoThis is Fedora 18, which is very old .. 2013
- me551ah 7y agoMaking electronic music is so much more than just operating system support. You need a DAW and most of the ones that you get on Linux are horrible, except Bitwig. So you would be forced to use only one DAW. Most of the well known plugins like Serum, LFO Tool and Massive are not available either so you would be limited to the ones included in Bitwig or the basic VSTs that you find for Linux. And while JACK is pretty good at low latency audio you would miss out on the ASIO control panel provided by your sound card driver. While its possible to get asio working on linux using wineasio, it's a cumbersome process since you need to compile the asio dlls which have licensing restrictions. You would have a much better experience if you just install Windows on KVM and use PCI passthrough for your sound card.
- justaj 7y ago> Most of the well known plugins like Serum, LFO Tool and Massive are not available either Though everything that those VSTs can do, can also be done in Bitwig Studio starting from v3. > miss out on the ASIO control panel What does this add that the usual tools in Linux can't fix? Also, it's recommended to go with class compliant USB audio interfaces or otherwise interfaces that are supported on Linux. Going with MOTU gear for example is a bad idea.
- casion 7y ago"Can do" is not particularly useful. You "can" sit there and sequence thousands of sine waves in audacity to create any sound that you want... but nobody wants to do that. Bitwig's grid is capable, but the ease of access for particular workflows is burdensome. Replicating Serum in the grid isn't possible practically, both because of filter designs and the wavetable capabilities, and getting close requires some significant acrobatics. Massive... much easier. LFO Tool, basically impossible to replicate in Bitwig because the main draw is the _workflow_. Bitwig is a very capable, fun and useful product for electronic music creation but I think your response to the OP is correct on a very technical, and pedantic level, but extremely unhelpful regardless.
- cycloptic 7y ago
- cupantae 7y agoOk so many people are commenting that this article is out of date. I've been searching for what the best out-of-the-box music Linux distro would be, so I can dual boot that for any music work. Namely it must have: - jack set up and default for everything - complete DAW solution: synth set up etc - updated, stable software - MIDI set up fully - real time kernel is definitely a plus - acceptable performance on modest hardware A lot of the recommendations online like Musix are not current at all! I wonder if Ubuntu Studio is the answer, just purely based on the website being updated and professional-looking. I've considered KXstudio but cannot confirm that it is a distro rather than a software repo. AVLinux? Any firsthand experience? I will test Ubuntu Studio today and report back
- rudenoise 7y agoSo after trialing a few of the "audio-centric" distro-flavours I couldn't find any that were particularly compelling (most, Ubuntu Studio included, were installing huge quantities of tools that I was never likely to explore). I've ended up using Manjaro, with Jack, Reaper, Renoise, Airwindows plugins, a real-time kernel and very little else. It's pretty good. I found this guide was helpful https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Professional_audio https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Professional_audio
- jcelerier 7y agoArchLinux has a pro-audio package group which does some system setup IIRC : https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Professional_audio https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Professional_audio ; of course software is up-to-date. I know that more and more Linux audio devs are using Arch as main OS also, so things may be a bit better tested there :)
- jimbosis 7y agoKXstudio is now a software repo only for "Any Debian or Ubuntu based system, running GNU/Linux. For Debian, version 10 (Buster) is required; on Ubuntu, 18.04 (Bionic)." https://kx.studio/Repositories:FAQ https://kx.studio/Repositories:FAQ I was able to use the KXstudio repos on Devuan ASCII 2.0, if anyone is wondering about Devuan compatibility. KXstudio used to also have their own distro, based on Ubuntu, but the last release was based on Ubuntu 14.04, based on my memory and the DistroWatch page. The ISOs are still on GitHub, but, it goes without saying, are no longer supported. https://distrowatch.com/table.php?distribution=kxstudio https://distrowatch.com/table.php?distribution=kxstudio https://github.com/KXStudio/KXStudio/releases/ https://github.com/KXStudio/KXStudio/releases/
- taylodl 7y agoI'm a professional developer and amateur musician. Honestly, I believe this is a case where the "Apple tax" is well worth it. You can get far with GarageBand and where that falls short you can use Logic Pro, which for $200 is still a far sight cheaper than the other commercial DAWs. Interested in hearing other people's experiences.
- Bootwizard 7y agoI feel like the audience this article was written for would do well to try out Reaper. It's a FOSS DAW that has almost every feature you wpuld ever need, but also has a steep learning curve.
- uxp100 7y agoI don’t think reaper is open source. It is, however, pretty good, and cheap.
- squeaky-clean 7y agoReaper is neither free nor open source. Cockos (the company behind Reaper) has several open source libraries used within Reaper, but Reaper is proprietary software that costs $60 for a personal license. The developers don't believe in wasting time on anti-piracy checks, so it's very easy to use Reaper without paying. Kind of like Sublime Text. Reaper is a great DAW, and I would recommend it to everyone. Whether a beginner looking for their first DAW, or a pro with a million dollar studio. Just pointing out it's not free/foss because that's something I've seen people claim about Reaper for over a decade.
- taylodl 7y agoThanks for the feedback on Reaper
- calvinmorrison 7y agoIt's the WinRAR license
- auiya 7y ago
- LeonB 7y agoReading this i didn’t feel it was addressed to me as a musician. But as an engineer I felt it was addressed to me.
- jfengel 7y agoThat would be "Musician", not "Muscian". The actual link spells it correctly.
- AdmiralAsshat 7y agoProps to Fedora for their thorough documentation, but to a musician looking for a prospective Linux distro to serve their needs, this looks dense as all hell. I wonder if they might be better served taking a page from something like Ubuntu Studio[0], and just making a spin that tries to preconfigure all of this stuff out-of-the-box for the end-user, so that they can simply install the ISO and get going. [0] https://ubuntustudio.org/tour/audio/# https://ubuntustudio.org/tour/audio/#
- mushufasa 7y agosection on training yourself to listen https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/Fedora/18/html/Musicians_Guide/sect-Musicians_Guide-Solfege-Training.html https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/Fedora/18/html/Musician...
- cies 7y agoCheck out "Unfa" on YT, he makes vids on opensource music production. Very good quality content IMHO. He uses KXStudio iirc.
- beat 7y agoUgh. I've been using Linux since the .9 kernels/SLS distro days (1995 or so), and I've been producing albums for 13-14 years and recording longer than that, and I wouldn't even consider doing real music production in Linux. It is absolutely not worth the bullshit and the spoons. I want to be recording music, not putzing around with device drivers or scrounging for plugins that don't completely suck. I mostly use Reaper on a Mac, and pay a monthly subscription for Plugin Alliance plugins. It's well worth the money, because it works, sounds great, and is straightforward to use. Given a choice between spending two hours improving the eq/compression/reverb of a mix and two hours trying to figure out why no sound is coming out, I know which one I prefer.
- zwieback 7y agoYes, Reaper is great. I played around with various options and Reaper is the winner for me. I found a 8 channel Firewire Presonus interface in a cabinet at work and that still works great with Reaper.
- krn 7y agoIt's closed-source, but Bitwig Studio[1] is probably the best DAW that supports Linux natively since its initial release in 2014. At least for electronic music production, it's considered on a par with Ableton Live. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitwig_Studio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitwig_Studio
- deeblering4 7y agoFor me music creation is a process of capturing lightning in a bottle. When I'm ready to record something, my kit needs to work and get the idea into a track right away while I have the idea and the juices are flowing. If I have to troubleshoot or configure anything while in this mode the creative idea is lost and I get super frustrated. This is why I've shied away from linux as a music platform, setup and troubleshooting is the last thing I want to do when feeling creative, I just want to plug-in and hit record. With that said my approach is around physical instruments, maybe it's different if your studio is entirely in the box.