4 ms·
Thanks. That's all really quite educational. Does the U.S. have any social program like Canada Pension Plan where: 1. your paycheque is forcibly deducted an a
by Waterluvian 7y ago
Thanks. That's all really quite educational. Does the U.S. have any social program like Canada Pension Plan where:
1. your paycheque is forcibly deducted an amount based on a formula
2. that amount goes into CPP investment
3. when you retire you can get a monthly pension based on the total amount you paid in
To me that seems like a sane way to protect people from themselves.
- wmf 7y agoThat's called Social Security in the US but many people have additional retirement savings because it doesn't pay much.
- ficklepickle 7y agoIt is in addition to social security in Canada. We call that OAS. Social security (OAS) gets clawed back if ur over like $70k/year in retirement or so. CPP does not, IIRC.
- SQueeeeeL 7y agoWe do, but our law makers have been looting social security for decades so it's basically unrealistic to expect most people in the country to see any benefits
- lotsofpulp 7y agoHow have lawmakers been looting social security? As far as I know, taxes collected for social security are either paid out as benefits or invested by purchasing US debt. But I don't see any other option of what to do with them (keeping them as cash seems imprudent as they would just lose value due to inflation).
- turc1656 7y agoIt's a tax, so they can take part of the money and do other things with it. And they have from time to time. They are not remitting the full tax receipts to the Social Security Administration for disbursement. Which instead of having them buy US debt, actually creates the need to create more US debt because they have obligations to meet and the SSA is locked into certain debt instruments that can't be exited on large scale easily. EDIT: This is not correct. It appears they have borrowed against the SS fund using treasuries, which will have to be back. Or phrased another way - the SS system chose to invest in US debt.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoAny sources? These reports don't support your statements: https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/chartbooks/fast_facts/2019/fast_facts19.html#page35 https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/chartbooks/fast_facts/2019/f... https://www.ssa.gov/agency/performance/ https://www.ssa.gov/agency/performance/ And I don't know of a debt instrument that can be exited more easily than US Treasuries: https://www.ssa.gov/news/press/factsheets/WhatAreTheTrust.htm https://www.ssa.gov/news/press/factsheets/WhatAreTheTrust.ht... This interview with a prominent actuary who worked in the Social Security admin is also very helpful to clarify the workings of SS: https://us14.campaign-archive.com/?u=bd0d1b66f832083794c33c979&id=d540b66d82 https://us14.campaign-archive.com/?u=bd0d1b66f832083794c33c9...
- turc1656 7y agoThank you for this. It appears I was lied to. The person that told me this is not someone who usually neglects to do their research and verify things, so by extension I did not. I have edited my response above accordingly. Much appreciated.
- idoh 7y agoIt's "looting" in that from the outside looking in, when social security has a surplus, the federal government takes that money and spends it on non-related things. Internally, one part of the government is writing an IOU to another part to make it seem like the money is "invested". So from some super technical and pedantic sense, the surplus is invested, but it is only ever invested in internal IOUs from the same entity to which it belongs, it's not like social security is buying up equity or real estate for the long term.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoAre you suggesting that the US government use social security taxes to purchase equities and real estate? The purpose of the current system is to make the benefits one receives sort of proportional to the income they earn. Of course it's the government taking in money and spending it, and it's all one government if you zoom out, but it's still useful to categorize certain funds.
- idoh 7y agoWell, I could live with either taking the surplus from that specific program and investing it in the best possible way to cover for well-known coming shortfalls, or saying that it is a generic tax like any other tax. Then at least people would know where it stands. Instead we have a weird situation where the tax specifically calls out social security, but in reality gets spent on a bunch of unrelated things, with a thin veneer of technicality to make it all hold together.
- turc1656 7y agoAs others have mentioned, this is referred to as Social Security. I'm not sure how it works in Canada once it's is forcibly deducted, but in the US, it's just a tax like any other tax. The idea is that the government will honor the promises made about the schedule of payments based on a complex formula - but basically it goes by the year you were born and the amount of money you have made over time. People who make less get a larger % of their earnings back from Social Security. The higher earners make more, but there is a cap. Similar to income taxes, there are steps in which you get back varying %'s, which is why those with lower income get more as a portion of their earnings. In this way, the government simply collects money from current earners and then distributes that to the existing retirees. It's not like there is a trust set up and your money is locked away with your name on it. Canada's system may or may not be structured the same way. The idea is that if the government defaults on this, then there are much larger issues anyway. But because it's just a tax they can technically do whatever they want with the money and being the scumbags that they are, they periodically do steal from that money, which is why Social Security is underfunded. Personally, I think the payouts are even pretty respectable, despite what others might think. The average payout is currently around $1,500 per person per month. That's not a lot, but if you have a spouse that's $36,000 a year. Also, one thing that most forget is that even if your spouse doesn't work their entire life (i.e. stay at home parent), a spouse can claim an additional 50% of their spouses as their own. Every person who is married has this option - they can claim their own or the 50% of their spouses (which does not reduce their spouses, it's just on top). For anyone working, it usually makes sense to claim their own unless there is a massive difference in pay. So if one person is scheduled for 2k a month, the other is guaranteed at least 1k or their own if it's higher. Honestly, it's a nice idea and has been working reasonably well for decades. But the issue is that when you look at it with a technical eye, you'll see it's all basically the same structure as a ponzi scheme. The current people taxed don't pay for themselves, they pay for others who came before them. Over time the number of people required to pay for a single retiree has gone up. This indicates a growth requirement in the tax base. Without this constant growth which seems to go up more and more over time, the system fails. People ignore this because they think it's impossible because it's run by government. I'm not so sure that's true.
- Waterluvian 7y ago