9 ms·
I discovered the concept of pensions managed by corporations when Sears Canada went under and a ton of people lost their pensions. I guess it's a pretty common
by Waterluvian 7y ago
I discovered the concept of pensions managed by corporations when Sears Canada went under and a ton of people lost their pensions. I guess it's a pretty common thing. But it seems absolutely insane to me.
Who in their right mind, given any choice on the matter, would want to lock their retirement into the existence and health of a corporation?
Until I saw the Sears debacle occur, I thought everyone basically puts together RRSP (Canadian retirement tax havens, I think 401k?) accounts and rely on their required payments into the Canada Pension Plan. It's much less likely that the government or a bank will fail, and the bank, unlike Sears, is CDIC backed.
I guess my question is: why do we allow companies to manage retirement funds?
- smabie 7y agoPension plans don’t really make economic sense. Fortunately, private pensions will soon become a thing of the past. Of course, the only reason they ever were a thing was due to tax breaks, but that’s a different story.
- ixtli 7y agoThey don’t make economic sense when the only economic concern is to generate private wealth for the owner of the company and it shareholders at a consistent year-over-year rate. If your economic concern includes growing a middle class that is motivated to spend money and to take business risks then they make a lot of sense.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThey don't make sense because calculations for pension liabilities require knowing economic conditions decades into the future. I have yet to come across someone that prescient.
- apendleton 7y agoThis is true for any way of providing for retirement, though. Eliminating pensions just transfers the risk from companies to individuals. It's clear why companies would want this, but not clear it's societally beneficial.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe best model I've seen is to raise families that stick together, and support each other. As parents age, children and cousins support them, and they age, so on and so forth. Unfortunately, this requires a lot of compromise, and I see that once financial independence is achieved, it is difficult for families to continue this way of life. There's also other facets of modern life that may not be conducive to this lifestyle.
- ixtli 7y agogenerational wealth is how real wealth is built: nearly all riches are inherited. the main thing i have learned with age is how incredibly important having a very very strong support system is, whether thats family, friends, a club, school, spouse, children, or whatever. you can. not. survive. without this. Its disconcerting how completely i overlooked this in my youth. independence in the context you describe is not something that should be lauded in our society and specifically parents that drive their children away should, in the great majority of cases, be vilified along with the typical narrative of celebrating the child's victory at overcome adverse conditions.
- redis_mlc 7y ago> how incredibly important having a very very strong support system is Agreed. Try recovering from surgery alone sometime to find out!
- ixtli 7y agothis is a great refutation of the current status quo where people are required to plan decades into the future for their own retirements. indeed no one is capable of this.
- xxpor 7y agoThey're good for people who have trouble saving themselves, which is a huge proportion of the population. Just look at all of the people who are excited to get a huge tax refund, then immediately spend it all.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoThe unfortunate part about this is there now needs to be some relatively easy system laid out for people to plan their retirement. I don't know the exact numbers, but a quick google[1] told me 35% of American's don't have access to 401k's - it's probably those people who also need help planning to retire the most. And of those people, I'm not sure how many are actually on track to ever retire. I understand there's a general bootstrap mentality, but it's hard to see how 100,000,000 people not having retirement savings is going to work out well. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/12/how-many-americans-dont-have-access-to-a-401k.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/12/how-many-americans-dont-have...
- gizmo686 7y agoPrivate pensions don't solve this, in that they were still only available to those whose employers offered them. For the most part pensions were replaced with 401ks, so there was no significant loss of access to retirement product. To your concern about lack of access, the solution is simple: raise the cap on IRAs. This still doesn't solve the nudge problem, where people are less likely to sign up withou HR emailing an enrolment form every year. There is also probably a correlation between people without 401k access, and those who would not be reaching the current IRA cap anyway.
- ghaff 7y agoWell, there are: 1. IRAs 2. Savings that aren't tax-advantaged So it's not like not having access to 401k's keeps people from retirement savings. That said, 401k's are nice from a tax perspective and, even though they're still usually opt-in, are at least as straightforward as anything that requires affirmatively making a choice can be. But, yes, although they have downsides defined-benefit plans were effectively a form of forced savings for long-term employees in large organizations.
- roywiggins 7y agoThis risk is supposedly managed in the US by the Patient Benefit Garanty Corporation, but it may itself need a federal bail-out... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pension_Benefit_Guaranty_Corporation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pension_Benefit_Guaranty_Cor...
- turc1656 7y agoThe one thing that made them "make sense" to most people was that the average person is/was terrible at personal finance and retirement planning. The company running the pension was a way for the average person to be "guaranteed" a retirement income without having to worry about anything. Remember, corporate pensions were a big thing when the US was at it's greatest economic strength (post-WW2) and the internet with all of its modern tools to make investing much simpler for the average person didn't exist. You had to pay brokers for every single trade or someone else to advise you or you had to just buy and hold a small set of stocks for 30 years and hope those companies would still be around (a fair bet at that time). Back then companies didn't really go under like this. If anything, they got bought by a larger company and merged, but the frequency of that was nothing like today. Today, with health care costs what they are, having pensions and defined benefit plans are insane to me. It's much better for the company to say "we will match x% in a 401k". They are defining their contribution and it has a cap. If anything happens to the company, the employee's funds are safe as the money is already transferred. For the employee, it does require them to manage this money but that's far easier and cheaper today and that money doesn't require the company to be around forever. If things tank, the employee is protected.
- Waterluvian 7y agoThanks. That's all really quite educational. Does the U.S. have any social program like Canada Pension Plan where: 1. your paycheque is forcibly deducted an amount based on a formula 2. that amount goes into CPP investment 3. when you retire you can get a monthly pension based on the total amount you paid in To me that seems like a sane way to protect people from themselves.
- wmf 7y agoThat's called Social Security in the US but many people have additional retirement savings because it doesn't pay much.
- ficklepickle 7y agoIt is in addition to social security in Canada. We call that OAS. Social security (OAS) gets clawed back if ur over like $70k/year in retirement or so. CPP does not, IIRC.
- drawkbox 7y ago> I guess my question is: why do we allow companies to manage retirement funds? Additionally, why do we let employers be involved in choosing our healthcare companies and plans at all? Employer managed retirement accounts and healthcare need to go away. They just need to pay more to the employee to do those things on their own. Healthcare disconnected from the employer is pro-business and it will lead to a better consumer healthcare market with less fixed pricing, more like auto, home, life insurance which people get on their own. Imagine when you change jobs if you had to also change your home, auto and life insurance policies in addition to your health insurance policies, it is silly. Requiring companies to provide healthcare is also a competitive disadvantage globally when other countries offer it as public or private separate from the job and the businesses, who don't want to deal with it nor do they care about your health beyond your production, don't have to. Starting a business changing jobs are also more difficult with employer bound healthcare. Healthcare bound to the job is a legacy system that needs to be updated along with retirement disconnected from employers. Employers just need to pay that in salary or that goes to the employee to manage. Safety nets and public retirement systems like Social Security + Medicare make up the rest.
- frandroid 7y agoEmployees, through their unions, /demanded/ and obtained defined-benefit pension plans from large employers in the 60s and 70s. One problem, in the United States, is that Ronald Reagan passed a law that allowed companies to fall behind on their pension liabilities--i.e. shortchange their employees' pension plans. Add 20 years, and suddenly GM, among others, had a bankruptcy-inducing pension shortfall in 2008. Banks being CIDC-backed just protects the first $100K of one's holdings, so far from the full retirement savings...
- ajross 7y ago> Who in their right mind, given any choice on the matter, would want to lock their retirement into the existence and health of a corporation? When pensions were invented, there wasn't any choice. In fact modern employers in the US use almost exclusively 401k's instead, for exactly the reason you argue. But employers with pension programs that predate modern retirement regimes still have them. And they can't just "roll them all over" to employee-owned securities in any practical (or even legal!) way, there just isn't a scheme to do that. And you can't just cut them off and start using 401k's instead, because the pensions are are being funded by the contributions of the active employees! It's basically an addiction. And it's not going to be fixed absent very extensive government involvement and probably more than a few bailouts. Until then we'll suffer along and sigh when companies go under like this, leaving their pension recipients destitute.
- TuringNYC 7y ago>> Who in their right mind, given any choice on the matter, would want to lock their retirement into the existence and health of a corporation? 1. Many times the "corporation" is actually a government with the power to tax, so the benefits are very well protected -- basically citizens are on the hook to pay these benefits. In the case of small cities, bankruptcies do happen, but it would be a good bet (IMHO) to say, bet on a pension w/ the City of NY, or with the US Federal government. 2. Many pensions are guaranteed by US tax dollars: see https://www.pbgc.gov/ https://www.pbgc.gov/ 3. Traditional Pensions were defined benefit plans and very very good deals you often got cost of living adjustments, you could never deplete the funds, you got to start drawing down early and could draw down as long as you live. Modern plans are defined contribution. The only thing guaranteed is what you put in, not what you can get out. What you get out is based on luck on the market, some statistics, and some government policy (e.g., ask retirees living off interest income how live has been for the past 15yrs) Given how puny my 401k outcomes are compared to traditional pensions, it may almost make sense to roll the dice on a pension, but it is a bet on the company for sure.