3 ms·
Even defined contribution pensions [in the US apparently called "401(k)"] require that young people work so that the retired investors can take a share of that
by rwmj 7y ago
Even defined contribution pensions [in the US apparently called "401(k)"] require that young people work so that the retired investors can take a share of that productive output. It may not manifest itself directly as those pensions "imploding", but something will happen such as incredibly poor returns or low interest rate that will make them worth less than we think.
- paganel 7y agoThat has already started happening in Chile, which afaik was one of the first countries that started implementing the defined contribution system.
- tomrod 7y agoHow? I thought the money was actually banked?
- mumblemumble 7y agoIt's typically invested in securities such as the stock market. If the market value of those securities takes a nose dive, so, too, will the cash value of one's life savings. Market value is driven by supply and demand. If, for example, you get a sudden glut of people looking to sell their securities - say, because all the baby boomers start dipping into their retirement savings at about the same time - that isn't matched by a sudden glut of people looking to buy those securities, then a lot of retirees are going to suddenly discover that their life savings is basically just evaporating at the very moment when they started to rely on it. Some Gen Xers and Millennials might remember having seen a small version of this play out a decade or two ago, when everyone tried cashing out of their comic book collection at about the same time.
- barrkel 7y agoStuff pensioners need today, beyond non-depreciating physical assets, needs to be supplied out of stuff which is produced today. If the economy is growing at a faster rate than pensioners are increasing their consumption, anything they've "banked" can proportionally hold & increase its value (unless it was very poorly invested). But if pensioner consumption grows faster than the economy, then there's less stuff to go around. Either pensions are worth less, or a bigger slice of the pie goes to pensioners (e.g. propping up asset prices with cheap money) and young people are screwed over (since they don't have many assets). The weird politics we're seeing these days is driven by a mix of the latter effects, I believe, amongst other things (like loss aversion in older people with less productive capacity, and cohort effects in communication media choice leading to information bubbles).
- triceratops 7y ago> require that young people work so that the retired investors can take a share of that productive output. Higher productivity, on which all economic growth is ultimately based, requires fewer and fewer people to produce the same amount.
- rwmj 7y agoJust as well productivity gains haven't stalled then. Oh wait .. More seriously, it might happen that we get massive automation which means we no longer need humans to create the things that pensioners consume. A "care robot" (see the film "Robot and Frank") would be a game changer here. It's not clear that this is actually going to happen in the next 30 years though.