3 ms·
>"dealing with bad actors", as the author puts it, is censorship by another name. First, one must accept that bad actors exist, and that all forms of moderatio
by krapp 7y ago
>"dealing with bad actors", as the author puts it, is censorship by another name.
First, one must accept that bad actors exist, and that all forms of moderation are not merely attempts at political or cultural oppression.
Second, one must accept that all public spaces, both online and offline, enforce some degree of restriction on how one can legitimately interact with that space. I cannot, for example, walk nude in any public place, or shout obscenities at people with a megaphone without suffering both social and legal repercussions. Those repercussions are the result of society, even in the context of a "public" space, attempting to deal with a bad actor.
Online, one has the further restrictions imposed by the architecture of the software itself, beyond whatever rules are enforced by the nature and moderation of the platform. Hacker News won't let me make death threats or dox people, and the software won't let me upload pornographic images.
So, yes, dealing with bad actors is censorship. By your definition, merely requiring participants to obey the law is censorship. But "censorship" at that point becomes so abstract and general a concept that it ceases to become a threat to anyone but anarchists and bad actors, and becomes self-evidently necessary to have any kind of a civil society or constructive dialogue to everyone else.
Also, it seems weird to see an attempt at a full-throated defense of maximalist freedom of speech from someone who claims to require an NDA with a non disparagement clause for basic social interaction[0].
[0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22282579 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22282579
- sneak 7y ago> I cannot, for example, walk nude in any public place To use your example: do you think this is reasonable or just? Do you think it’s a sane thing to use force to enforce such a thing? > Also, it seems weird to see an attempt at a full-throated defense of maximalist freedom of speech from someone who claims to require an NDA with a non disparagement clause for basic social interaction If that’s what you read from that post or that comment, I have done a terrible job of communicating. You seem to have misread a discussion of social media’s corporate censorship into “full-throated defense of maximalist freedom of speech”, which it is absolutely not. If you re-read it carefully you will not find that conclusion supporter anywhere in the text—I specifically avoided it because I do not hold those views. Then, again, when you parsed the circumstances under which I formally ask people to keep my private information private: it is drastically far removed from “basic social interaction”. You seem pretty bent on fiercely mischaracterizing the things I have said or do. If you’re not actively trolling and really have sincerely read these beliefs into the words that I wrote, perhaps a third bit of my recent writing may be relevant to you: https://sneak.berlin/20191201/american-communication/ https://sneak.berlin/20191201/american-communication/ I can only tell you that your beliefs of my views, articles, and life are inaccurate and not supported by the data available. In the event you are actively trolling, well done. I slept on your comment before replying, because few things in the world make me type more fiercely than people making demonstrably false statements of fact about things I do or believe.