11 ms·
>of course they do also bin based on demand/sales, which is scummy. Why is this scummy? It's a free market and it's not a life saving drug, they can ask for wh
by ChuckNorris89 7y ago
>of course they do also bin based on demand/sales, which is scummy.
Why is this scummy? It's a free market and it's not a life saving drug, they can ask for whatever they want, nobody is forcing you to buy it.
That's like saying "Software engineers are paid according to demand/market which is scummy."
The best business strategy for companies and professionals alike is to find a niche with less competition where you are a leader(cough, monopoly, cough) and charge whatever the market will bear. If Apple/Microsoft/AMD/Intel can get away with that it means the market can bear it. The fact that you don't like it, is another issue.
- bobbob1921 7y agoi agree , you can also add vmware to this list. they ship a free (and great imo) hypervisor which has full features built in, with only a license key unlocking those advanced (and expensive) features. this also applies to almost every piece of demoware software.
- zozbot234 7y agoBecause it's price gouging. They would be actively restricting supply of their highest-performing parts for no other reason than to charge a higher price for them. Software engineers don't do this, they're highly paid because demand is so huge that it outstrips even an ample supply. Of course, in practice, it can be hard to tell whether intentional "crippling" is going on. Yield problems are common and might manifest in the exact same way, after all - for example, chips that don't "make timing" for their design frequency can be sold for lower specs.
- ajross 7y ago> Because it's price gouging. No, it's deliberate discounting of economy products! What's the difference? I don't know either. Price discrimination is a very real thing that exists virtually everywhere. It's why the market will bear Beats headphones in the same shops that sell generics at 20% the price. At the end of the day, a manufacturer doesn't "owe" you something at cost. The idea of capitalism is that competition in the market will drive prices down instead, and it does. But one side effect is that customers and sub-markets that are able to bear higher markups on their versions of stuff are asked to pay it even when it doesn't make sense at the level of per-part costs. So it's true, that that Beats headset costs only $4 to make and "should" be available much cheaper than it is. But it isn't, and the reason is simply that people are willing to buy them at $200. If you're not, that seems unfair, I agree. But... what's the alternative?
- zozbot234 7y ago> it's deliberate discounting of economy products That's a very nice way and non-scummy way of putting it, yes. If that deep discount compared to the "full-featured" price was made clearer, I assume that many people would not even find it scummy that these discounts are conditioned to being sold a "crippled" version of the product. So, depending on the "framing" you pur on this, you can nicely account for either of these perspectives.
- ajross 7y agoThe important point was the economics in the later stuff. Price discrimination isn't about "framing", it's just the way competition works in the case of multiple submarkets needing similar products but having different price tolerances. You can't "fix" this with framing or spin, it's just the way markets work.
- leetcrew 7y agoI'm not really sure what you want them to do in their marketing materials. it's not like Intel keeps it a secret that the hedt parts are just xeons with higher boost clocks and ecc disabled. the general public doesn't even understand what ecc is, nor are they considering buying a $1000+ cpu. I doubt most people even understand hyperthreading (the main difference between i7 and i5).
- aikinai 7y agoThis is a ridiculous statement. Tons of software is sold with more expensive versions unlocking more advanced features.
- leetcrew 7y ago"price gouging" is a myopic view of what goes on in the CPU/GPU market. intel/amd could not afford to sell hardware at consumer prices if buyers could turn around and put those consumer parts in servers at scale. in the alternate universe where certain features aren't disabled for consumer parts, your i7 costs as much a a xeon; you don't get xeon features for i7 money.
- zozbot234 7y agoYes, as someone has said elsewhere, they might essentially be selling you their chips at a deep "discount", while making that discount conditional on forgoing some desirable features. It's pretty much the same thing, just with a different framing placed on it.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoMarket segmentation is what allows you to have cheap things. Next time you walk through first class to your coach seat remember that those people are subsidizing you.
- brokenmachine 7y agoI think it's flawed logic to say that first class is subsidizing coach. Sure, they are paying more per person. But in exchange they are getting more room, more attention from attendants, boarding first, etc. If the plane was completely full of people in coach and had no first class at all, I don't think that means the airlines would lose money. Also, if there were no people in coach, then the first class tickets would be astronomical.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoOne of the reasons that free market capitalism enjoys wide support in the western world is because of the "consumer surplus". That is because for the vast majority of transactions, there is a very large gap between the highest price a consumer is willing to pay and the lowest price a producer is willing to accept. The canonical example is for essentials like food: people are willing to pay every single penny they have for food for their family. OTOH, farmers are willing to sell wheat in bulk for under 10 cents a pound. For obvious reasons farmers cannot set different prices for each pound of wheat to get "all the money". It's seen as deeply unfair when the vast majority of industries are price takers while a select few can charge the maximum a customer can bear. If every industry could effectively price differentiate could we'd be spending all our money on food with no money left to buy CPU's and our whole free market system would collapse.
- brokenmachine 7y agoNot sure I'm getting all the subtleties of your argument but for food, say for example suddenly they charged 100x the price for wheat, people would switch to something different. Of course people need food, but there are many kinds of food and it's competitive between the different foods. Lifesaving drugs are something where it's often difficult to substitute.
- maccard 7y ago> Why is this scummy? It's a free market and it's not a life saving drug, they can ask for whatever they want, nobody is forcing you to buy it. That's pretty much the only argument _for_ doing it; it's the equivalent of defending your argument as free speech - just because you _can_ say it, doesn't mean you should.
- brippalcharrid 7y agoBut even if it were a life-saving drug, would it exist at that point in time (rather than a few decades later) if billions of dollars hadn't been spent to bring it to market (instead of investing the money in any one of a number of other things, including non-pharmaceutical healthcare research), and would that money have been invested in the first place if there hadn't been an expectation of a return on investment that took into account the risk of failure?